Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

AI will expose weak leadership faster

Timeless skills help leaders and employees through transformational changes.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Tacy M. Byham

CEO · Development Dimensions International (DDI)

Four months into her new management role, Deandra was preparing for annual performance reviews. Eager to explore how AI and leadership could work together, she built an AI agent that analyzed quarterly goals, one-on-one and team meeting transcripts, and HR’s performance criteria. 

Within minutes, she had a detailed assessment of all eight team members, including key performance moments Deandra had forgotten.

She could have submitted those AI-generated reports to HR and called it good, saving time and avoiding potentially awkward conversations. But Deandra understood a fundamental truth about leading through AI transformation: While AI was great for analyzing tracked activity, it could not and should not be the sole arbiter of performance.

AI had never worked alongside her team or witnessed their judgment, creativity, or collaboration. Deandra couldn’t rely on an algorithm to make decisions that could advance or derail someone’s career based purely on what looked good on paper.

Thankfully, Deandra’s story is the best-case scenario. AI didn’t replace her as a manager. Instead, it amplified her effectiveness while revealing her sound judgment, conscientiousness, and readiness to step up as a leader.

AI exposes leadership gaps

I talk to executives every week who worry AI will create a new generation of weak leaders who rely too much on technology.

In reality, AI is simply exposing leadership weaknesses and skill deficits faster. For example, before AI, a manager who communicated poorly, avoided difficult decisions, or failed to build trust with their team could coast—for months or years—before the consequences became obvious as team performance dwindled or people left for other roles.

With AI accelerating everything, those same failures surface faster and cost more. The manager who communicated poorly may roll out a redesigned workflow before explaining what changed, leaving teams to build on confusion.

A leader who avoids hard calls may accept a confident-looking AI recommendation without pressure-testing it, allowing an error to travel several layers up the organization. And a leader who hasn’t earned their team’s trust has little cushion when rapid AI-driven change increases stress and erodes morale.

Trust drives AI outcomes

Most organizations treat tools as the center of their AI transformation, like it’s the film Field of Dreams: If you build it (or mandate it), they will come.

But data shows otherwise. Frontline leaders are three times more likely than senior leaders to be anxious about AI, according to our research. That’s because they’re responsible for adoption, reskilling, and workflow redesign, often without the leadership development needed to navigate these obstacles. 

AI disruption means teams need leaders they can trust to shepherd them through this change, and that trust can only be built through connection, communication, curiosity, and empathy.

Empathy alone is tied to a 1.3 times greater likelihood of productivity improvement and 1.4 times greater quality gains. It creates the psychological safety teams need to be curious, experiment, and even fail and learn from it, which ultimately generates better outcomes. Leaders who model curiosity and are willing to be a beginner in front of their own team build the trust that moves AI adoption forward.

Timeless skills help leaders rise to a new challenge

As McKinsey points out, AI may transform how we work, but only humans can set the tone for why our work matters and what we’re trying to achieve. And that ability is a specific, teachable behavior.

Despite all the AI hype, these aren’t new skills invented for the moment. DDI’s 5Cs of Leadership in the AI Era draw on the same foundational skills and behavioral science we’ve measured and prioritized for over 50 years, grounded in the Key Principles for Better Leadership.

What’s different is how leaders must apply them, by pressure-testing AI recommendations, redesigning work instead of simply automating old workflows, and keeping teams steady through unprecedented change.

For example, one of the 5Cs, leading with conscience, means knowing when to say “no” to using AI, even if it would save time, like in Deandra’s case. A conscientious leader asks whether removing humans from the loop comes at a cost, like losing trust with a customer or employee, and whether that cost is worth the tradeoff.

The other Cs play out just as concretely. Driving creativity means redesigning an existing workflow to be truly better and more efficient for the humans in the process. Communicating with clarity means going beyond announcing a pilot of AI tools to explain exactly what’s changing and how it will improve day-to-day operations.

Build leadership as part of AI infrastructure

Even the best AI tool training and governance can’t overcome poor leadership. Teaching people to use AI without preparing managers to lead them through the change ignores a critical piece of system infrastructure.

AI can produce a recommendation, but it can’t decide how to act on it, accept accountability for the outcome, or recognize when efficiency comes at an unacceptable cost. Those decisions require human judgment, and the consequences become greater as information and decisions move faster.

Only about a third of employees trust their managers to do the right thing. That crisis existed long before AI, but it underpins the AI adoption problem.

Fortunately, leadership isn’t a fixed trait that managers either have or don’t. It’s a capability system you can define, develop, and strengthen deliberately through assessment, practice, and reinforcement. Organizations that succeed with AI will prioritize leadership infrastructure as much as the tech stack.

Tacy M. Byham is CEO of DDI.