Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

A call for an employer-employee collaborative approach to open enrollment in 2025

It's time to see open enrollment as one of the most critical opportunities for employees to secure what they need and for employers to communicate their support.

A call for an employer-employee

[Andrey Popov / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Julie Turpin

Chief People Officer & Executive Vice President · Brown & Brown (Brown & Brown, Inc. – NYSE:BRO)

It’s time we stopped thinking about open enrollment as just another box to check and instead saw it as one of the most critical opportunities for employees to secure what they need and for employers to communicate their support effectively.

While it’s unpleasant to think about, preparing for a personal crisis is one of the most important considerations for employers and employees. Consider the following scenarios:

• A teammate tragically passes away after being hit by a car while walking home. Their life insurance policy eases the family’s financial burden, providing support during their grieving period.

• A teammate loses a family member to suicide. The company’s mental health services offer vital support to the surviving family.

These stories remind us that benefits, even in less dire situations, are there to protect the well-being of our people and their families.

Despite this truth, open enrollment is often viewed as a tedious task during a busy end-of-year season, and its potential impact is easily lost. To shift away from this “transactional benefits” mindset, employers and employees can work together to make it a meaningful, collaborative process.

For employers, this is an opportunity to demonstrate their commitment to employee well-being, reinforcing the promises of their employer brand. By providing clear communication, accessible tools, and personalized support, they can ensure employees are confident in how their decisions impact their future.

In return, employees can take an active role in evaluating their options, aligning their choices with their needs and values, and taking full advantage of their employer’s support. When approached as a partnership, open enrollment becomes not just a formality but a shared investment in the future success and well-being of both the individual and the organization.

FOR EMPLOYEES: HOW TO TAKE FULL ADVANTAGE OF BENEFIT OFFERINGS

It’s easy to fall into the trap of repeating what you did last year—Why bother reviewing all the options when you can just click the same boxes? Autopilot thinking can lead to missed opportunities and coverage gaps that don’t meet your current needs. Major life events like marriage or childbirth and shifts in health needs should influence your approach to open enrollment.

This year, commit to reviewing everything with fresh eyes. You can do this in these ways:

1. Look beyond your impact. Open enrollment is the time to take stock of how your benefits can serve your needs and those of your loved ones.Consider how your choices can impact your family’s well-being, and do your due diligence to understand their needs. Consider asking trusted friends what benefits they lean on for their families, or ask your child’s doctor about next year’s health expectations.

2. Be present. You’re busy, and it’s easy to gloss over the emails, updates, and meeting invites you receive from your employer, but during open enrollment, it’s crucial to stay engaged. Attend informational sessions, read the benefits guides, and really understand how the new or updated offerings can apply to you.

Ultimately, the best way to navigate open enrollment and maximize your benefits package is by approaching it with a mindset of education over convenience. If you don’t take the time to fully understand what’s available, you may find yourself missing out on significant benefits or paying for options you don’t need or won’t use.

FOR EMPLOYERS: HOW TO MAXIMIZE ENGAGEMENT DURING OPEN ENROLLMENT

Instead of using the same rollout format as last year, use open enrollment as an opportunity to show how much your company values its employees. Here are three ways employers can better engage employees during this period.

1. Align your offerings with your employer promise. You lose credibility if there’s a disconnect between what your company claims to value and what your benefits package provides. Employees need to see that you’re putting your money where your mouth is. For example, if you claim to prioritize mental health, but your offerings in this area are lacking, it’s time to close that gap. Conduct a thorough review of your offerings to ensure they reflect your company’s values, understanding that alignment takes time, but committing to assess and close gaps annually shows ongoing progress.

2. Tell a compelling benefits story. A dry list of benefits doesn’t engage anyone. Instead, try telling a compelling story. Use realistic scenarios or employee testimonials to show how these benefits have made a tangible difference in people’s lives.

3. Bring something new to the table. As benefits evolve, companies offering unique support will build stronger communities over time. Whether launching pilot programs on new offerings or leaning into artificial intelligence (AI) to provide 24/7 access to benefit support, enhancing the experience of a traditionally mundane process will make a difference.

Open enrollment is one of those things that’s easy to overlook. When companies take the time to offer real support and employees actively engage with what’s available, we shift from just ticking boxes to preparing for whatever life throws our way.