Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Avoiding the road to mediocrity

If we continue to live in a world where our most talented entrepreneurs feel they must pursue the formulaic “pattern” everyone else is chasing, we’ll end up with mediocrity.

Avoiding the road to mediocrity

[Dusko / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Sid Banthiya

CFO · TMRW Life Sciences

“Every time I see a new startup—say, a dog food brand— I think, ‘Why? There are already ten other dog-food startups that are essentially all the same!’ Sure, the offerings may be slightly different, but even the branding seems similar. I don’t get it.” 

Well, maybe it’s because each of those startups is funded by an investor who has bought into a “pattern.”

Nearly all of us experience “pattern recognition”—when our brains are stimulated by something in the now that extracts a similar pattern from our long-term memory. A Morgan Stanley report says the answer to whether pattern recognition is useful for investing is tricky. Yet, Andreesen Horowitz, one of the largest venture capital firms in the country, explicitly mentions a “pattern-based investing” approach, where they actively seek out companies that exhibit similar characteristics to past successful investments, leveraging their knowledge of market trends and emerging technologies.

It follows that should a venture capital partner notice a rapidly growing dog-food business, they or their brethren would quickly invest in a similar business. Venture firms have the highest return requirements of any asset class, and fund sizes are growing exponentially. They need to find businesses that can grow much faster than average. If the market is big enough, and the business can gain enough share to shut out competitors, the fund will be returned on a single investment. The ultimate achievement is a quick, successful exit (“IPO or acquisition”), a win they can splash across as many forms of media as possible, inspiring future entrepreneurs to seek their support over their competitors in the future. 

Many young founders believe the fastest way to a successful capital raise is to lean into the patterns recognized by the venture community. The problem is, entrepreneurs seeking funding will, sometimes inadvertently, lock their burgeoning company into a trajectory they can’t get out of. There’s nothing inherently wrong with the venture path—startups will receive more than enough funding to get their business off the ground. That said, the founder is beholden to an expected return on investment. For some, that level of growth and its drivers don’t apply: think consumer products versus enterprise software. For others, the market-share game will become the dominant driver of their business. 

For example, a dog food founder, whose first goal is to draw Purina customers to their business, will need the flexibility to discount price to lure those customers over—even if the company won’t profit from that sale. If the founder can’t reach a certain percentage of market share, you can be sure the funding they’re dependent on will be turned off just as quickly as it was turned on.

A startup unburdened by venture, however, could create a product with the space and time to experiment, measure results, and ultimately have the ability to meaningfully progress on a mission and vision that go beyond “winning.” Further, they’d have the ability to share profit—not just options—with employees, satisfying their need for both ownership and liquidity. 

Interestingly, the market of late has moved from a growth at-all-costs mindset to a more measured respect for unit economics and a path to profitability. That’s sensible, but sensibility pales in comparison to the appeal of “unicorn status” and all that comes with that pronouncement. The entrepreneur we celebrate today is the antithesis of the slow and steady builder. Finding the quickest path to a $1bn valuation is what we seem to be focused on, and fascinated with. 

And the narrative is still that non-VC backed entrepreneurs make fewer exits. But that narrative is a myth. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, the majority of IPOs and acquisitions are achieved without venture capital. But, but …don’t they need funding for a startup?!

Fortunately, we’re living in a time when the startup environment could not be more accessible to founders trying to get their ideas out. It’s creative content—not performance marketing—that drives audiences. And I can tell you from my own experience, when capital and resources are constrained, entrepreneurs find a way. In fact, 78% of small businesses were started without any formal funding, which has the added bonus of allowing founders to own more of their business. 

Deciding to not pursue venture financing (and the instant media attention that comes with it) allows founders to focus on customers’ needs and the sustainability of the business. In the race to innovate, founders should slow down for a minute and think deeply about what’s really driving them. Is the priority to win at someone else’s game, or to truly solve a problem in a way that hasn’t been done before? Headlines can be alluring, but why not let the work do the talking?

If we continue to live in a world where our most talented entrepreneurs feel they must pursue the formulaic “pattern” everyone else is chasing, we’ll end up with yet another suburb that looks like the last one or another film reboot of an original—a stop after another stop on the road to mediocrity.