Have you noticed that almost every company claims that they put their customers first? Most organizations that you’ve ever interacted with, whether they made you feel like their best friend or a burden, would say if asked that nothing is more important than their customers.
Amazon, for example, has set out to become “Earth’s most customer-centric company,” and the first of its leadership principles is “customer obsession”: “Leaders start with the customer and work backward. They work vigorously to earn and keep customer trust. Although leaders pay attention to competitors, they obsess over customers.”
And yet, search Amazon’s website and you’ll have to scroll past a half-dozen “promoted” items before you see what you were searching for—and good luck finding their customer service number! They aren’t the only company whose devotion to the customer has limits. We’ve all experienced “no quibbles” return policies that require a receipt, or refunds that for some reason must be in-store credit.
I propose a litmus test for any company calling themselves “customer first.” Will you allow your company’s current bottom line to suffer to serve your customers? There are reasonable limits, of course, but the basic logic stands: Your company can’t be customer-first if short-term profits are more important, so you must be willing to lose money, even if only in the short term.
CUSTOMER FOCUS FROM THEN TO NOW
The concept of customer focus traces its roots back to the early 20th century when the advent of department stores introduced novel practices, such as attentive service and hassle-free returns.
In the modern retail landscape, several companies have embraced customer-centricity as a core principle, reaping substantial rewards. Zappos, an online shoe and clothing retailer, disrupted the industry by prioritizing customer service and even allowing customers to return products within 365 days. This unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction led to a cult following and, ultimately, an acquisition by Amazon.
Nordstrom, a legacy brand, thrived by providing exceptional in-store experiences, including personalized styling and liberal return policies. This approach not only retained loyal customers but also attracted new ones seeking superior service.
Apple took things a step further. Renowned for its sleek design and intuitive user interfaces, Apple redefined retail with the introduction of Apple Stores in 2001. By blending innovative products with immersive experiences, Apple prioritized customer engagement and education, setting new benchmarks in the tech retail sector and fostering unprecedented customer loyalty.
Despite the good intentions of many retailers throughout the 1900s and 2000s, the prioritization of customer service over time has been surpassed by meeting Wall Street quarterly earnings. For example, many retailers have shifted to outsourced customer care centers with language barriers and profit-driven policies over those considered more customer-friendly.
CUSTOMER-FIRST IN A DIGITAL WORLD
All of the examples above are of physical retailers with whom it is possible to have one-on-one interactions. Today, 15% of all commerce happens online, and customer focus often must happen at the level of policies (generous return terms, for instance). Many companies struggle with providing strong customer service when they cannot interact with the customer face to face. However, a standout in the e-commerce realm is Warby Parker, which transformed the eyewear industry by offering affordable, stylish glasses online while leveraging a “try before you buy” home try-on program. By blending convenience with a customer-centric approach, the company disrupted traditional optical retail.
In the place of personal interaction, many online companies have focused on personalization. The advent of the digital age has revolutionized customer interactions, enabling companies to gather vast amounts of data and tailor experiences to individual preferences. This transformation has given rise to personalized marketing, predictive analytics, and seamless omnichannel experiences. E-commerce giants like Amazon and Netflix have set high benchmarks by offering personalized recommendations, curated content, and frictionless purchasing journeys.
Retailers’ use of data to provide personalized customer experiences sounds great, but is that really the intent? I would argue that the use of data to curate a customer’s experience on your website or app is a pure profit move to sell more, with true customer service taking a backseat.
Customers are often uneasy about the amount of data collected from them. This speaks to a lack of trust between consumers and companies. Consumers know that the businesses with which they interact will talk a big game about how customer-obsessed they are, but will ultimately choose profits. Similarly, they will talk about customer-friendly tailored experiences, but customers experience a data-hungry system that replaces human interaction with a poor facsimile to save the company money.
According to one study by PwC, only 27% of customers trust the companies they buy from, and they know that customer obsession is often only a marketing ploy and not something that companies are willing to fully commit to.
REAL CUSTOMER-FIRST POLICIES
What does real customer-first service look like? For my company, it means giving a client whose expectations we didn’t meet additional incentives or reduced fees. It means having human beings on hand to talk to our clients whenever there is a problem—even when email and AI helpdesks could save us money. It means believing that even if it costs you more in the short term, the gains from building trust with your customers through authenticity are far higher and pay dividends in the long term.
Bob Kaufman is the Founder and CEO of Connexpay.