Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

A revised roadmap for value-based mental health care

Value-based mental health care requires building better roads: clearer pathways to care, stronger quality signals, and smarter routing across patient needs.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Sandeep Acharya

CEO & Founder · Octave

As a teenager with a new driver’s license, I dreaded driving with my father. The imaginary brakes from the passenger seat and the white-knuckled grip on the door handle made me more anxious, not more skilled.

At the risk of sounding like a backseat driver, after 15 years working with health plans, I see the same pattern in mental health care. We talk endlessly about improving the driver—through new incentives and payment models—but rarely about improving the road. Without better roads, even the best drivers struggle to get to their destination.

There is a better path forward: a roadmap for value-based care in mental health grounded in a simple idea: that value comes from getting the right level of care to the right person at the right moment in their journey. In practice, that requires a sequence of capabilities that build on one another. There are four, and they work best in the order they appear.

1. Functional digital front door

In conversations with payor teams, I’m struck by how often responsibility for behavioral health directories sits far from the clinicians and operators who understand care most deeply. That disconnect matters. Unlike many other medical specialties, about 40% of behavioral health patients begin their search for care inside their payor’s directory.

When those members encounter long, static lists with little clarity about who is available, appropriate, or in-network, they don’t persist. They turn to Google, social media, or paid marketplaces to find care elsewhere.

A static directory is not navigation. It is the difference between driving with Google Maps and following a MapQuest printout. One updates in real time. The other assumes nothing has changed.

Patient satisfaction rises when members can find and book with a provider through their plan. Providers benefit too. Despite widespread perceptions of provider shortages, most payor networks include thousands of clinicians who can take on additional appropriate patients.

By reducing search costs for patients and providers, payors can do more than improve experience. They can counter unit cost inflation without reducing provider income. More importantly, they reclaim a degree of influence over how care is delivered. A digital front door is not just an access tool. It is a control point that makes the rest of value-based care possible.

2. Quality as the basis for tiering

Five years of claims data show enormous practice variation between providers, and large differences in effectiveness that cannot be explained by patient demographics alone. These differentials contribute not only to poor outcomes and high churn out of care, but also to substantial wasted spend on unnecessary or misaligned care.

Patients have almost no visibility into these differences. We ask patients to choose a therapist the way someone might choose a highway exit in the dark—without signs, lighting, or support.

In fact, the signals they rely on most, such as reviews, are often misleading. Reviews tend to reward friendliness but do little to penalize unsound clinical practices. When we compared patient ratings of providers with independent assessments of those same providers against practice guidelines, we found no correlation.

Patients aren’t going to wade through massive datasets to find higher-quality care. That creates an opportunity—and a responsibility—for payors. By using their unique vantage point across networks, payors can give members a better chance of good outcomes by prioritizing providers who route patients to appropriate care, tiering out extreme underperformers, and making specific areas of clinical expertise transparent rather than generic.

3. Escalation ramps for more acute needs

Sometimes patients fall into what might be called supportive stagnation. They are making little progress because their needs exceed what a practitioner can address. Other times, patients may require specialized care immediately, even if that need is not obvious at first glance.

While it’s tempting to optimize front doors for maximum ease, the best systems deliberately use some friction to identify patients who require specialized attention. Value is not created by making every pathway equally smooth, but by routing patients toward the level of care that fits their needs.

There was a time when high-value mental health care required a one-stop shop. After billions invested, the limits of that model are clear. Today, deep expertise is distributed across many organizations. At scale, the opportunity lies in coordinating specialists who each do one thing well.

Getting more value out of mental health care has increasingly been conflated with changing incentives. Incentives don’t fix broken infrastructure. Better roads make better drivers. And from the backseat, that is where the real work still lies.

4. Clear off-ramps for sub-clinical care

An uncomfortable truth is that a subset of patients, either initially or over time, no longer meet a threshold of clinical severity that warrants ongoing treatment. This creates a challenge: by the time symptoms improve, enough rapport has often been established that patients—and sometimes providers—are reluctant to end the relationship.

One of AI’s most promising applications in healthcare is providing support when a patient no longer requires clinical intervention. Thoughtful payors have begun experimenting in this space, and the long-term value potential is real. Sub-clinical support cannot and should not replace sound clinical care. With clear guardrails and deliberate handoffs, it can reinforce, not undermine it.

In mental health, we have spent years adjusting mirrors and seats—revising reimbursement formulas and layering on complexity—while leaving the underlying infrastructure unchanged.

If payors focus first on building what the system lacks—a functional front door, transparent quality signals, deliberate escalation pathways, and responsible off-ramps—value-based care becomes more than a contracting strategy. It becomes a delivery strategy.

From the backseat, the direction seems clear. Another payment model will not unlock the future of value-based mental health care. It will be built by designing better roads—and then giving patients and providers the tools to travel them well.

Sandeep Acharya is the founder and CEO of Octave.