Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

6 key ways to building and nurturing a strong customer success strategy

Here are six keys to building and nurturing a strong customer success team.

[Images: Damir Khabirov / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Toni Ann Careccio

Chief Customer Officer and Board Member · PortPro Technologies, Inc.

Let’s face it, running a lean business is tough. For many businesses, operating lean translates to budget cuts across the board and a “hold” on major investments. That’s why it’s more important than ever to invest in building and maintaining loyal customer relationships.

We all know that keeping a customer is less expensive than acquiring a new one. It could also be more profitable. According to McKinsey & Company, 80% of value creation comes from core business, which is mainly generating new business from existing customers. Satisfied customers are 20-30% more likely to renew.

McKinsey also advises that you measure customer satisfaction through the net promoter score (NPS). I love hearing this because I’m a huge fan of Fred Reichheld’s “The Loyalty Effect,” the customer retention “bible” and the origin of the NPS. In his research, Reichheld showed that raising customer retention rates by just 5% increased profits by 25% to 95%.

Leaders who recognize this often have formal customer success teams in place. At my company, PortPro, we built customer success into the backbone of our business model. Based on our experience, here are six keys to building and nurturing a strong customer success team.

1. BECOME AN EXPERT AT WHAT YOU DO

Your strongest customer success managers (CSMs) should also be among your most expert product users. For example, before one of our CSMs ever speaks with a customer, we train them to become expert users on our software. It’s more efficient because CSMs can confidently make recommendations without escalating a problem to subject matter experts, who are busy with their own deliverables. It also builds trust with the customer, who expects simple guidance on how to optimally use our system.

2. CREATE A SUCCESS MATRIX CORE

Identify what success will look like for your customer and benchmark this score. The KPIs for this score vary by industry. For example, Salesforce uses a combination of product adoption, customer expertise, and technical expertise to calculate its success score with each customer. You can also lean on customer success software and tools to help you calculate these scores and measure the “health” of your customers.

Benchmarking should take place first in the sales phase and then continue throughout the lifecycle of your relationship. Why? Say your customer invested in your product to increase their efficiency. Sales should help emphasize this pain by identifying a benchmark of time spent prior to using your product. Then, when it comes time to measure impact six months or a year down the road, the customer success manager has a baseline for comparison. 

3. LISTEN, SHARE, AND ASK FOR CUSTOMER FEEDBACK

Listen to what your customers really need and use that information to boost value by showing support where they want it. For example, if you notice an uptick in help requests after new product releases, then consider coordinating customer-only webinars with each release to allow them to surface questions.

If customers aren’t sure what they need, then simply start a conversation with, “How are we doing? Is there anything I can be doing better to assist you and make you even happier with us?”

Listening to challenges and goals allows your team to more appropriately provide recommendations to overcome those challenges and achieve those goals. Customer success team collaboration is key. CSMs need a channel to surface and identify common issues, whether it’s in a Slack channel or customer service software.

4. ESTABLISH YOUR FOLLOW-UP: YOUR WORD IS YOUR BOND! 

Nobody likes to be dropped off in the wilderness with no map and no destination. Sometimes that’s what customers feel like if there’s no plan for what’s next. Set expectations for the full lifecycle and each upcoming touchpoint. 

When you make recommendations, follow up to check how they work. Establish a regular meeting cadence (i.e., monthly, quarterly, etc.) to update measurement benchmarks. If they’re below expectations, be proactive and make recommendations to raise them. Remember, all things being equal between you and your closest competitor (from your customer’s perspective), the customer will choose who makes them feel the most visible and important. 

5. CREATE A STRUCTURED PROCESS 

A structured process drives consistency for the customer experience from the first touchpoint. It includes the aforementioned regular meeting cadence, but also:

  • Chart out your organization’s accountability for the customer at every significant touchpoint, from the time they enter your funnel as a qualified lead to when they emerge on social media as an evangelist for your brand.
  • Document the “hand-off process” from cross-functional teams (e.g., when does customer success take over from sales or onboarding? What does that handoff look like?).
  • Assemble cross-functional teams (e.g., sales, solutions engineering, and account management) for key stakeholder meetings such as demos, training sessions, and renewals.

To add a personal touch, sprinkle in additional calls and support to check in on progress or follow up on recommendations. Organize your notes regarding your calls and meetings, and share them with the customer to clarify action items and future agendas.

6. BRING VALUE TO YOUR “A” GAME 

The stronger the relationship a customer feels they have with you, the greater the value they perceive from your product. Even if you’re under pressure to run lean, there are a lot of customer-support strategies you can implement to help keep competitors at bay:

  • Build a sense of community. Not just with your organization and product, but with other customers. Recognize top-tier customers by sharing their expertise and best practices. 
  • Invite customers to monthly new feature webinars. If any customers were involved in the beta release, consider including them in the presentation.
  • Send a monthly customer-specific newsletter.
  • Schedule customer-only appreciation dinners and parties at industry events.
  • Develop training and best practices content with evolving customer needs in mind. What will help them do their job better? 

CUSTOMER SUCCESS IS EVERYONE’S RESPONSIBILITY

The customer success team is the tip of the spear. Every team contributes, from the C-level to sales, and from product development to marketing. Take a customer-centric approach, and the profit should follow.