Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Building brand trust in the age of AI: Why human connection still matters

Having worked extensively in brand strategy, consumer engagement, and multicultural marketing, I’ve seen firsthand how trust can make or break a brand.

Building brand trust in the age of AI: Why human connection still matters

[Mix and Match Studio / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Maria Alonso

Head of Account Management · Fortune 206

In an era where consumers are bombarded with information, brands no longer compete just on products or services—they compete on trust.

Yet, trust is at an all-time low. Consumers are skeptical of institutions, businesses, and the marketing messages they encounter daily. As AI continues to reshape industries, the real challenge isn’t just leveraging technology—it’s maintaining authenticity, credibility, and emotional connection in an increasingly automated world.

Having worked extensively in brand strategy, consumer engagement, and multicultural marketing, I’ve seen firsthand how trust can make or break a brand. The companies that thrive are those that prioritize human-centered storytelling, transparency, and meaningful interactions—even in an AI-driven landscape.

THE TRUST DEFICIT IN THE DIGITAL AGE

Today’s consumers are more skeptical than ever. From political misinformation to data privacy concerns, people are wary of brands that feel impersonal or deceptive. A 2023 Edelman Trust Barometer report found that only 62% of people trust businesses to do what is right.

The problem? Too many brands rely on corporate-speak, vague promises, and AI-generated content that lacks personality. But consumers don’t just want efficiency—they crave real, honest communication.

One example that stands out in my career is a campaign I worked on called Chosen for World Vision. The traditional child sponsorship model wasn’t resonating with younger donors because it placed all the power in the hands of the sponsor. We flipped the script—allowing children to choose their own sponsor, capturing their emotional reactions on video, and reshaping the donor’s role. The shift from transactional to relational marketing skyrocketed engagement. Why? Because it made people feel something.

AI CAN PERSONALIZE, BUT IT CAN’T REPLACE HUMAN EMOTION

The explosion of AI in marketing has been both a blessing and a challenge. AI can enhance personalization and efficiency, but it can’t build trust—because trust is built on human relationships.

Here’s the key: AI should enhance human connection, not replace it.

• AI-powered recommendations can improve customer experience, but a brand’s values and voice must guide its messaging.

• AI chatbots can assist in customer service, but complex, emotional interactions require real people.

• AI-generated content should always be refined by humans to ensure it maintains authenticity and emotional impact.

Take Starbucks’ AI-powered personalization strategy. Their Deep Brew AI system customizes rewards, offers, and in-app experiences for each user. However, Starbucks doesn’t rely on data alone—it reinforces trust through local community engagement, ethical sourcing, and in-store human interactions.

Brands that lean too heavily on AI without fostering real human connections will struggle to build lasting loyalty.

AUTHENTICITY IS THE NEW DIFFERENTIATOR

More than 70% of consumers say they prefer brands that align with their values. Authenticity isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s a business necessity.

Consumers quickly see through performative marketing. If a brand suddenly jumps on a social cause without a history of supporting it, the backlash can be swift (think Pepsi’s infamous Kendall Jenner ad). But when brands consistently stand for something, they earn trust.

A brand that does this well? Ben & Jerry’s. Their long-standing commitment to climate action, racial justice, and corporate responsibility isn’t just a marketing stunt—it’s ingrained in their brand DNA. They don’t just talk about issues; they actively fund initiatives, support advocacy efforts, and educate consumers. They walk the talk.

In my own work, I’ve helped brands shift from generic claims to storytelling that highlights real customer experiences. When people see themselves reflected in a brand’s message, they engage.

HOW BRANDS CAN BUILD TRUST IN AN AI-DRIVEN WORLD

So how can companies balance AI efficiency with human connection and authenticity? Here are three key strategies:

1. MEET CUSTOMERS WHERE THEY ARE—AND LISTEN FIRST

• Don’t assume—use social listening, focus groups, and direct engagement to uncover real consumer insights.

• AI can analyze data, but humans must interpret it to uncover deeper emotional drivers.

2. SHIFT FROM TRANSACTIONS TO RELATIONSHIPS

• Consumers don’t want to be sold to—they want to feel valued.

• Focus on storytelling and emotional connection, not just promotions.

• AI should assist in personalization, but brands must ensure the experience feels human.

3. EMPHASIZE TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY

• Be open about how AI is used—consumers want to know how their data is handled.

• Don’t just talk about social impact—show real action.

• If something goes wrong, own it. Honesty builds trust.

THE FUTURE: HUMAN-FIRST, AI-ASSISTED MARKETING

AI will continue to revolutionize marketing, but trust is built on human relationships. The brands that thrive will:

• Use AI to enhance (not replace) human connection.

• Communicate transparently without corporate jargon.

• Prioritize real, human-driven storytelling.

• Show—not just tell—what they stand for.

The future of marketing isn’t just about adopting the latest technology. It’s about staying human, relatable, and deeply connected to the people we serve. Because in the end, consumers don’t buy from brands—they buy from brands they trust.