Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Colleges serving a different kind of student matter

It’s time to broaden the definition of higher education excellence

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Mark D. Milliron

President and CEO · National University

For decades, old-school rankings and classic classifications have helped define what excellence looks like in higher education. However, in doing so, they’ve narrowed the nation’s vision. We can do better. We can widen the spotlight and find real difference makers in the process.

Let me be clear: There’s nothing wrong with highlighting the remarkable contributions of the country’s “top-tier” universities. Americans should be proud of the colleges and universities whose name recognition extends around the world. The premier research institutions that push the boundaries of knowledge, deliver breakthroughs in science and medicine, and expand understanding of the universe are national treasures. As are so many historically powerful small, liberal arts institutions, HBCUs, and more.

BROADEN THE DEFINITION

But pride shouldn’t stop there. It’s time to broaden the definition of excellence to include the array of institutions whose work may not make headlines but are every bit as essential to national progress. As the president of a university that almost exclusively serves nontraditional, working, and military-affiliated learners, it’s encouraging to see that many are making the case that it’s time to rethink how institutional success is recognized—coming together to celebrate a much wider range of colleges and universities.

This isn’t about symbolic pats on the back or recognition for its own sake. There is real risk in overlooking the institutions that educate the majority of today’s learners. To serve all students, we have to see all students, and that requires also seeing and celebrating the different kinds of institutions serving them.

Put simply, our current systems for classifying institutional types and qualities are not built for this wider view. Even federal reporting still relies heavily on “first-time, full-time, fall freshmen” as the primary profile for measuring student progress. At National University, an institution that serves nearly 50,000 students, just 36 students fit that category. And we’re not even close to alone in this challenge. Literally millions of students are rendered invisible by these data blind spots.

THE SHIFT

Fortunately, the paradigm is starting to shift. New approaches to evaluating institutional value are spotlighting a broader group of colleges and universities that deliver results for students, particularly students navigating higher education with limited resources or on less traditional pathways. One exciting step in this direction is the ACE and Carnegie Foundation’s new Opportunity Colleges and Universities (OCU) classification, which aims to identify and recognize institutions that advance social and economic mobility. This new classification system helps shine a bright light on institutions rated high in accessibility (e.g., high acceptance rates, low cost, flexible programming) and high in graduates’ earnings. Roughly 400 institutions, of the more than 4,500 in the U.S., meet this standard.

By focusing on who colleges serve and how well they serve them, this classification widens the frame and celebrates institutions that may never appear at the top of traditional rankings but are transforming lives and communities every day. Moreover, we send a signal to nontraditional, working, and military students that there are spaces and places that can and will serve them well.

The University of Maryland Global Campus (UMGC), for example, has focused for more than 75 years on serving working adults and military-affiliated students. With thousands of learners logging in from around the world, UMGC has built one of the largest footprints in online higher education. Its programs are designed with flexibility in mind so that students balancing jobs, families, and military service can persist and complete their degrees. It is an OCU.

Dallas College, meanwhile, is reimagining what access and success look like for tens of thousands of students in Texas. Many of its learners are the first in their families to pursue higher education, and the college has redesigned programs to ensure these students don’t just enroll, but finish. The college also works closely with local employers to prepare students to graduate with the specific skills Dallas’s growing economy demands. It is an OCU.

National University is an OCU too. We are made up of thousands of faculty and staff committed to helping nontraditional, working, and military students at all ages and stages succeed. Our doctoral, masters, and undergraduate degrees ensure that “ANDers”—students balancing school and work, and raising kids, and serving in the military—have high-quality education options.

HIGHLIGHT VITAL ROLES

The regional publics, community colleges, and independent universities that educate the majority of today’s students are every bit as critical to the nation’s future as the most “highly-ranked” institutions. We need to do better at highlighting their vital work. Indeed, the nation’s higher education system is best served by making sure every institution—from flagship research universities to local community colleges—can be recognized for the role they play in helping students rise. If these institutions do the work of helping our students rise and thrive, let’s bring them from the shadows into the light.

Mark D. Milliron, PhD, is president and CEO of National University