Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

5 influencer marketing trends & what they mean for marketers in 2024

We used our platform to compare influencer statistics over the past two years. Here are five trends/stats we’ve pulled, along with an analysis of what these numbers are actually telling us. 

Woman recording a video

[Images: Artem Varnitsin / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Dave Dickman

BY Dave Dickman

When it comes to building an influencer marketing strategy, data is only half of the puzzle. The other half is critical thinking. It’s not enough to know what the numbers are; you must also think about the why—what outside factors could contribute and what other stats correlate with this one? Only then can you move on to constructing informed solutions for your marketing goals.

At Tagger by Sprout Social, we track millions of data points to build comprehensive reports that help our clients make an informed strategy. For this article, we used our platform to compare influencer statistics over the past two years, specifically measuring influencers and content using paid or sponsored hashtags. The data referenced in this article was collected via Tagger’s social intelligence engine, Signals. It compared all 2023 posts from influencers globally across social platforms featuring #ad to those from 2022. It includes data specific to posts from over 350K influencers.

Here are five trends/stats we’ve pulled, along with an analysis of what these numbers are actually telling us. 

1. INCREASES AND DECREASES AREN’T ALL GOOD OR BAD

Humans like to put things in boxes to help us understand the world, but oftentimes, things aren’t that simple. We tend to view rises and falls as good or bad, depending on their measurements. For instance, an uptick in platform users would generally be seen as a positive, while a decrease in engagement would be seen as a negative. But that’s exactly what happened with TikTok.

In 2022, around 134K creators used #paid or #sponsored in their content tags. The average engagement rate for this tagged content was 3.15%. For 2023, the number of TikTok creators using these hashtags jumped to 147K. At the same time, the engagement rate for this content dropped to 1.48%. TikTok is still the most engaging platform, but this is a considerable change from a year ago. So, what happened?

The likely answer for TikTok’s engagement drop is that paid content isn’t doing too well. Businesses that saw TikTok’s engagement last year started putting more money into the platform. This increases the number of content creators who want to capitalize on the trend, creating an influx of paid content. Any time there is too much of something, audiences begin to lose interest. 

2. INCREASED COMPETITION IMPACTS ENGAGEMENT AND VISIBILITY

In influencer marketing, it’s a general rule that smaller creators have better engagement rates. Sure, more people will see your content if you partner with a big creator, but the followers of smaller creators are more likely to take the time to interact with it. Smaller influencers also cost less than large creators and can hold more influence over their followers.

From 2022 to 2023, there was an upward shift in creator sizes, with creators who have followings of 25K or more seeing an increase in the use of paid hashtags, while nano and micro-influencers saw a decrease in paid hashtag use. Engagement rates decreased across all creator categories, with a significant drop in mid-size creator engagement. However, nano and micro-influencers still maintain significantly higher engagement rates than larger influencers.

Once again, decreasing engagement does not point to failing efforts but an increase in competition. If businesses are sinking more money into influence strategy (and they are), more creators will get sponsorships. However, an increase in content creation from larger creators can make it more difficult for smaller creators to gain visibility. This can explain the decrease in smaller creator engagement as well. But note that nano creators maintain a reliably higher engagement rate despite drops.

3. TOO MUCH CONTENT CAN BE A BAD THING

Trends have always been part of business, but social media has made it easier to track what‘s hot and what’s not. Still, it’s important to remember that trends are never guaranteed and can change as quickly as the tides, so keeping a constant watch is crucial.

For example, technology influencers had the highest post volume by category last year, with around 179K paid posts. However, this year, the number of posts dropped significantly, down to 46.4K. At the same time, engagement rose.

There are several factors to consider here, the first being product releases. A new iPhone or Google Pixel will surely increase paid content in the tech space. Late 2022 also saw the release of chatGPT and other generative AI programs. While there was definitely audience interest in these subjects, too much content in the same space leads to oversaturation and declining engagement rates.

4. NEVER UNDERESTIMATE THE POWER OF VISUALS

Social media is very visual. The influencer categories with the highest engagement rates always have a visual element, even if the category is not inherently related to visuals. An excellent example is influencers in the outdoor activity category, which has the potential for a lot of visual appeal. For two years, influencers in this category have maintained significant engagement rates while other categories, including big ones like beauty and fashion, have experienced ups and downs.

While influencers should always be relevant to your brand and target audience, considering how visual their content is can add another dynamic to experiment with regarding campaign content.

5. NIL GIVES RISE TO NEW INFLUENCER OPPORTUNITIES 

Name, image, and likeness (NIL) are still very new concepts in the influence world, but the numbers have been positive. College athletes have ranked in the top five categories with the highest engagement for two years in a row.

College athletes offer some unique traits as potential influencer partners. As younger people, they are more familiar with and engaged on social media, and more likely to interact with followers. They inherit a built-in fanbase from the university team they play for, which can be massive at larger schools. The common interests of their team also give them a boost, with consumers who might not be familiar with them but are fans of their school. This broad school appeal can also be leveraged to pursue non-team-related partnerships.

ALWAYS REMEMBER THE WHY

Data is helpful when it comes to informing strategy and the state of industries, but it goes hand in hand with critical thinking. It is worth remembering that data changes often result from smaller factors rather than one big one. 


Dave Dickman is the former CEO of Tagger by Sprout Social.