Family caregivers are the fastest-growing employee group. They cut across age and gender, although the majority are women. As companies look for ways to help these workers balance care and careers, they must be careful not to conflate eldercare with childcare.
According to SHRM, which issues an annual benefits survey, companies are offering fewer eldercare benefits than in prior years. And yet, caregivers of adults often find they have to reduce their hours, take a leave of absence, turn down promotions, or quit working altogether due to a lack of support. While it’s critical companies do more to retain workers who are caregivers of adults and bring benefits in line with what they offer workers who are parents, the two life stages require different solutions, as they are vastly different experiences. Here’s how:
CHILDCARE VS ELDERCARE
Parenting is visible in the workplace; eldercare is not. From a colleague’s growing stomach to photos of children displayed on a desk to discussions about coaching soccer or driving carpools, it’s common for employees to talk about their children at work, and even celebrate this life stage with baby showers for expectant and adoptive parents. Eldercare, on the other hand, is not a common conversation topic in the workplace.
Discussions, if any, among colleagues about an elderly parent’s need for assistance with bathing and dressing, chronic or terminal illness, dementia, or multiple doctors’ appointments are often hushed and fleeting. Coworkers may notice a caregiving colleague taking time off, leaving early, or fielding an abnormal number of personal calls at the office, but they likely don’t know why and are left to draw their own conclusions. This is why eldercare must be identified and normalized in the workplace.
Childcare follows a timeline; eldercare does not. For parents of healthy children who are hitting development milestones, childcare has some predictability. Parents know when and how often to schedule wellness checks, when and what hours their children will be in school, and when they will be on vacation. Therefore, they know when to schedule time off or backup care for their children.
Eldercare has no time frame. Family members have no idea when they might get the call that a family member fell or was rushed to the hospital. Even following a significant diagnosis, there is no predictability as to how a disease might progress or how quickly. Therefore, working caregivers cannot easily plan for coverage at work or at home. So, while it is encouraging to see companies expanding parental leave policies into family leave policies, leave is not a solution on its own. Flexibility is critical for adult family caregivers.
Bringing a child into the world is about new beginnings; eldercare is about endings. Assisting someone at or near the end of life is laden with grief. Employers must know this: Your adult family caregivers are grieving well before a family member or friend passes away. Early childhood is a series of firsts; later life is about lasts.
This is probably why, in a recent survey we conducted of working family caregivers, 90% of the respondents said having a support group or affinity group at work would be helpful. One respondent said, “I work in a terrific company where we all share a lot about our personal lives and caregiving experiences. But I am the only elder caregiver, and that can feel isolating.”
Adults have a say in their care; children typically do not. When a parent sends a child to school or drops them off at a daycare center, the child might protest, but ultimately, they comply. Dealing with adults is a different story. Assuming an adult has no cognitive decline, they have the final say in who cares for them and how. Adult children trying to offer support to another adult cannot simply develop a care plan that accommodates their work schedule. The plan must work for the person receiving the care first, and then the caregiver must figure out how they can or cannot help. That’s complex.
Many professionals plan to start a family; few plan for eldercare. In many cases, employees plan to start a family. They think about what becoming a parent will do to their finances and their careers. Too few people have planned for eldercare. They are unprepared for the disruption to their careers and they receive little or likely no training. Companies that offer caregivers education and flexibility can make a big difference in helping a caregiver manage this stage of their life.
So how should companies choose the benefits that best support caregiving employees? In the report, “The Caring Company,” Harvard Business School’s Joseph Fuller and Manjari Raman suggest companies conduct a care census to understand the magnitude of employees’ caring responsibilities and best support them during their “predictable and unpredictable life events.”
QUESTIONS TO ASK IN YOUR CARE CENSUS
Here are some questions to include in your care census. The answers can help inform your support programs.
- Are you providing care to a family member or friend? How old is the care recipient?
- If you are not already providing care, do you believe you will have caregiving responsibilities in the near future?
- Have your caregiving responsibilities impacted your ability to perform your job?
- Have your job responsibilities impacted your ability to provide care?
- How can our company support you?
In order to support your caregiving employees across all life stages, ask them what they need. There is no one better qualified to tell you.
Liz O’Donnell is the founder of Working Daughter, helping people balance eldercare and careers, and helping businesses support caregivers.