Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Authority doesn’t multiply when you split it

Nine websites, one subject, and a brand spread thin.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Bhavik Sarkhedi

Bhavik Sarkhedi is the founder of Ohh My Brand and co-founder of Blushush, focused on building authority-led visibility for founders. · Ohh My Brand | Blushush Technologies

For a long time, I believed online reach was arithmetic. Two places to be found on the internet beat one; five beat two; and whoever turns up in 10 places wins the client.

So I tested it properly. I built six websites on one subject and three more on another. Same research, same build process, same publishing setup. I reshuffled the wording on each one, but the substance stayed the same. I launched nine sites within months of each other, each meant to be another door into the same expertise.

Then I realized most of them were invisible. But why?

Of the six, two were indexed and gathering readers. The other four were stuck on their homepage, every interior page ignored. Of the three, one worked, and two sat idle. I assumed a broken build, so I opened a winner and a loser side by side and viewed the live versions. They were twins. Same structure, same sitemap, same server behavior, same standard of writing.

There was no bug. The sites were healthy. The disease lay in the strategy.

THE SYSTEM ONLY NEEDS ONE OF YOU

Google has outlined exactly what happened to me. When it finds a group of pages carrying the same content, it does not rank all of them. It selects one as the canonical version, after judging it most useful for a reader. The others are simply not shown.

That’s a personal branding problem. My nine sites were one chance and eight photocopies. I had submitted the same essay nine times under nine different names, and the grader marked the first one carefully and skimmed the rest.

THE HUMAN VERSION OF THIS

Most people don’t own nine domains. But count your surfaces: LinkedIn, a newsletter, the second newsletter you began when the first went quiet, a podcast that stopped at episode 11, a personal site you last touched two years ago.

Each carries a slightly different version of the same expertise.

Herbert Simon saw the cost of this in 1971, decades before any of these platforms existed. Information, he wrote, consumes the attention of those who receive it, so that “a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention.” Attention is the scarce resource, not information.

Nobody holds more attention in reserve because you opened another channel. The same attention gets divided into smaller pieces, and a divided signal does not add itself back up later. It stays small in more places.

CREDIBILITY COMPOUNDS WHERE IT COLLECTS

Every mention, link, referral, and half-remembered conversation about your work is a deposit. Kept in one account, the balance eventually crosses the line where people treat you as the obvious answer. Split across six accounts, you hold six balances too small to matter.

In Ahmedabad, India, food carts queue at 8 p.m., selling the one thing they have sold on that one corner for 11 years. The cart selling everything is nobody’s first choice for anything.

THE ANSWER ENGINES MADE THIS STRICTER

When a buyer asks an AI assistant whom to hire, the model is looking for a position it can attach to a name with some confidence. Nine thin versions of a person offer nine weak associations and no clear one. A human being can hold ambiguity about you and still pick up the phone. A model tends to resolve that ambiguity by naming somebody else.

This is an argument for having one destination. In my case, I needed to choose the single surface where buyers actually made up their minds, the media channel read by the last five people who hired me. Everything went there: the full argument, the actual work, the proof.

Everything else then pointed at that channel rather than competing with it. Other platforms became roads instead of destinations. I still post on them, but don’t keep parallel bodies of work that eat each other. After I merged the scattered sites into their strongest versions, the surviving sites absorbed the readers the copies had been holding hostage.

THE FIX TO TRY

I recommend a two-minute diagnostic. Open a browser you are not signed into, search your own name, and read the first page as a stranger would, counting how many different descriptions of your work come back.

In my experience, when someone who has never met you cannot say in one sentence what you are for, the problem is in the scattering.Spreading yourself feels productive because activity is easy to count and authority isn’t. Nine sites felt like nine times the work, and they were. They also produced one site’s worth of results, distributed badly.

That is the lesson I paid for: one place holding everything real, with the rest of the internet as signposts pointing at the same door.

Bhavik Sarkhedi is founder of Ohh My Brand and cofounder of Blushush.