Not long ago, your brand’s reputation was shaped by what you communicated and what customers said about you in public forums. Now, it’s also shaped by what AI says about those customers—and about you. Every post, review, response, comment, and rating is being summarized, scored, and surfaced by generative search tools that decide which brands deserve attention.
AI has quietly taken the wheel in shaping perceptions and driving customer decisions. AI search results and emerging AI platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google Gemini now play an active role in determining which brands get noticed and, more importantly, which brands are recommended for specific use cases.
This is a major swing from traditional search results that provided options and information for the consumer to decide. Now AI search is providing specific recommendations along with supporting data and information that informs those recommendations.
Indeed, according to a study from Bain & Company, 80% of consumers now rely on search engine answers, also known as zero-click AI searches, for nearly half of their inquiries. This change in behavior has led to a reduction in organic web traffic by an estimated 15% to 25%. That means consumers are making decisions based on summaries and signals surfaced by AI, without ever seeing a link to your site, let alone clicking it.
Every digital footprint, from online ratings and reviews to an offhand social media comment, feeds into how AI judges and positions your brand. And those AI narratives quickly reinforce themselves across search results and social platforms, either locking in reputational advantages or amplifying negative sentiment.
Optimize for AI
Unlike traditional search, today’s AI chatbots don’t just list results—they make recommendations, complete with pros and cons. In traditional search, if you asked, “Who should I use to start an LLC?” you’d get a bunch of links without any opinion. Usually, either the brand with the best SEO would win by ranking near the top, or the biggest brand in the category would win through sheer awareness.
Ask ChatGPT today who the best company is for starting an LLC, and you might see a mix of big players—but what it says about each brand reveals how powerful these summaries have become. With these new AI experiences, AI pulls information, both good and bad, from every source they have access to about your brand—not just the major sites. This new reality means that policing the brand is harder than ever and no longer just a marketing function. Rather, it must be a full company effort.
It’s not enough to ensure your brand shows up accurately across the major customer review sites, community and social platforms—you need to have visibility and influence tied to any mention that may be sourced by AI chatbots. You also need an organization-wide feedback loop. Every team, from operations to customer care to sales, should help identify the sources of negative sentiment, address the root causes, and amplify the positive experiences that result from those improvements.
Stay positive
Specifically, you need to understand, and act on, the way your brand is viewed and presented by AI. A big part of this is recognizing that the quality and tone of your customer responses is a key data point for AI.
Positive responses will dramatically improve how your brand is surfaced in zero-click search and summary results. Indeed, businesses that proactively respond to customers will likely see stronger placement in AI-generated summaries. A thoughtful reply to a negative comment can also shift the sentiment balance in your favor, whereas silence or generic responses can lower your visibility.
To rise to the top, you need to control the narrative. And that means making sure every review response reflects your brand’s approved messaging, tone, and values—no matter who’s responding or where. It also means crafting replies that are designed not only to please customers but to send the right signals to AI. This can greatly influence the way that algorithms summarize and surface your brand.
Keep in mind that the customer journey doesn’t end when the purchase is complete. In fact, that’s where the opportunity to catch and shape feedback often starts. It’s where continuous improvement and lasting loyalty truly begin.
Shape how AI sees you
Your brand doesn’t exist in isolation. It’s constantly being measured against the competition by both customers and algorithms. You need to know exactly where you stand out, where you’re falling short, and where your rivals are starting to eat your lunch.
Every review, star rating, and response is processed by AI algorithms that determine how, when, and where your brand gets surfaced. Again, positive, consistent signals boost your standing, while negative, inconsistent ones can degrade it. In other words, what customers say and how you engage with their comments directly influence the trust and visibility of your brand.
The key is understanding, then shaping, how AI platforms represent your brand through a combination of content, partner, social, and PR strategies, while continuing to focus on delivering high-quality products or services, engaging proactively and transparently with customers online, and managing crises effectively with swift and honest communication. That’s how you can get these platforms to reflect your best attributes and position you as the preferred choice in their recommendations.
What leaders can do now
Here are three immediate things leaders can do to strengthen their company’s brand reputation in this new age of AI search:
1. Audit your AI presence. Test how your brand appears in ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity in comparison to competitors.
2. Build a cross-functional reputation task force. Align marketing, customer experience, and operations around feedback loops.
3. Respond with purpose. Treat every review as a chance to train the algorithms in your favor.
Reputation is now a non-negotiable for building trust with customers and AI systems alike. the brands that reach the top and stay there are the ones that dedicate the necessary resources to shape and control customer perception at every turn.
Daniel Lysaught is chief marketing officer at LegalZoom.