Public relations folks have long been the intermediary between executives and the media. We find opportunities, relay them to the client, draft or secure the executive’s commentary, get it approved, and send it back to the reporter. For decades, communications has built executive visibility through third-party validation in the media.
That role and process might be changing.
In recent weeks, several journalists and publications have said they now require direct contact with a source before they’ll publish on their behalf. Here’s why that’s happening.
The shape of the problem
AI has made it easy to create a fake expert or generate quotes for PR, media, and websites. The culprits are often sites trying to churn out content linking back to their site for clicks.
Over the past two years, reports have exposed that journalists have allegedly fallen for AI-generated quotes from fictitious experts, fake publicists who spam them, and possibly AI-agent-fabricated quotes attributed to sources who never said them.
Some experts have described being used as hallucinated sources and quotes. And journalists have even reportedly been impersonated to snag a byline.
This ecosystem of bad actors and AI has taken away the easy, low-friction version of a PR person’s job, where a simple written quote response moves from executive to reporter without raising questions about its origin or authenticity.
Journalists know this now, and they’re changing how they source accordingly. To an editor who’s already been burned, the authentic submission and the fabricated one look identical, at least until proven otherwise.
The solution presented
Journalists and their publishers’ verification processes are increasingly confirming identity and the quote for every submission.
We recently held a pre-interview for a well-known podcast to review topics and questions, set the flow, and ensure the spokesperson’s tech works. The producer also said pre-screening is now required because people claimed expertise in AI or other topics without the knowledge to back it up.
During the pre-screening, this podcast needs to verify that a source is who they claim to be. Then, that the source actually said or has expertise in what’s being attributed to them. The podcast’s producer also asks for a phone number to speak with the source directly after verification.
This isn’t an isolated incident. We’ve started seeing requests for commentary directly from sources elsewhere too, some of it as blunt as “I will not accept comments sent on behalf of someone else. It has to be direct from source.”
A top workplace news website also started making the same request, and journalists’ queries increasingly ask for a phone call instead of written commentary because a phone call is much harder to fake than an email quote (for now).
Prepare for a new responsibility
A pitch that once hinged on the strength of a journalist-marketer relationship must now clear an authentication bar built for people trying to get away with something nefarious. PR practitioners who never fabricated anything will need to do extra work because of the broader fallout.
Surviving this shift requires two things.
First, executives must be prepared and willing to take a verification call when a journalist asks. This level of visibility and access is paramount to avoid looking evasive or potentially fraudulent. Collect a documented record of what was said and when.
Second, ensure you’ve built a trusted relationship with a journalist. You need to be able to differentiate a legitimate verification request from a clickbait site fishing for information. Ideally, this exists because the representative has been doing the trust-building work for years, long before the journalist’s request came in.
Both are paramount. If you’ve laid the groundwork but don’t have an executive willing to give access, it starts to look like stonewalling to a journalist already on high alert for fraud.
Conversely, giving a journalist direct access to a leader with no foundational relationship or groundwork is also a problem. PR people can’t just connect reporters without preparing executives, even if it makes source verification easier.
This means executives need advance media training to avoid going off the rails and telling a reporter information they shouldn’t. Otherwise, executives can say things they shouldn’t—such as an upcoming but unannounced project—because they thought the discussion was “off the record” (when nothing is really off the record).
It’s a misread to treat this shift as a demotion. Being able to say yes with confidence when a journalist calls to confirm a quote is the job now. That’s what’s actually changing: The trust an agency built with reporters is becoming the thing clients pay for.
Lizzy Harris is the CEO and cofounder at The Colab.