Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Coopetition as an engine for increased interoperability

Coopetition is an approach that forward-looking companies are embracing to achieve both greater customer satisfaction and increased interoperability within the tech ecosystem in which they operate.

Puzzle pieces

[Images: Gajus / Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Guy Yehiav

President · SmartSense by Digi

The technological pendulum swings between enterprises selecting one vendor for everything and choosing edge solutions that are discrete but best at the value they deliver for the specific needs for which they are developed. As technology customers require more and more integration capabilities between the solutions they purchase, technology providers are challenged with the task of collaborating with each other in mutually beneficial vendor relationships.

Coopetition is an approach that forward-looking companies are embracing to achieve both greater customer satisfaction and increased interoperability within the tech ecosystem in which they operate. Developing a business environment with standard protocols, open APIs, and sophisticated certification programs can ease the agreement process for technology vendors while maximizing the existing investments of customers.

ESTABLISHING AND DEFINING A UNIQUE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE 

To develop a competitive advantage, supply chain technology solution providers should select one or two capabilities in which to specialize. From end to end, there are several categories within the supply chain technology space: production scheduling, menu management, Build of Materials (BOM) management, sales and operations planning, integrated business planning, strategic network optimization, cross-docking, warehouse management, inventory management, automatic computer ordering, and more. No one company can be the best at delivering value across all of them. 

Once a technology solution provider has established an identity by optimizing for one or two specific capabilities, even if they are providing end-to-end solutions, it can then examine the other solution providers in the space and identify opportunities for integration. Business leaders need to view the market they’re playing in through the prism of customer value optimization. When the point of view of the customer is considered, possibilities for added value through integration with other solutions reveal themselves.

DEFINING A FRAMEWORK FOR COOPETITION 

There are three potential levels of overlap in capabilities that inform how a technology company should approach coopetition. First, a fellow solution provider in the space could be 100% complementary to your solution. Customers need both of your solutions in tandem to satisfy their operational needs. There is a natural partnership in this situation. Engaging in co-marketing opportunities and mutual referrals will make sense for both companies as they educate their customers on the efficiencies of purchasing and implementing both solutions. 

Second, one of the solution providers in the coopetition develops a capability similar to their partner.  Ongoing collaboration is still possible. Most likely, the new capability will be average at best and customers will have the choice to go with a basic capability or pay for the more optimized edge solution. The level to which the partners step on each other’s white space will determine if the coopetition can continue and prosper. 

Finally, if one of the competitors in the partnership develops the same core capability as the other with 100% overlap, then both are striving to be the best in the market, and it doesn’t make sense for either of the two companies to continue to engage in coopetition. This could happen through internal development or in the case of one of the solution providers acquiring a direct competitor of their partner. In this case, partnership doesn’t make sense for the competitors (who need to increase their market share) or the customers, who need to reduce redundancy in their tech stack, not increase it.  

NAVIGATING ASSOCIATED RISKS 

Of course, there are limits to collaboration and potential risks of coopetition, which is an always evolving area of business strategy. Your partner in coopetition could go out of business, get acquired, or develop their own solution that all but matches yours in performance. All these circumstances could become a reality for your partners in a short amount of time. That’s why it’s important to stay flexible and agile with a startup-like ability to change and pivot, doing so through a prism of value while examining the value pillars your company provides to its customers in tandem with your coopetition. 

Business leaders need to keep a constant tab on what their competitors and partners are doing as they engage in coopetition. They need to perceive if the potential partner poses no strong direct competition. In that case, there’s a straight line to integrating and adding value for customers. Then there’s a middle ground where the relationship continues until one of the partners steps too far into the other’s territory. And finally, the situation where direct competition of core competencies necessitates the refusal to cooperate or termination of an existing relationship. 

INCREASED INTEROPERABILITY FOR THE MARKET

There’s a long history of coopetition in technology markets leading to increased interoperability and positive externalities for providers and users alike. Microsoft and Apple’s coopetition is a great example. In 1997, Microsoft invested $150M in Apple, in part because they knew Apple had a user base that would be purchasing their software products. The interoperability between the two tech giants continues today, creating value for consumers of both brands by championing shared standards and trustworthy integrations. 

Shared standards and open APIs help support healthy competition in the market and give customers a greater variety of choices, which incentivizes solution providers to continue to innovate and provide exceptional customer experiences. Coopetition fuels open technology environments, generating continuity in solutions markets and maximizing value for customers and users. If solution providers are committed to agility, developing a strategic approach to coopetition is a worthwhile endeavor in the pursuit of increased growth and customer satisfaction.


Guy Yehiav is President of SmartSense.