Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Don’t measure the ROI of stuff you’re going to do anyway

And start with what matters most in marketing.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Andrea Lechner-Becker

Chief Strategy Officer · GNW Consulting

Marketers are obsessed with accountability, largely because of pressure from CEOs and boards. It’s why so many of us over-index on proving every dollar spent is measurable. But the reality is that when every campaign, channel, and event must justify its existence, teams think like auditors instead of growth strategists.

Yes, we want to show return on investment (ROI), but most of us would rather measure impact quarterly or annually, not weekly. Yet the short-term nature of sales drives that pressure.

It’s no wonder that only 52% of chief marketing officers (CMOs) and senior marketing leaders can prove marketing’s value and receive credit for its contribution to business outcomes. That gap is about a mindset.

About 80% of your marketing budget is non-negotiable. You’ll spend it no matter what. The real ROI lives in the 20% that’s experimental, creative, and risky.

How marketing teams measure ROI today (and why it hurts us)

If your team spends hours building dashboards to justify a website or to attend your industry’s biggest trade show, stop. Those audits reinforce a defensive posture.

In every industry, you can’t opt out of some marketing basics. Skip the trade show, and competitors whisper your company is struggling. Drop your website redesign and the sales team blames marketing when leads dry up. These are credibility questions.

The obsession with proving ROI on the inevitable wastes hours trying to quantify something that’s never going away, and distracts from the 20% of spend that actually deserves scrutiny: Your big bets, where real lift is possible.

Find the 20% that drives growth

Your 20% is where strategy, creativity, and innovation live. It’s where your team experiments with new platforms, campaigns, or new ways to stand out.

To isolate it:

  • List the non-negotiables, your 80%. The website, technologies (like chat and increasingly AI), core email, organic content engine, mandatory events, and branded paid.
  • Name three to five potential big bets. A new channel, guerrilla marketing campaign, product-led growth motion, community strategy, or bold partner play.
  • Assign one owner and one key performance indicator (KPI) per bet. No shared ownership or vague metrics.

For each, ask: What lift did this create against our baseline of pipeline, revenue, or reach? The baseline is powered by your 80% delivering predictable performance year after year. If the bet doesn’t move the baseline, replace it.

Explain your marketing budget to the CEO and CFO

Stop reporting ROI across the board and shift the conversation to portfolio management.

Show your CEO that 80% of the budget funds the reliable, proven foundation keeping the business visible and operational. Then highlight the strategic 20% and explain the chances you’re taking.

Present it simply:

  • 80% equals fixed investment
  • 20% equals growth investment

Build a one-page portfolio scorecard with the initiative and owner, a one-sentence hypothesis, one KPI tied to revenue math, a clear budget and time box for this quarter or half. Then, a decision at the period’s end: Either scale, iterate, or sunset.

When you do this, you start looking like a growth engine that knows how to allocate risk.

What marketing technology ROI data reveals

The State of Martech Implementation 2025 showed that successful companies allocate early enablement and training to ensure a strong adoption foundation, accounting for around 60% of their budgets. Reactive teams spent about 65% of their time cleaning up project mistakes.

The same logic applies to budgets. ROI shows up when you plan intelligently from the start and teach teams how to execute.

The data demonstrates that 58% of successful implementations hit ROI within six months. Only 33% of average ones do, and 28% never see ROI. Translate that to budgeting. When you fund adoption and training upfront, big bets pay off faster. Treating change as an afterthought leads to stalled bets and money spent on remediation instead of growth.

Examples of big bets that drive marketing growth

Think like a product manager, not a committee. Keep your test portfolio lean and visible, including a mix of thoughtful experiments across these categories:

  • Channel bet. Pilot Reddit or YouTube Shorts with creative built for the format, not recycled assets. KPI: Net-new qualified traffic or assisted pipeline.
  • Data bet. Enrich first-party data to unlock segmentation your competitors cannot touch. KPI: Conversion rate lift.
  • Automation bet. Replace two manual handoffs with automated triggers. KPI: Lead velocity or time to first response.
  • Content bet. Launch an opinionated editorial series that takes a stand. KPI: Subscriber growth and sourced pipeline.

Keep three to five of these live at any given time. Anything more, and you’re managing noise.

Pro Tip: Underpromise and overdeliver here. Be extraconservative with timeframes.

Marketing metrics that connect to revenue

Ditch vanity metrics. Measure what moves revenue:

  • Lift over baseline. Pipeline or revenue contribution versus the same period last year.
  • Time to impact. Days from launch to first qualified opportunity.
  • Efficiency. Customer acquisition cost shift for your target audience.
  • Adoption. For martech-heavy bets, ensure you track logins, feature usage, and campaign throughput.

Report these metrics monthly on one page—no 30-slide dashboard tours. Executives don’t need a sightseeing trip through your customer relationship management system.

The CMO’s real role during budget season

The CMO’s job is to protect the 80% that keeps the lights on and defend the 20% that could change the game. Tell the truth about what is fixed. Scrutinize only what deserves it.

The most effective CMOs do not report ROI on everything. They report on lift and how big bets moved the baseline. Ask yourself: Are you measuring performance, or proving you exist? The future belongs to CMOs who separate table stakes from transformation. Stop wasting time on the obvious. Measure what matters.

Andrea Lechner-Becker is the chief strategy officer at GNW Consulting.