Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Anti-DEI activists, the weapon of conflation, and the way forward with equitable innovation

The conversation shouldn’t be about whether we’re “pro-DEI” or “anti-DEI.” It should be about how we are identifying and solving the very real problems of inequality.

Anti-DEI activists

[(JLco) Julia Amaral / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Anna Dewar Gully

Anti-DEI activists have mastered the art of conflation, distorting and blending key issues to sow confusion and derail meaningful change. This tactic mirrors the relentless speed of today’s 24-hour news cycle, where problems are oversimplified and sensationalized, leaving us overwhelmed and unable to move forward.

In the realms of higher education and business, where the acronym and many of the concepts of diversity, equity, and inclusion are under significant attack, this strategy serves to obstruct progress and amplify division.

CODIFYING THE ANTI-DEI MOVEMENT

On January 21, 2025, the newly inaugurated 47th president of the United States issued an executive order placing federal DEI staff on paid leave, soon to be laid off.

This is the latest in a long string of attacks on the broad and varied organizational practices lumped haphazardly into the term DEI.

DEI has become a lightning rod across campuses, corporate boardrooms, and political campaigns. Thanks to the constant noise from right-leaning media, anti-DEI activists, and so-called “anti-woke” crusaders, DEI is now the epicenter of the culture wars. Corporate giants like Walmart, Meta, and McDonald’s have dismantled DEI teams, slashed budgets, and shelved initiatives after facing backlash from conservative activists like Robby Starbuck.

But here’s the thing: A myopic and loud set of voices has shaped this frame.

That’s a mistake we’ve made too many times in history. These narrow ideological voices confuse us—keeping us stuck in a loop—to distract us from the real problem. They are trying to reduce some of the most important problems of our time to a binary “DEI or anti-DEI.”

It’s a false choice, a false dichotomy. If we’re not careful, this choice will lead us to the wrong future. We need to change the frame.

CHANGING THE FRAME TO EQUITABLE INNOVATION

As leaders, the conversation shouldn’t be about whether we’re “pro-DEI” or “anti-DEI.” It should be about how we are identifying and solving the very real problems of inequality—unfairness, bias, barriers, unmet needs, and gaps in decision-making—that exist in every organization and community there is.

These are the problems that leaders and employees alike want fixed because they stop people from doing their best work and stop organizations from having the best impact.

If you believe in fairness, why wouldn’t you want to solve the problems getting in the way? If meritocracy is your ideal, are problems of unfairness not the problems we all need to solve?

At Tidal Equality, we’ve already changed the frame. We call it equitable innovation—and we define it as any beneficial change that reduces bias, barriers, unmet needs, and representation gaps in decision-making to expand fairness and equality of opportunity.

You can’t regulate against fairness. You can’t ban problem-solving.

If anti-DEI activists want to argue for meritocracy and insist it should exist, then equitable innovation—the work of solving the problems that stand in the way of meritocracy—is what can bring that lofty ideal to life.

Whether or not you call it DEI or not is not the point. The point is solving the problems that are getting in the way for people.

Whether it’s removing unnecessary job criteria that leave out whole populations, or changing the way you design your events so that more people can engage, the opportunities for equitable innovation abound in every type of human-centric decision your organization or institution makes.

THE PROGRESS NO ONE CAN STOP

Again, there’s good news: None of the anti-DEI legislation or regulation could possibly stop this kind of problem-solving or this essential form of innovation.

Why? It’s too nuanced. It could never be regulated.

There is nothing preventing the average employee or leader from learning how to identify unmet needs, unresolved barriers, or biases in criteria—and fixing those problems to make systems and decisions fairer within the span of their control.

Call it DEI and be in the battle, or call it innovation (with an equitable intent) and win the war against inequality.

At Tidal Equality, we’ve shown that we do not have to place these problems in the binary political frame. They’re organizational dysfunctions that need to be fixed. And they can be resolved to the benefit of all your stakeholders.

This kind of problem-solving is teachable, doable, and incredibly valuable.

You don’t need DEI in your job title to pursue equitable innovation. It doesn’t have to be a DEI initiative to address unmet needs or remove barriers. Just do it.

HOW TO PUSH BACK

Reject false choices: It’s not DEI vs. anti-DEI. It’s about removing barriers that hinder success. If they talk about meritocracy, you talk about what’s getting in the way and fix it.

Focus on root causes: Inequity—and not attempts to solve it—is the source of division. Solving systemic bias is essential to building better outcomes for everyone. 

One step at a time through complexity: It’s easy to be awed by the scale of the problem but instead, focus on one problem at a time.

EQUITABLE INNOVATION: THE WAY FORWARD

Equitable innovation is about making everyday decisions that center on fairness and get bias, barriers, and unmet needs out of the way.

Here are five steps leaders can take toward equitable innovation:

  1. Prioritize fairness: Look at decisions through a fairness lens.
  2. Seek diverse perspectives: Involve many voices to define the problems and solutions.
  3. Challenge the status quo: Identify and disrupt unfairness in the every day.
  4. Invest in learning: You can learn equitable innovation, and so can your team and entire organization.
  5. Solve real problems: Solve real problems, then solve some more.

KEEP MOVING FORWARD

Anti-DEI activists want to turn progress backward, but inequality is the real threat to meritocracy and our world. As leaders, we need to reject false narratives and false choices and focus on real problems and solutions. We can collectively change that to build better institutions, companies, products, and services—that’s how we will build the future that’s built for us all.