Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Beyond platitudes: Strategies to capture the win by targeting competitor trust gaps

Trust arbitrage consistently drives results that are brutal for competitors and beautiful for us.

[Adobe Stock / Prostock-studio]

Profile photo of Christine Alemany

Chief Growth Officer · Thrv Advisors

When I led a client’s expansion into the cybersecurity market, I noticed that Fortune 100 companies were increasingly forced to explain their latest data breaches, each claiming it was an “isolated incident.” From Equifax to Target to Capital One, the pattern was unmistakable.

While every established player was selling the increasingly hollow promise of breach prevention, we built our entire launch around a different truth: The question is not if your company will be breached, but when, and what happens in those critical 72 hours afterward.

That insight became our wedge into a $150 billion market. Within 18 months, we captured 12% market share in the enterprise segment by positioning around “breach resilience” while competitors peddled prevention fantasies. More importantly, we listened to how CISOs were shifting budget conversations from “How do we prevent breaches?” to “How do we survive them intact?”

This is trust arbitrage: Systematically exploiting credibility gaps your competitors cannot credibly address fast enough to build a sustainable revenue advantage.

CREATING TRUST ASYMMETRY

Traditional competitive strategies focus on features or pricing. Trust arbitrage exploits how decision-makers evaluate risk in low-trust environments.

When customers do not trust anyone completely, they default to trusting whoever acknowledges the reality they are experiencing. In cybersecurity, this reality was characterized by persistent anxiety about breaches. In fintech, it is regulatory uncertainty. In enterprise software, it’s concerns about vendor lock-in.

The companies I have advised that master this approach become the trusted voice of uncomfortable truths their competitors refuse to acknowledge.

During our cybersecurity expansion, deals where we competed directly against incumbents closed 20% faster than industry averages. Why? Because we eliminated cognitive dissonance between what prospects feared (inevitable breaches) and what vendors promised (flawless prevention). We were not just selling software. We were selling psychological relief.

Most corporate approaches to “building trust” fall flat. Undifferentiated platitudes (“We value your trust”), industry-standard practices, and unverifiable assertions represent defensive positioning rather than strategic differentiation. When every company makes similar claims, they become invisible to increasingly skeptical customers.

The most effective flanking strategies navigate these risks through careful research, substantiation, and authentic positioning. Rather than opportunistically attacking competitors, they establish clear, verifiable contrast that genuinely matters to customers while remaining firmly grounded in organizational capabilities and values.

HOW YOU CAN MAKE THIS WORK IN PRACTICE

After running this playbook across multiple market expansions in various industries, I have learned that you can’t rely on trust arbitrage. It requires discipline, and frankly, most revenue leaders lack the patience for the groundwork.

Here’s how you can get started:

1. Start with competitor intelligence that truly matters.

The first mistake I see is targeting surface-level weaknesses that competitors can patch with a press release or feature update. That is amateur hour. You want to identify the contradictions inherent in their business model.

You can take our cybersecurity play. The established players depended on customers believing breaches were preventable. Their contracts, pricing, and channel partnerships were based on delivering preventive security, or “improving security posture.” They could not pivot to “breach resilience” without admitting they had been selling customers a lie for years.

During a fintech expansion, we discovered traditional banks could not match our fee transparency without revealing their profit mechanics. Their quarterly earnings literally depended on the complexity of fees, and simplifying fees would crater their margins.

2. Build narratives around what customers already suspect.

Here is where most people screw up: They think trust arbitrage means attacking competitors directly. Wrong. You’re not saying, “Traditional banks rip you off.” You’re saying, “Banks have made fees deliberately confusing, and here’s why that needs to change.”

In cybersecurity, we did not attack specific vendors. We highlighted that average breach costs had increased 26% over four years, while the industry continued to sell prevention. When 70% of breached organizations reported that breaches caused significant or very significant disruption, the math became undeniable. We did not have to attack our competitors. We pointed out that the emperor had no clothes.

The magic happens when prospects think, “I always knew something was off about those fees,” rather than, “These people are just as bad.”

3. Create proof that is impossible to ignore.

Vague claims about competitor problems will get you laughed out of serious deals. You need data that makes your point undeniable.

For cybersecurity, we benchmarked the speed at which different approaches can contain simulated attacks. We published the methodology and the raw data of our analysis. When prospects asked incumbents about their containment times, most could not even define the metric.

4. Turn customers into evangelists.

The real payoff comes when your customers start asking competitors the uncomfortable questions your positioning raises. In cybersecurity, CISOs who bought into our “breach resilience” approach began grilling other vendors: “What’s your average containment time? How do you measure recovery effectiveness?”

Suddenly, prevention-focused competitors were fielding new questions. They could not answer these without admitting their claims were unrealistic. Sometimes, we could not overcome our limited name recognition. But we started building momentum and winning more deals, with our win rate increasing over time. We changed how the entire market evaluated security solutions.

THE NUMBERS DON’T LIE

Trust arbitrage consistently drives results that are brutal for competitors and beautiful for us.

In cybersecurity, our competitive win rate against prevention-focused incumbents hit 65% within a year. Compare that to typical market entry win rates of 15%-20%, and you understand why I’m a believer. Sales cycles that typically lasted 12-18 months were compressed to 8-10 months because we were validating what prospects had already suspected.

The pricing impact surprised even me. When you are the only vendor acknowledging uncomfortable realities, customers stop treating you like a commodity. We sustained a 20% pricing premium over some of the established players because they trusted our analysis and methodologies.

Competitors can copy features and match prices, but it is harder to admit their core positioning was wrong without destroying trust. During our cybersecurity play, it took established players nearly two years to pivot from prevention to resilience. Even then, they looked like followers, not leaders.