In many organizations right now, the middle is cracking. Managers are juggling expanded spans of control, constant transformation and a wave of AI initiatives they’re expected to “figure out” on top of everything else.
Middle managers are being stretched thin—juggling broader spans of control, constant transformation and now AI initiatives they’re expected to decipher. A 2024 McKinsey Health Institute report found they experience higher burnout rates than any other group, while iCIMS research shows over half of Gen Z workers fear AI will threaten their job security this year. Together, these pressures reveal a deeper structural issue: shrinking early‑career pipelines and rising demands on the middle.
Based on my experience in HR conversations with CHROs across industries, a consistent trend is emerging: organizations are weakening the talent bench that sustains long-term performance. If that trend continues, I am afraid we are driving our workforce strategy over a cliff.
I specifically want to address three core issues that demand closer attention:
- How cutting early‑career hiring increases pressure on middle managers.
- How AI‑native early‑career roles can compress ramp time and return bandwidth to the middle.
- How the C‑suite can redesign early‑career roles for an AI‑native workforce.
THE MIDDLE‑MANAGEMENT DILEMMA
During my twenty years in human resources, I learned one critical truth: middle managers play a crucial integrator role as translators of strategy and orchestrators in execution. When entry‑level hiring stalls, they lose their primary source of delegation and development. Work that used to be shared with analysts, coordinators or associates now rolls uphill.
Although AI has the potential to help lighten this load, it still needs to be trained, tested and audited. That oversight frequently falls to managers, essentially creating a net neutral workload.
Cutting early‑career hiring amplifies this tension. Managers lead teams with fewer junior contributors to absorb execution work. They become de facto owners of AI tools, responsible for testing systems, crafting prompts, validating outputs and translating limitations to leadership. They also shoulder the emotional and change‑management burden of helping employees adapt, often with limited time and support.
A 2024 Gartner survey of HR leaders found that 75% say managers are overwhelmed by expanding responsibilities and 69% say managers are not equipped to lead change—even before generative AI is fully embedded.
Over time, this creates a “great squeeze” in the middle: rising expectations, shrinking teams and increasing complexity. AI adds new capabilities, but without thoughtful role design, it can also add new demands that the early‑career bench that could help.
AN AI‑NATIVE WORKFORCE STARTS AT THE BOTTOM
The instinct to pause entry‑level hiring in an AI era comes from a familiar narrative. For years, early‑career roles were treated primarily as a cost.
I spent most of my HR career in the financial sector. In banking and corporate finance, it was common to hire recent graduates into analyst roles which were labor‑intensive but essential positions that fed many areas of the bank. After a few years, analysts might move into risk management, client portfolio management or other specialized roles. Each early‑career class gradually permeated the organization.
The tradeoff was time. It often took 18 to 24 months before a new analyst became a reliable, independent contributor. Formal education provided technical skills, but not company‑specific judgment, stakeholder nuance or familiarity with internal tools. For many, it was also their first full‑time job, so basic workplace learning layered on top of technical learning.
For managers, this shifts value. When early‑career roles are designed to be AI‑native from day one, they provide leverage rather than additional supervision load. Managers can focus on coaching judgment, scenario thinking and stakeholder management instead of recreating basic training material or redoing work.
HOW TO REDESIGN EARLY‑CAREER ROLES FOR AI
For leaders evaluating headcount and hiring in upcoming budget cycles, there is an alternative to freezing early‑career roles and assuming AI will fill the gap. It starts with recognizing that the health of the middle layer depends on how organizations invest at the bottom.
- Redesign early‑career roles as AI‑native. Define early‑career jobs as AI‑augmented contributor roles and specify the AI tools they will use, the decisions they will support and how their work connects to outcomes managers are accountable for.
- Use early‑career talent as your AI test lab and champions. Concentrate AI experimentation in early‑career teams on clearly scoped, lower‑risk workflows.
- Build a visible AI‑native pipeline into middle management. Require AI fluency and leadership in AI‑enabled environments for managerial promotions. Prioritize candidates who’ve grown within your AI‑driven workflows and understand both the tech and your business.
Choosing to cut early‑career hiring in response to AI might reduce short‑term salary costs, but it can also concentrate more work and more risk on a middle layer that is already stretched. More importantly, it removes the internal pipeline of AI‑native talent that could grow into future managers.
Trent Cotton is the head of talent insights at ICIMS.