Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

A new approach to incident responses

Why teams collapse under pressure during a security incident.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Ken Grohe

President, LeverageGTM, Inc.

Most security leaders believe their teams understand how incident response should work. Procedures are documented. Roles are defined. Analysts are experienced. Playbooks exist for common scenarios. On paper, the organization looks prepared.

But real incidents do not test knowledge. They test execution under pressure.

Cytactic’s 2025 State of Cybersecurity Incident Response Management (CIRM) Report makes this gap clear. Of the 480 senior U.S. cybersecurity executives polled, 97% recognized the critical role technology plays in managing incidents, yet 80% admitted their teams lack sufficient practice running real scenarios.

This gap between awareness and rehearsal is where response begins to break down.

Why documentation doesn’t translate into performance

Documentation creates confidence, providing the sense that a plan exists for when something goes wrong. But documentation is static, and incidents are dynamic.

When teams encounter unfamiliar combinations of technical, legal, and operational challenges, they don’t pull out a document and calmly follow it step by step. They fall back on instinct as they have done in previous Fortune 500 issues, such as the 2020 Solar Winds attack. Without rehearsal, instinct often leads to hesitation, misalignment, and over-cautious decision-making.

This is reinforced by our report’s finding that 57% of leaders said their last major incident involved a scenario they had never rehearsed.

When teams are outside familiar territory, knowledge alone is not enough.

The cross-functional challenge

This challenge becomes more pronounced when multiple teams must operate together. Security teams may know exactly what needs to happen technically, but legal, communications, IT, and executives could be experiencing the situation for the first time in a live environment.

This is why 80% of leaders say cross-functional simulation exercises improved their peers’ understanding of their roles during incidents.

Simulation isn’t about teaching security how to respond, but teaching the entire organization how to operate together when conditions are uncertain.

The false confidence of past experience

Many organizations assume that past incidents prepare teams for future ones. But no two incidents are the same. One incident may be due to a supplier breach; another may be due to a disgruntled employee. The technologies involved change. The regulatory environment evolves. The business impact varies.

Our report highlights that 41% of leaders said their last incident made them realize they were “not nearly ready,” despite having plans and prior experience.

Why leaders are turning to simulation

Perhaps the most telling statistic in our report is that 95% of organizations plan to invest in AI-supported simulation exercises in the next year, starting with agentic enablement.

This signals a recognition that incident response maturity is no longer about adding tools. It is about rehearsing how people and tools operate together under pressure. Organizations are realizing that readiness is not theoretical. It must be practiced repeatedly in realistic scenarios.

Teams that rehearse together:

  • Build familiarity with unfamiliar situations.
  • Learn how legal and communications interact with security in real time.
  • Executives experience the required pace of decision-making.
  • IT understands how recovery timelines intersect with containment steps.

Rehearsal reduces hesitation when teams encounter something they’ve never experienced before. It also exposes gaps in plans before a real incident reveals them, and improves how quickly teams align. When teams practice together, they spend less time explaining and more time acting. They understand each other’s needs and expectations.

This directly addresses the report’s broader findings that decision delays and cross-team misalignment are major bottlenecks during incidents.

The connection to CIRM

Cybersecurity Incident Response Management (CIRM) is a Gartner-defined category of security tools that emphasizes continuous readiness and simulation. Managing an incident is a dynamic skill that depends on how well the organization can adapt in real time. Simulation becomes the mechanism that turns theoretical plans into operational confidence.

Most teams don’t fail during incidents because they don’t know what to do. They fail because they’ve never practiced doing it together under pressure. Playbooks create awareness, but simulation creates readiness.

Ken Grohe is the president of LeverageGTM, Inc.