Most employers have one disability accommodation process—and a predictable outcome. An employee asks for an accommodation. Human resources sends them forms. The forms come back incomplete. HR asks for more. Someone schedules a meeting. Weeks pass before anyone decides what happens next.
We’ve made the interactive process too hard, not because the law requires it, but because employers use the same process for every request, no matter how different. A four-week lifting restriction after surgery is not the same as a permanent inability to lift. A temporary remote-work request during treatment is not the same decision as an indefinite remote-work request. These employees may all need accommodations, but they don’t need the same process. Instead, it’s better to build separate programming for short-term and long-term needs.
SHORT-TERM ACCOMMODATION SHOULD BE “YES OR YES”
Short-term accommodation programming includes determining what levels of leave or temporary accommodations will always be approved with supporting medical documentation and no concerns over misuse or abuse. This is your short-term “yes or yes” process: The employer will either say “yes” to leave or “yes” to working with temporary restrictions during recovery. For example, will you always approve up to six months of leave when the medical picture is clear, and a return date is in sight? Will you always provide light duty or a modified schedule for up to 90 days, extending it if that still works operationally? Once you decide your parameters, you should hold that line regardless of who’s asking.
Reaching the end of a short-term period doesn’t end the accommodation—it moves the request into a more robust interactive process.
Short-term programming should be simple. Every temporary accommodation needs a start date, an expected end date, and a scheduled check-in, with clear information about the restrictions or leave, even when the medical note is thin.
Without pre-established criteria, supervisors will make the call themselves, based on opinion or how much they value the employee. When HR sets short-term standards with legal counsel and leadership up front, similar cases get treated consistently—and the organization saves the time it needs to properly evaluate long-term requests that may not be reasonable.
WHEN THE NEED BECOMES LONG-TERM, THE PROCESS CHANGES
Organizations also must define when a request exceeds short-term approval: restrictions that outlast the approval period, leave that exceeds what short-term programming covers, or intermittent leave that continues year after year outside the protection of the Family and Medical Leave Act.
Crossing that line doesn’t end, or automatically extend, the accommodation. It changes the question to: Is this still reasonable to accommodate?
A restriction that’s easy to support for 90 days can affect a job differently after a year. A defined leave period is manageable. Leave with no return date requires closer analysis. Intermittent leave past FMLA can continue as an Americans with Disabilities Act accommodation. However, employers can ask whether unending intermittent leave is reasonable.
These are no longer “yes or yes” decisions. They require data and legal analysis, because a long-term accommodation can reshape how the job gets done and how work gets assigned and staffed. The employee may be counting on this decision to stay employed. That weight is exactly why it needs more process, not less.
A medical note that says “light duty” or “work from home” may support a 90-day accommodation. It’s rarely enough for a long-term one. What can the employee do, and for how long? If leave is involved, what frequency, what duration, and will it actually help them recover?
For long-term decisions, you’ll almost always need a focused supplemental medical questionnaire, tied to the job and limited to what you need to know. This isn’t about making someone prove their condition repeatedly. It’s about determining whether a reasonable, effective accommodation exists. Functional limitations, leave needs, and duration are critical.
We want the answer to still be yes—to the existing accommodation, a modified version, or something different that meets the same need. After a complete, good-faith process, the answer may also be no.
FUNCTIONAL LIMITATIONS DRIVE THE DECISIONS
Take the employee’s preference seriously. They often know what will help, and the request is sometimes both reasonable and effective.
Sometimes something else meets the same underlying need. An employee may prefer and request remote work when a modified schedule solves the actual limitation. The employer’s obligation is to provide an effective accommodation, not necessarily the one requested.
The same discipline runs the other direction. A supervisor can’t wave off a request as a preference because they personally don’t want to grant it. Remote work, a flexible schedule, or specialized equipment can look optional to someone who doesn’t need it. For someone who does, it can make the job possible. Decide based on data, not on what feels reasonable to whoever is judging it.
HR OWNS THE PROCESS, AND CO-SIGNS THE DECISION
HR facilitates the process: gathering information, closing gaps, talking with the employee, and keeping things moving. Supervisors understand the essential functions and operational realities. They belong in the decision.
HR’s job is to keep that decision grounded in data, not opinion—pushing back, looping in legal, or escalating to leadership when the decision isn’t or when HR disagrees with the supervisor. HR doesn’t make long-term decisions alone, but it must agree with the outcome. If it doesn’t, others get brought in to get it right. HR protects both the employee and the organization.
SUCCESS IS NOT THE SAME AS HAPPINESS
A good interactive process won’t always make the employee happy, or the supervisor either. Sometimes the employee gets exactly what they asked for. Sometimes a different accommodation meets the need just as well. Sometimes the process shows the employee can’t perform the essential functions even with accommodation, and the conversation moves to leave, reassignment, or another option. Disappointment doesn’t make it the wrong decision.
The interactive process isn’t a customer-satisfaction exercise, or an obstacle course employees must survive to get help. It’s a structured, good-faith effort to find out what someone medically needs and whether a reasonable accommodation exists.
That is good faith. And good faith is the work.
Rachel Shaw is president of Rachel Shaw, Inc.