While staying at a San Francisco hotel that charged a premium nightly rate, I ordered breakfast to the room. I opened the door to find a small delivery robot.
Cute, I thought. The robot resembled R2-D2. It rolled in and popped open revealing my mess of a breakfast tray. Orange juice had spilled across the waffles. The robot must have hit a wall on the way up.
I was left wondering whether automating this service is a good move for the hotel.
It’s the question every service business needs to answer before it automates anything that touches the customer. Not can we automate this, but what will be the customer’s perception of our service when we do?
The cost of getting it wrong
Conventional wisdom says automation is a lever for scaling more efficiently. That calculation works for many parts of an organization but the closer a task sits to the customer, the more visible that “efficiency” becomes for the client. With a cheap product, customers reason that automation is driving down their cost. With premium service—like the San Francisco hotel I stayed at—the customer didn’t choose you because you cost less. They chose you because they believe you perform better.
This is the question I’ve been sitting with as president and chief business officer of AURIX, a proprietary security automation platform owned by Specialized. In physical security, service quality isn’t just a feature of what we sell; it is what we sell.
In any premium service business, automation is not a cost-cutting strategy. It is a brand strategy. Every decision to remove a human from a moment that touches the customer is a statement about how much that moment is worth to your company. Get those decisions right and automation amplifies your value. Get them wrong and you’ve quietly told the customer that the experience they thought they were paying for was never really the point of your service.
The robot in the hallway didn’t fail because it was a robot. It failed because somewhere in that hotel’s operation, they decided breakfast delivery was a low-value task.
Understand low- versus high-value tasks
Every customer interaction in a service business falls somewhere on a spectrum of low- and high-value tasks. Low-value tasks are the repeatable, transactional work that keeps the operation moving. At Specialized, that looks like scheduling shifts, procuring uniforms, and corporate’s initial search for talent. All go unseen by the customer.
High-value tasks include how Specialized responds to incidents, and how its teams learn from those incidents. Almost everything in security becomes a high-value task because everything is important when safety is involved.
Before a company decides what to automate, it must be honest about what the customer is actually paying it to be excellent at—and how unforgiving the customer is when something goes wrong.
A fast-food restaurant putting a kiosk at the counter is meeting an expectation. A 4-star restaurant doing the same thing is upending one. The moment a customer sees a kiosk, they pattern-match and recategorize the business accordingly: premium or basic, quality or cheap. Most service businesses assume their customers see them the way they see themselves. That is almost never true.
When it comes to the human conversations behind the work—between leadership and the people delivering the service, between officers and clients in the moments that matter—there is still a need for human interaction. You can automate it. But the moment you commoditize the human, you commoditize the service. If your intention is to be a premium vendor or service, you want to create more opportunities for human interaction, not fewer, because each of these touchpoints is another opportunity to convey the quality of your brand. Each touchpoint is a reminder of why they chose you.
A lesson from modified foods
We have seen this story before but in a different industry. When genetically modified (GMO) foods first reached consumers, the promise was straightforward—cheaper, more abundant, more efficient. Arguably necessary, too, because we need to feed billions of people. But consumers were uncomfortable with lab-grown food.
Twenty-five years later, restaurants buy and serve GMO food, and most customers never know. Resorts do, too, because they want to maximize profit. I eat GMO food from time to time when it hasn’t been disclosed to me—but when I have a choice, I avoid it. And given the choice and the means, customers will pay a premium for what they believe to be real, and in this example, not lab grown.
There is a buyer for everything. But if an organization is going to thrive, it must make wise choices. Service businesses now stand where the food industry stood in the 1990s—rolling out automation everywhere, often before leadership has thought through how the customer will react.
Test for task value
Most leaders I talk to are already past the question of whether AI belongs in their operation. Of course it does. The harder question is where to draw the line, and how to know when you’ve drawn it in the wrong place.
Before you automate anything that touches your customer, ask these three questions.
1. What is the customer paying us for? If the answer is speed and convenience, automate. If the answer is attention or assurance, don’t.
2. If a competitor automated this same moment tomorrow, would our customers see it as innovation or as a tell? The honest answer almost always reveals where the line is.
3. Can the human in this moment be replaced without compromising our service? If you can’t answer yes with confidence, you’re looking at a high-value task.
The goal isn’t necessarily to automate less, but to identify the moments when it serves the brand and when it undermines it. If we were to implement this test with the room-service delivery robot, we’d learn that automation risks compromising quality service.
The difference between premium and basic
In the future, any advanced firm will automate low-value tasks, and many will automate high-value ones. Customers will come to expect the baseline of automated efficiency in every interaction—but they also will become increasingly aware of the moments when a human shows up. Those moments will reflect a firm that intentionally chose human engagement over an automated one. That signal will become the difference between premium and basic service.
Automate the scheduling, procurement, onboarding logistics, and reporting. With the resources saved, thoughtfully select and prioritize the moments your customer will remember because in those moments, their perception will be the difference between choosing you and choosing a competitor who raced to automate without discernment.
Lucian Corneliu is president of AURIX.