Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Become irreplaceable, even if AI can copy a startup quickly

Find your unique angle for customer satisfaction.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Michael Gargiulo

CEO · VPN.com

The speed of imitation has changed the rules for founders. There was a time when building a strong product and moving quickly gave startups a real edge. That edge still matters, but it doesn’t protect a business the way it used to.

Today, AI can help recreate a landing page, rewrite messaging, mirror a funnel, and imitate a customer journey in a matter of days. In some cases, it can happen even faster.

Such a rapid shift creates pressure for founders. They must compete against established entities in their space—businesses that can copycat visible parts of the game plan, and race to get their own version to market before a founder can widen the intellectual property gap.

Often, imitation begins with surface-level assets. Things like features, design choices, and even pricing can be quickly imitated. Front-facing copy, like a brand’s marketing language, can be copied and reused. To an outsider looking in, this can sow doubt, particularly in a crowded market where buying decisions are quickly made.

If nearly everything customers can see visually online can be copied using AI, then founders need to think more seriously about what competitors still can’t take from them. Business success doesn’t rely on appearance alone.

Trust for success

Trust works differently, takes time, and grows through repetition, consistency, and a steady pattern of doing what you said you’d do.

An AI-cloned online interface may look convincing, but it can’t instantly carry the reputation of the company it copied, borrow years of positive interactions, or manufacture customer confidence on demand.

Founders need to look at visibility through a different lens. Businesses that are holding their own have already invested time, effort, and money to earn customer trust.

Trust starts with a clear expectation before a sale ever occurs. It is cemented by a hassle-free, seamless refund policy. It’s further reinforced by competent, speedy, human-powered customer service that resolves customer problems promptly. Combined, these actions create and reinforce trust over time. They are what shape a brand’s namesake and reliability.

That part matters more now, too, because AI-based copycats usually focus on what’s easiest to reproduce, including websites, services and online services that AI can copy overnight. Yet they struggle to reproduce the feeling customers get after dealing with a business that has established trust.

Features are great, but they don’t create loyalty on their own. Loyalty is a direct result of a positive customer experience. People will remember whether you cared about them, responded to their inquiries promptly, and were worth trusting again.

In a world where products, services, and brands are becoming easier to imitate, it’s this experience that holds the most value in the long term.

Domain and online distinctions

A digital asset is also a brand’s most formidable marketing weapon. A strong domain name, for example, is usually the customer’s initial impression, whether that’s a hero banner or a snippet of marketing copy that piqued their interest. Clear, easy-to-remember, and marketable domain names help establish trust from day one.

How can AI copy your business in just 24 hours?

  • Duplicating your messaging: An AI-using competitor can paste your website, ads, and emails into an AI tool to extract your positioning, then generate a lookalike landing page, ad angles, and email sequence in your same voice.
  • Cloning your funnel and offer: A competitor can use AI to reverse-engineer your pricing page, demo or webinar, FAQs, and reviews, then recreate the same sales flow and “bundle” with minor tweaks and a new brand name.

Speed still matters, too, but not for the same reason it once did. It’s no longer only about being first. It’s about building enough trust, recognition, and customer loyalty before imitation arrives. That’s a very different strategy.

Founders who think long term are building a distribution method and intellectual property that they control. They’re building email lists, communities, referral loops, partnerships, and direct customer relationships. They’re creating reasons for people to stay that go beyond a feature comparison.

A startup with no audience and no loyalty is easier to copy than to defend. A startup with a loyal customer base, a clear identity, and a trusted name has a much stronger position, even if competitors try to replicate the mechanics of the offer.

This is where a shift in conversation is needed. Today’s question is whether a viable product can hold consumer attention in a crowded market where copycats quickly emerge from the woodwork to compete.

Your moat

The AI boom isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. This means that founders can future-proof their brand by building for it instead, focusing on trust, relationship-building, and authority in their space as key tenets.

Sure, products can be recreated, and shockingly fast in today’s market. But a business person’s belief is much harder to replace.

Michael Gargiulo is CEO of VPN.com.