Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

College athletes are paid without a map

Instead of focusing on the size of the check, advisors should focus on setting up the player for holistic success.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Richard Gebbia

Co-CEO and Principal · Siebert Financial

The national debate surrounding name, image, and likeness (NIL) has been stuck on the wrong question for years. Commentators, athletic directors, and fans have spent endless airtime arguing over whether college athletes should get paid. But that debate is over. The checks are arriving, the transfer portal is churning daily, and the cat is out of the bag. The real issue, that almost nobody seems to want to address, is that we are handing 18-year-old kids life-changing sums of money without handing them a map to navigate it.

When you look at how these decisions happen in real time, the pressure on a young athlete is intense. For many families, a four-year collegiate window feels like winning a high-stakes lottery with a sudden expiration date. Because of that reality, immediate cash outlays drive the decision. Kids pick programs based on who has the highest bid today, rather than where their skills will develop to the next level. You occasionally see rare exceptions where a top prospect chooses a program based on long-term athletic fit rather than top dollar, but that restraint is hard to maintain when a family feels compelled to maximize immediate earnings.

That immediate focus creates a high-pressure environment. Parents and guardians carry the weight of wanting to secure their family’s financial standing in a single recruiting window. Yet in the rush to secure the largest check, very few stop to ask what happens once the contract is signed, the excitement settles, and the money actually hits the account.

THE ILLUSION OF THE LONG GAME

What catches families most off guard in this new landscape is not just how fast the money arrives, but how abruptly the noise stops. During recruitment, a family is courted constantly. The phone rings around the clock, coaches make sweeping promises, and the athlete is treated as the center of the university’s universe. The moment the contract is signed and the athlete walks through the facility doors, the recruiting circus ends, and parents suddenly find themselves on the outside looking in.

I lived that transition firsthand with my son, Tristan, when he signed to play quarterback at Nebraska. You go from being deeply involved in every conversation to realizing your child is now entirely in the hands of the coaching staff in a brand-new environment. It is a stark awakening for any parent, and it is a vivid lesson in how transactional elite sports can be. When an athlete is not prepared for that shift, they easily misinterpret temporary recruiting hype as permanent security.

REINVENT IDENTITY BEFORE THE WHISTLE BLOWS

The reality of high-level sports is that terrain changes in a heartbeat. Early in my financial career, we represented a high-profile NFL player. I remember sitting in meetings where franchise leadership swore he was the absolute future of the organization. Three days later, he was benched, and his role was completely altered. That is the nature of the industry. In a blink, the chair gets pulled right out from under you. If you do not have a plan built for that moment, you are left managing a lifestyle you can no longer sustain.

The hardest thing an athlete loses when their playing days end is not their income, but their identity. When you have spent your entire youth defined as a football player, walking off the field for the last time can feel like losing your anchor. Most athletes operate with a singular focus on reaching the professional level, which makes the end of the game psychologically devastating if they have not planned for a pivot.

When my playing days at Ole Miss came to an end and the NFL was no longer an option, my father pulled me aside and gave me advice that changed my trajectory: Take the exact same intensity you put into football and pour it into business. That mindset shift is what every athlete needs, but very few are taught how to execute it. They need guides who understand that transition, not traditional advisors looking solely for asset management targets. A modern advisor must understand the locker room, the deal structure, and the camera all at once. You have to wear five hats: advisor, sounding board, trainer, motivator, and strategist. If you are not managing the complete ecosystem, you are not actually protecting them.

THE ONLY MAP THAT ACTUALLY WORKS

So what does an actual financial map look like for a 19-year-old inheriting significant capital overnight? It is not complex financial jargon or speculative products. It starts with a fundamental principle my father taught me decades ago, one that remains undefeated across Wall Street and sports alike: Finish every single year with more money than you started with.

That sounds deceptively simple, but executing it requires true discipline in a culture built on rapid spending. A real roadmap forces an athlete to treat their earning window not as spending money, but as foundational capital. It means mapping out taxes, fees, and expenses long before the check clears, protecting the base before chasing upside. NIL capital is a powerful tool, but money without direction is just a temporary flash. We need to stop celebrating the size of the check and start focusing on the quality of the map.

Richard Gebbia is co-CEO and principal of Siebert Financial Corp and co-CEO of Gebbia Media.