Have you ever wondered why someone repeatedly follows, comments on, and provokes a person they claim not to like? The subject of the disagreement changes, yet the person returns. They read, react, argue, wait for a response, and begin again.
Watching this pattern led me to ask, what is a person actually getting from the conflict?
That became the starting point for my conflict-as-contact hypothesis. It explores whether some repeated provocation is maintained because conflict produces something that may be missing elsewhere: attention, acknowledgement, and human contact.
WHEN LONELINESS CHANGES THE VALUE OF ATTENTION
There is already evidence that loneliness belongs in this conversation.
In 2019, Keita Masui studied 513 participants and found loneliness to be a positive predictor of internet trolling. His central finding was more nuanced: Loneliness amplified trolling particularly among people already high in Machiavellianism and psychopathy.
More recently, a 2025 study of 399 social media users found that revenge and loneliness both significantly predicted online trolling behavior. Revenge was the stronger predictor, but loneliness remained independently significant.
Neither finding means that loneliness causes trolling. My hypothesis asks a different question: Can the response created by provocation itself become rewarding because it provides acknowledgement and contact?
Think about someone who feels chronically lonely, overlooked, or socially invisible. Meaningful relationships take time. They require reciprocity, vulnerability, and another person’s willingness to participate.
Provocation can produce a response almost instantly. That creates an interesting psychological possibility: The emotional quality of a response and its social function may be very different.
An angry response is unpleasant, but it is still a response. An argument provides attention. A defensive reaction confirms that the provocation has reached another human being.
The emotion is negative but the contact is real.
WHEN PROVOCATION CREATES VISIBILITY
Consider this example. Maria follows a public figure online. They have no personal relationship. She leaves a provocative comment and receives a response.
She comments again. Other people join in. Some criticize her. Others argue with her. Within minutes, Maria has become part of an active social interaction.
Looking only at the content, we see disagreement and disapproval. Looking at what the interaction produces reveals something else: Maria receives attention, responses, and visibility.
If this happens repeatedly, a simple association may begin to form: I provoke, and people respond.
This does not have to be a conscious strategy. Human behavior is also shaped by what happens after we act.
I describe this possible mechanism as the conflict-attention-reinforcement loop. Conflict produces attention; attention provides acknowledgement; and the resulting interaction may increase the likelihood of the same strategy being used again.
WHEN THE RELATIONSHIP ALREADY EXISTS
Nikolay is a more complicated example, because he argues with people he has known for years. And sometimes he is right.
During a meeting, Nikolay challenges a decision and presents legitimate arguments. The group discusses them and resolves the issue.
Later, another disagreement emerges. Then another. The subjects change, while the interaction around them begins to look familiar. People explain themselves, try to persuade him, devote time to his objections, and gradually organize the conversation around his disagreement.
At that point, another question becomes useful: What does Nikolay receive from this recurring pattern?
It may be attention, significance, or access to meaningful interaction. The function may also be entirely different.
The hypothesis is not a diagnosis.
There is an important distinction between legitimate disagreement and a recurring pattern. When someone raises a substantive problem, resolving it usually ends the issue. In a recurring pattern, one issue is resolved and another soon appears, recreating a similar interaction.
WHAT THE CONFLICT PRODUCES
When conflict repeatedly appears around the same person, look beyond the immediate subject and observe what happens afterward.
Two questions are particularly useful: What does this person receive after the conflict? What happens when the usual prolonged reaction does not follow?
The conflict-as-contact hypothesis also proposes a simple test: neutral acknowledgement.
“I hear you.”
“I understand your position.”
The person receives confirmation that they have been heard without turning the disagreement into a prolonged confrontation.
If acknowledgement helps maintain the behavior, changing the way it is provided should affect what happens next. If the same pattern continues with the same intensity, another explanation becomes more plausible.
That is what makes the hypothesis testable. For now, it remains a hypothesis awaiting empirical testing.
Understanding the possible loneliness behind conflict does not excuse aggression, harassment, or abuse. Boundaries remain boundaries. But it can change what we notice.
Sometimes the person who enters other people’s lives most loudly may be experiencing the greatest absence of meaningful contact in their own.
The content of a conflict tells us what people are arguing about. Its function may tell us why they keep coming back.
Stoyana Natseva is the founder of Happy Life Academy.