Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

CEOs and the visibility trap

Four ways smart leaders get in trouble after they increase communications.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Beth Jannery

Founder & President · Titan CEO Advisory

From my experience working with CEOs today, they realize they have two jobs—running a business and communicating clearly. They want to focus on business growth and strategy, and tend to neglect messaging until absolutely necessary.

My advice: Proactively manage executive communications to avoid wasting time and money when a crisis hits.

CEO decisions shape employees’ perceptions of safety and trust, and their words influence how investors interpret momentum and risk. The CEO’s words signal to the outside world what kind of company this really is.

At this stage, leadership exists in the public eye, even if unintended. The boundary between internal and external communication starts to erode.

4 communication dangers for CEOs

CEOs now operate in an environment where internal messages travel outward quickly. A comment made in a meeting shows up in Slack. A clarification meant for a small group becomes a signal about values.

Many leaders respond to their new capabilities by trying to control the narrative or increase output. They tighten messaging and review every word. Here are ways any CEO can still find themselves in trouble.

1. The danger of quiet

The CEO may not be aware that, with more communication, silence begins to carry meaning. Internal teams are constantly interpreting what leaders say, what they don’t say, and how consistently they behave. CEOs must be on their communication game.

I recently watched a leader create confusion by remaining silent about a sales opportunity. He assumed a specific team was already working on a product launch, so he didn’t mention the launch in a team meeting. He left the work as the sales leader’s responsibility.

Since the CEO didn’t mention the launch at the meeting, the sales leader misinterpreted the silence as a sign that the launch was being deprioritized. What happened next? The sales team gravely missed the mark and didn’t come close to their original launch numbers.

I recommend keeping internal communications open and sharing a list of priorities to show their importance. For one client, I developed a communications dashboard so the CEO could monitor incoming questions each week. Team members can raise concerns quietly but efficiently, and priorities don’t get confused.

2. The danger of inconsistent comms

If communication accelerates faster than thinking, inconsistencies appear. When leaders speak before internal tensions are resolved, those tensions become visible to everyone else. Employees sense it, markets sense it, and trust erodes. There’s a big difference between what the CEO may want to do and what they actually can do.

Often, teams lose trust if an initiative is started before the communication cascade has come out, which should only happen after board approval (in this case).

Effective board communication can also stress company leaders. Without a head of executive content or communications advisor, the CEO is left to their own devices. One client spoke openly before running ideas by the board, so communication got out more quickly. Once the board got wind of those communications, the leader had to scale back how much was shared externally.

Bottom line: CEOs are meant to lead, but aren’t always meant to be a messaging expert. I see this all the time, and it’s unfortunate that many CEOs don’t realize it until they hit crisis mode.

3. The danger of silenced feedback

When working inside organizations, I’ve observed how communication is shaped by hierarchy, incentives, and fear of consequences. People bring insights, but they also bring caution. Even honest feedback is filtered through what feels safe to say. Over time, leaders receive more noise.

For example, an internal HR survey or employee feedback survey may appear confidential, with HR taking steps to ensure it remains so. But when employee confidence has eroded, employees don’t feel safe and hesitate to speak up for fear of being found out. “Why rock the boat?” they think. This damages the company’s internal employee culture because the leaders aren’t getting the truth.

4. The danger of perfection

As visibility increases, CEOs lose the ability to think imperfectly in public. Uncertainty is a normal part of good decision-making, but it starts to feel dangerous to express, and leaders begin editing themselves in real time.

One client felt overly cautious because, counter to the image of many CEOs, this leader tended to overshare. We scaled that back by creating a thought partnership and sometimes speaking daily before any event or meeting.

I’d hear the crux of the leader’s intended message and offer talking points to keep the leader on track. It took two to three times of scaling back, but the leader learned how to communicate with a preset call to action. Instead of winging it and editing himself as he went, he set out with a clear message.

In addition, he held back from oversharing with other C-suite members until an idea was fully baked, which helped avoid creating unmet expectations if an idea didn’t materialize.

Find your voice as CEO

As a CEO thought partner, I’ve helped effective CEOs think more clearly about what matters most:

  • Resist the urge: Don’t speak until you understand second‑order consequences.
  • Create a judgment-free space: So employees can share ideas and challenges.
  • Ask different questions: What will people infer from the statement? What assumptions will this reinforce? What tension does this surface that we haven’t named yet?
  • Learn to show, not tell: a truly great CEO will walk the walk, not just talk the talk. 

CEOs also recognize they cannot do this work alone. Modern leaders need strategic, operational, and sometimes emotional support, especially with their executive presence and narrative. They need their own CEO brand and narrative.

I’ve seen the most effective leaders communicate authentically, learning when and how to communicate to be heard and believed. This work happens before the message goes out. It happens before the post is written and before the meeting ends. Ideally, it happens before an internal or external messaging disaster occurs.

Beth Jannery is the CEO of Titan Global Advisory.