Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

A finance guy’s case for rethinking process

Old controls exist for a reason but the best leaders question them, keep the purpose, and rebuild the process with modern technology.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Erik Clarke

Chief Financial Officer · Trans Lease, Inc

I am, by training and profession, a finance guy. I gravitate to controls, disciplined processes, measurable outcomes, and decision-making centered on numbers. I also like contemporary art, especially work that takes familiar materials or ideas and uses them in an unexpected way.

Those interests may seem unrelated, but I increasingly think good management sits at the intersection of art and science. Stick with me on this one.

Running a business requires science. Financial information must be reliable, risks must be controlled, and processes need to produce consistent outcomes. Improving a business, however, requires creativity, too. Leaders must be willing to examine something that has worked for years and ask whether the same objective could now be achieved in a fundamentally better way.

That is why when someone says, “that’s how we’ve always done it,” the process deserves more scrutiny than it usually receives. The problem is not that old processes are inherently bad; although sometimes they are. Sometimes clunky processes were created for rational reasons, like when a critical error leads to a new control. The danger is that the circumstances of that error may change, but the clunky process remains in place.

Businesses outgrow processes

I saw this repeatedly during my years in management consulting. While working on major transformations in the banking, tech, and fintech worlds, I saw companies reach points where the processes that supported an earlier stage of growth no longer matched the scale or complexity of the business.

For example, I worked on one of the most significant IPOs of the 2021 cycle. Preparing for public ownership required stronger financial reporting, forecasting, governance, technology, and controls, but it also required reconsidering practices designed for a smaller, less complex organization. The objective was to understand why older controls existed and determine whether there was a better way to accomplish the same purpose.

I encounter the same challenge in executive leadership today, particularly around legacy technology. Older systems create accommodations around their limitations. Employees transfer information manually because systems cannot communicate, maintain separate spreadsheets because the core platform isn’t reliable, or establish workarounds due to system limitations. Over time, those accommodations create inefficiencies that harm the business.

This is also where many technology transformations go wrong. A company buys a modern system and then tries to recreate every step of the workflow built around the old one. That is the managerial equivalent of handing Picasso a coloring book. You end up with a better system but you force it to interact with dated processes.

Preserve purpose, not processes

The better approach is to consider historical context but not let it rule the new operating model. If a process requires three approvals, leadership should understand why. The approval controls may be designed to mitigate fraud, prevent costly errors, or maintain segregation of duties. However, modern systems may offer automated authorization thresholds, role-based access, exception reporting, embedded controls, or real-time monitoring that addresses the same risks more efficiently. Institutional knowledge becomes harmful when staff refuse to accept the newer, better controls and defaults to the older model of manual reviews.

Organizations are naturally good at adding controls, reports, approvals, and bureaucracy, but much less disciplined about revisiting them after technology or business conditions change. Over time, individually rational decisions can produce an operating model that costs too much time and effort.

Executives can challenge the norm by asking what problem the process was designed to solve, whether the problem still exists, what principle or control must be preserved, and, whether process would be built the same way using the technology currently available?

Where art meets science

That final question is where art meets science. The science part defines the outcome and the tools we have at our disposal to achieve that outcome. The art is the creativity that allows us to reconsider how we get there.

Good process design embraces both discipline and innovation. The most effective organizations preserve the lessons embedded in their history without becoming captive to the historical solutions that were created to address their problems. They use technology to make old processes more efficient and effective.

“That’s how we’ve always done it,” should not end the discussion. It should begin an investigation into how to do things better.

Erik Clarke is CFO of Trans Lease Inc.