We face problems every day, whether complex or frustratingly simple. When I visit my grocery store to buy yogurt, I face what seems like hundreds of options to satisfy my shopping list. Should I opt for the exotic, vaguely Scandinavian-sounding option or the one with a happy cow? When responsible for solving problems, we need to simplify the process. To do this, we outline steps designed to de-complexify the problem and determine the most effective solution that matches our main objectives.
BUILD A ROADMAP
Whether it’s a 10-minute, 10-month, or even a 10-year problem, the problem-solving process starts and ends with the desired end state. What are we trying to accomplish? What does good look like? What don’t we want to happen? Once we establish our goal, we can fill in the gaps by applying our resources and outlining the steps to get there.
This process might be as simple as thinking of the good, the bad, and the doable—or, for more complicated problems, using a hand-written mind map. I like a mind map for two reasons: It forces you to stop and think, and it often unlocks new connections and possibilities. Start with what you’re trying to achieve in the center of the paper, then branch out into related thoughts. From there, connect ideas to find a workable solution. At this point, you’ll have a rough “map” of the solution. Ultimately, how we map out our problem doesn’t matter; what matters is breaking the problem into smaller components.
SIMPLIFY THE COMPLEX
Our problem-solving strategy must be effective and efficient to avoid wasting time and energy. Consider pre-made sushi trays at the grocery store. Even selling a simple product is comprised of a complex set of factors. Retailers love this product because it’s grab-and-go, easy to make, and can be offered at a premium price with healthy margins. But it’s not without downsides.
The sushi has to be effectively chilled and has a short shelf life (yesterday’s sushi isn’t super popular). We can define the problem as, “How do we sell quality sushi to the lunch rush that will make profits but won’t make anyone sick?” The problem can become overwhelming as the multiple stakeholders—from the fish buyer to the refrigeration design engineer to the health and safety officer—try to balance their individual factors while trying to solve the overall problem.
In this retail example, these factors may fall into one of two buckets:
• Customer outcomes: Having fresh stock available at busy times at attractive prices.
• Operational outcomes: Selling quality sushi with correct food safety and healthy margins.
The first objective for grocery stores is to achieve a positive emotional outcome for customers—a great product at a great price. The second objective is to achieve positive commercial outcomes by optimizing the costs. Breaking the problem into smaller steps toward these objectives ensures we use time wisely by not heading down paths that might promote high customer satisfaction at an unsustainable delivery cost or vice versa.
Once the desired outcomes are established, we can use data to design, refine, and prove the effectiveness of the desired customer and operational outcomes. If you set up a sushi case and nobody buys the sushi, it could be the sushi quality (customer), the presentation (operational), the temperature controls (operational), or the price point (customer). Limiting the consideration to at least two outcome groups allows faster resolution by focusing the attention on where it’s needed.
HOW TO SOLVE THE UNSOLVABLE
Often, the desired outcome is straightforward. Unfortunately, solving what appears to be a simple task can become very complicated. Take the replacement of blown light tubes in a store. Dark lighting negatively impacts the store’s appearance, which annoys customers and management. Maintenance teams may delay the changes, as replacing lights is inefficient because the labor cost is often greater than the cost of the replacement light tube.
This problem may be defined by asking yourself, “How do we coordinate the replacement of blown lights at stores that won’t negatively impact the business but will limit maintenance costs?”
Solutions might involve capital initiatives to address the problem. Retailers could install LED tubes with longer lives, hence fewer replacements. The retailer could also move to a standard light fixture across the store fleet so there is only one tube type and size. But until lights can change themselves, a maintenance worker will still need to safely get up and down a ladder.
While this problem can’t entirely be solved in the short term, the smaller problems can be. Does the maintenance worker have accurate knowledge of the light tube before visiting the store? Are new tubes available when the job is scheduled? Can these repairs be included in scheduled maintenance visits to reduce the strain of on-call resources? Each of these questions can be addressed to make the act of replacing blown light tubes as efficient and effective as possible.
PRACTICAL PROBLEM-SOLVING IN PRACTICE
When the time comes to work out the solution, you want to know you’ve considered the problem from every relevant angle. Problem-solving should always start with the objective. Big, complex problems can be made easier to tackle by taking three steps:
1. Stop and consider what you are trying to do and what outcomes you want to achieve.
2. Make the problem easier to approach by breaking it down into sub-parts and de-complexifying it from two different outcome groups (e.g., financial and service or environment and compliance, etc.).
3. With each group’s clear objective, the sub-parts are planned out appropriately, leading to achieving the overall objective.
Problem-solving doesn’t have to be complex—the problems are already complex enough. But breaking a problem down into desired outcomes and manageable steps creates a roadmap to a solution. Mastering the art of problem-solving is applicable throughout life. You can use it on anything from deciding what yogurt to buy to figuring out how to manufacture and sell that same yogurt.
Sean is CFO- North America at City Facilities Management