Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Authentic leadership is about what you give

What former Home Depot CEO Frank Blake taught me.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Adrian Cronje

CEO · Balentine

We hear the word authenticeverywhere in leadership conversations. Be authentic, they say. Lead authentically and show up as yourself.

It resonates because it’s true—people are drawn to leaders who let us in and reveal their humanity. To us, they feel grounded, and that’s comforting. Authenticity builds trust. But what we don’t talk about enough is how hard that actually is.

Leadership comes with a constant pull toward performance. The higher you go, the more visible you become, and the more subtle the pressure to say the right thing, project confidence, and meet expectations.

Layer on something even more human—the desire to be liked—and it becomes easy to drift. Maybe not in obvious ways, but in small ones. You soften a message, you avoid a hard truth. You lean into what’s well-received instead of what’s most needed.

Over time, those moments add up, and what looks like authenticity on the surface can start to feel more like a version of yourself that is shaped by the room rather than grounded in your values.

The most effective leaders I know understand this tension. They know that authenticity isn’t automatic—it takes discipline.

One of the clearest examples of this in my own life is my friend, Frank Blake, the CEO of Home Depot from January 2007 through November 2014.

Leadership starts at the bottom

When Frank was unexpectedly asked to step into the CEO role at Home Depot, he didn’t arrive with a fully formed leadership philosophy. In fact, he’ll tell you he wasn’t even sure he was the obvious choice.

What he did have was a simple idea rooted in the company’s founding of the inverted pyramid. In that model, the CEO doesn’t sit at the top. The CEO sits at the bottom.

That might sound like humility—something akin to an executive wearing the orange apron. In reality, it’s something far more demanding.

As Frank describes it, the bottom of the pyramid is weight-bearing. Everything is uphill. Communication doesn’t cascade down—it has to be earned through constant effort, repetition, and presence.

That reframing changes the role entirely. Leadership is about staying connected to what’s actually happening below.

Authenticity requires effort

What Frank demonstrates is that authenticity requires intention. You have to work to stay connected to reality.

He says he quickly learned that asking “How are things going?” yields very little. The natural response is to reassure the leader by telling them what they want to hear. So, he changed the question. Instead of asking for confirmation, he asked for truth through two questions:

1. What’s not working?
2. On a scale of one to ten, where are we?

Those questions signal that leadership isn’t looking to be liked but to understand. Instead of saying what feels good in the moment, create the conditions for honesty.

The power of showing up personally

One of the most enduring lessons Frank carried into his leadership came from watching President George H. W. Bush write personal notes by hand every day.

He brought that same practice into his time as CEO. Every Sunday, he would spend hours writing notes to employees to recognize specific acts of service, effort, or care. Not generic praise, but something personal and real. He knew those notes mattered when an employee asked him to rewrite one because they’d tested it under water to make sure it wasn’t printed.

It’s personal when you connect your humanity to someone else’s, they experience leadership through small moments versus big strategy, which builds trust over time.

Culture is what people carry with them

One of the most powerful stories Frank shares came from a letter he received from a store manager near the end of his tenure. The manager described how his team had gathered to help a woman living in extreme poverty by repairing her home, restoring utilities, and coordinating support from the broader community.

What stood out was what the manager said afterward. He had simply acted because “That’s what Home Depot does.” Then he asked a question that gets to the heart of leadership:

“Am I Home Depot—or is Home Depot who I am?”

That’s culture, or what people internalize and carry with them into their decisions.

Leadership is a legacy decision

In our work with families and entrepreneurs, we often talk about the difference between what you build and what you leave behind. Wealth is what you accumulate. Legacy is what endures in others.

Leadership works the same way.

The real impact of a leader isn’t found in strategy decks or quarterly results. It’s found in people.

  • Do they feel a sense of pride in their work?
  • Do they feel connected to something larger than themselves?
  • Do they carry those values into their communities?

Frank often talks about community in exactly those terms, as identity. People want to be proud of where they work. They want to know that what they do matters beyond the organization’s walls. Frank has seen firsthand that when that happens, alignment becomes natural, trust compounds, and the organization becomes more human and therefore more resilient.

Mentorship is how leadership scales

Another defining trait of authentic leaders is their willingness to invest in others.

Frank is extraordinarily generous with his time. He mentors without an agenda, asks thoughtful questions, and he shows up fully in those conversations. For people who work at Home Depot and for other leaders like me.

The kind of leadership that Frank demonstrates is a multiplier. People who feel seen and supported go on to do the same for others.

The real test of authenticity

Authenticity is about doing the harder work of staying aligned, especially when there’s pressure to perform, to please, or to conform. It’s the discipline of showing up consistently, listening when it would be easier to speak, and choosing what’s right over what’s well received. That is what I have learned from Frank.

In the end, authenticity is something others experience, not something you declare.

Adrian Cronje is CEO of Balentine.