Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Apple must democratize access to the data economy

Is Apple more serious about protecting privacy or its bottom line?

Laptop with Apple logo

[Images: Girts/AdobeStock]

Profile photo of Tom Chavez

When Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk recently spoke out against Apple, it struck a chord. Both men—under their own clouds of criticism over privacy and their management of social media behemoths—singled out Apple for its stronghold over mobile apps and more.

At a New York Times DealBook summit, Zuckerberg harshly described the iPhone maker as “the only company that is trying to control unilaterally what apps get on a device.” In November, Musk suggested Apple had threatened to take his platform off its app store. (“Do they hate free speech in America?” said one of his missives before he later appeared to reconcile some differences in a meeting with CEO Tim Cook.)

It may look like Apple is the good kid on the playground getting beat up by the billionaires, but don’t be fooled. Apple is an 800-pound tech gorilla, too, and far from perfect on data and consumers.

I’ve written previously—and approvingly—of Apple’s moves to give power back to regular people when it comes to privacy. The company understands the importance of putting privacy front and center for consumers with prompts that ask for permission to share data.

But does Apple really mean it? Or, is the so-called hard line on privacy a way to pay lip service to consumers while taking a muscular, anti-competitive stance?

The key to Apple’s strategy is App Tracking Transparency, or ATT for short. It’s made up of in-app pop-ups asking permission to “track you across apps and websites owned by other companies.” The feature was already available to consumers if they dug into their settings to enable it. Apple made changes last year to make the privacy option apply across apps. Those who did not comply or who skirted the rules faced a ban from its app store.

Not all data was off-limits—first-party data was safe; third-party data was the target. But because the App Store is the platform that sees everything, Apple has been able to skirt its own ATT rules. Apple’s privacy regulations for its devices say data gathered by analytics services aren’t used to identify you as a user. But an analysis of such tools recently reported on in Gizmodo found that a permanent ID number “tied to your full name, phone number, birth date, email address, and more” is shared with Apple along with data on analytics and device usage.

All of this, coupled with Apple’s growing advertising ambitions, point to disingenuousness. And it invites a logical question: Is Apple more serious about protecting privacy or its bottom line?

The company already has a search ad business—and plenty of inventory via Apple News. According to the reports, Apple’s ad unit has seen huge growth since ATT went into effect. Last year, close to 60% of app store downloads were via Apple ads. Compare that to under 20% in 2020. It’s a $5 billion business that analysts expect could bring in up to $30 billion when potential with Apple News and Apple TV is taken into consideration.

That’s great news for America’s most valuable company, but not for consumers.

Apple’s pursuit of privacy regulation seems to be more about nurturing a nascent ad business than being serious about ethical technology.

But don’t give Apple, where innovation and reinvention are part of the brand’s DNA, too much credit. The strategy is a new version of an old story. Google made waves for initially firewalling search data from their ad basis, but it became too lucrative an opportunity to ignore as the search engine giant started marketing the very data it vowed to keep private.

For Apple, there’s still time to change course.

The solutions are rather simple. You can respect data dignity while living in the data economy. Apple says users can control their participation in data sharing. Right now, they actually can’t when it comes to the biggest player in the room—Apple. It’s a strategy that’s no better than a total repudiation of data dignity.

Apple is second to none when it comes to user experience. Millions of Apple customers are delighted whenever they pick up an Apple product with a simple, streamlined, delightful interface—that is, until it comes to a user’s experience of privacy. While Apple’s advertising touts privacy (think the billboards that say “Privacy. That’s iPhone.”), why doesn’t Apple honor that virtuosity in user experience by offering consumers better visibility and control into how their data is being monetized?

As I’ve said many times, consumers do not mind giving up some of their data when they know they are doing it and understand what they are getting in return (think of the recommendation algorithm on Netflix). When data dignity and data utility come together, the results can be wonderful and pro-consumer. But with the way things are now with Apple, consumers will suffer because there isn’t democratized access to the data economy.

We need responsible data stewardship. It’s good branding, ethical tech, and simply smart business.

As a market leader, Apple could be poised to set the standard.

The fact is, as with all things in life, there must be room for nuance. Privacy is a human right that is compatible with data dignity. That right doesn’t stop when you log on to your phone, computer, TV, or any other device.


Tom Chavez is Chair of The Ethical Project and CEO of privacy and data governance company Ketch.