They say that 70% of businesses fail within their first decade. What if success itself is a leading cause of failure?
Twenty years ago, I founded my consulting firm in the basement of my home with no customers and limited resources. Today, we have over 1,000 clients—many of whom are familiar name brands or top private equity firms—and a 20-year track record of securing profitable growth every single year. We’ve built a total of five businesses, including a non-tech business that sold for tech multiples. It’s been a wild ride and at least 50% of our business success has been driven by a fear of screwing it up.
THE ART OF SCALING
Along the way, I figured out that you can get just about everything right, but if you are not careful, you can grow into oblivion. Growth puts tremendous stress on an organization and the art of scaling is a key skill that gets less attention than it deserves. A business is just a collection of processes, and having grown through a whole lot of inflection points, I’ve learned that all processes break with scale. All of them.
New entrepreneurs seldom fantasize about having great employee onboarding processes, but at some point, their competency in this area becomes relevant if they hope to scale. It may never break in spectacular fashion, but a mediocre onboarding process bleeds away performance through launch failures and poorly equipped team members. Most dangerously, it wastes time.
Every business has over one hundred processes and infrastructure components—from the sales motion to performance reviews and includes areas like organizational design—which can also break at scale. While it doesn’t make sense to have an industrial strength process in the early days, it’s critical to scale as the business grows from an entrepreneurial phase into a “real business.” Failure to upgrade seemingly boring processes creates friction in the business—and friction is the last thing you want.
Friction kills growth by distracting leadership and frustrating employees and customers. Eventually, operational friction kills culture and can destroy a business. Anyone who has ever worked in a high-growth environment that was chaotic and maddening with burnout-inducing intensity, role confusion, and a long list of other soul-crushing complaints has had a taste of friction. These are signs that a business’s growth rate exceeded the maturing of its processes.
DON’T SCALE MEDIOCRITY
We have a mantra, “don’t scale mediocrity,” which translates to a simple paranoia. As we grow, we ask, “What process is going to break next?” A process may not start out as mediocre, but as the company’s growth outstrips it, the process inevitably breaks down. Rebuilding processes before they break is the key to avoiding friction.
Here is a quick example. In the early days of the business, I was the chief sales guy, and later hired someone to replace me. I was able to spend a lot of time side by side with them and through osmosis, trained them. Last year, we onboarded a dozen salespeople in a single quarter and 80% of them have been successful—a statistic far better than the average, which is typically one out of two. In between the early days and last year, we learned hard lessons when we attempted to scale sales without building out our training and onboarding processes first. The very high failure rate of those early sales hires was the price we paid for it.
There is a huge bonus associated with having tight, effective processes that match your growth rate. Once they are in place and things are running smoothly, you can focus on next-level strategic efforts without distractions.
For example, due to our competent sales recruiting and onboarding processes, we have had more time to focus on refining our sales pitch and value proposition to drive a higher “sales close rate,” meaning the percentage of proposals we win. In 2022, that sales close rate was over 70% against an industry average of 30%. Just think about the time we saved. If we were average, we would have had to chase two to three times as many deals, do hundreds of additional proposals, spend millions on a bigger sales force, and likely would have been smaller and less profitable. The dividend from boring process investments can be extraordinary if you intelligently redirect your time and focus.
If a leader wants to scale smoothly—and every great leader should—they must get ahead of the growth curve and fix the things that growth will break. A business with limited friction is a lot more fun to run than one with constant small fires that threaten to flare up into full conflagration. Scaling mediocrity invites headaches and potential disaster. Pay the price now or pay it later, because growth doesn’t care.
Tom Beaty is the CEO of Insight Sourcing Group Holdings, Inc.