Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Don’t outsource customer trust to an algorithm

Improve customer service without loss of empathy, guidance, and accountability.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Dustin Lemick

CEO/Founder · BriteCo

At BriteCo, we believe AI, technology, and automation can improve how we serve customers. But human involvement remains crucial when customers need care, especially in our line of work—jewelry coverage, which can include emotionally significant engagement rings, heirlooms, and other pieces that are impossible to put a simple price tag on.

As AI takes on more work, deciding what it can handle and what still requires human involvement directly affects our customer relationships.

The speed of AI’s progress can make it easy to overlook the need for judgment. Automation has an obvious efficiency case when a system can complete an exchange quickly and cost-effectively.

But effectiveness and efficiency don’t always reveal whether the customer also needs the company present during the experience.

I see many businesses treating the ability to automate as sufficient reason to automate. Yet unintentionally, the company diminishes the customer relationship by assigning the wrong part of the AI experience—such as claims servicing—to that relationship.

AI OVERREACH IS EASY TO MISS

Within company systems, AI overreach is hard to detect because the “working” process can produce accurate answers and close interactions quickly and cheaply, giving the company a favorable result. If a customer needs simple information or a routine action, AI can often respond faster and may deliver a better experience than a person.

But the trouble begins when a business applies this logic to an interaction that depends on judgment, empathy, or accountability. AI can’t necessarily understand what the customer needed from an exchange.

For example, in my industry, an insurance policy is a legal, contractual promise about how an insurer will respond to a future event. The customer asks the company to honor that promise when filing a claim. The claim interaction carries more weight because the customer relies on the company at the precise moment the coverage product is meant to perform, often in a moment of very real human stress.

In claims, empathy and guidance are critical. The customer needs a person who can understand their concern in context and guide them through the next steps. At BriteCo, humans reach out within one day of reported claims and walk the customer through what to expect from start to finish. They are then available by phone and email throughout the claims process.

AI can play a role and do useful work, such as ensuring the policy is active and compiling documents, without taking over the entire claims experience. A human employee remains part of the customer relationship while technology supports the underlying process.

Our standard is a fully curated, white-glove claims experience, and achieving it requires technology to support the service without displacing these human qualities. For our customers, that means a person who knows their name and their story, answers the phone, and stays with them until the jewelry is back in their hands after a theft or loss, or the wedding is made right.

WHAT HYBRID BY DESIGN REQUIRES

With “hybrid by design,” the human-AI balance varies by interaction type. Routine work may be fully automated, while a claim can retain human involvement even when AI supports part of the process.

At BriteCo, we start by asking what the customer needs from the interaction. If the interaction involves customer uncertainty, or a need for empathy or guidance—such as a first-time customer unsure where to start with getting a quote—we establish the human role at the outset. We can then decide what work AI should perform within that experience.

The model requires systems that preserve this distinction. We establish the role of human involvement in the original design if necessary for a successful interaction. We expect the boundary to move as AI improves, so each new capability should prompt another look at what the customer needs. We’ll keep testing the technology against the reason the customer came to us in the first place.

TRUST REMAINS THE COMPANY’S RESPONSIBILITY

Customers trust companies that select and define an algorithm’s role and decide when a person is available. The company remains responsible for the experience whether the work is performed by an employee, a model, or both.

As AI tools improve and become easier for competitors to acquire, the quality of the decisions governing their use becomes a more durable advantage. Putting a person into every routine task can make service needlessly slow, while removing one from a moment of truth can make a company appear efficient but leave customers less willing to trust it.

We foresee AI assisting with more work. We’ll use it where it improves the customer experience while keeping people present for delicate and important decisions. As the tools evolve, we’ll keep reassessing boundaries because customer trust remains our responsibility.

Dustin Lemick is the founder and CEO of BriteCo.