Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Back to the future: How heritage brands can evolve their brand identity

The true magic of updating a heritage brand lies in the tension of navigating the past, present, and future.

Back to the future

[Adobe Stock – Jesse B/peopleimages.com]

Profile photo of Kate Wadia

Founder & COO · Mrs & Mr

Updating a heritage brand is one of the toughest challenges in branding. The industry is littered with rebrands that have gotten it wrong and faced backlash.

I’ve found the secret to getting it right lies in marrying the past with the present to create the future. It’s more art than science, but CMOs can avoid becoming a cautionary tale by focusing on five critical points in the creative process to help ensure their brand continues to stay relevant.

1. ANSWER THE EXISTENTIAL QUESTIONS 

Before you embark on a journey of change, it’s important to strategically understand the role your heritage brand plays in the world and answer the three most existential strategic questions:

  • Who you are?
  • How are you relevant?
  • What makes you different?

Once your positioning is clear about what makes your brand both relevant and distinctive, only then can you start to intersect that with other marketplace realities such as changing customer behavior and emerging cultural trends.

2. BE A BRAND ARCHEOLOGIST

Remember, generations of marketers before you have worked hard to differentiate your iconic brand from the competition—don’t just throw it all away. Are there brand truths that might have been lost over the years? Elements that may have been added to solve a particular problem or were specific to a period of time and are now no longer relevant?

Heritage brands have often had so many narratives over the course of their history, and it’s a common pitfall to try to hold on to several ideas at once. If you have too many points of view, you essentially have none. Take a reductive approach to help chip away at the layers and get to a strong, unique brand identity.

3. RESPECT THE CONSUMER

Never underestimate the deep emotional attachment people have to heritage brands. Whether a brand is aspirational or reminds a person of a certain time in their life, that relationship needs to be respected.

For example, when Pepsi created its highly successful update in 2023, the team discovered that its 1970s logos were the most beloved in the brand’s history, so they centered their refresh on that nostalgic consumer connection (full disclosure: Mrs&Mr has worked with Pepsi in the past). By looking to the past, you can tap into what was unique about your brand and then remix and reimagine that to propel it forward.

4. START WITH WHAT YOU SHOULD NOT CHANGE

Heritage brands are iconic for a reason—don’t change what people know and love you for! Whether it is a logo, a color, or a font, identify the core elements of your brand’s visual DNA before you start thinking about what should be removed or added.

You can modernize these elements, but do not strip away anything that provides instant brand recognition, such as the diamond shape of the Tabasco label or Sephora’s black and white stripes (full disclosure: Mrs&Mr has worked with Tabasco and Sephora in the past).

5. CRAFT IT TO LAST

Brands should only undertake a refresh every 10 to 15 years. If you have to do it more often, then your brand probably didn’t get it right the last time.

Build on your brand’s strong foundation of timelessness, not the trends of the moment. The key is predicting where you think the culture is going as well as where it is not. Mediums, channels, and technologies are constantly evolving, so you should also ensure any visual system you create is designed to be flexible.

NAVIGATING HEALTHY TENSION

The true magic of updating a heritage brand lies in the tension of navigating the past, present, and future. You want it to feel both incredibly familiar and incredibly different. Sit and think about the inherent tension in that statement for a moment. It can’t be one over the other. You can’t just be focusing on the new, but you can’t be stuck in the past, either. And finding that balance—navigating that healthy tension—is where the art lies.