Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

ESG promises: What happens when you talk the talk but don’t walk the walk

Don’t just do something because it looks good at the moment. Think about your ability to make a long-term commitment to stay with the initiative and how it will ultimately shape your business.

Employees discussing ESG

[Images: Blue Planet Studio/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Brendan P Keegan

6X CEO – 21X Board Director – 2X WSJ Best Seller · bFEARLESS Ventures

Back in 2021, I had the privilege of attending COP26, the largest environmental conference in the world, in Glasgow, Scotland. It was a fantastic opportunity to learn and recommit to my company’s environmental, social, and governance (ESG) principles. But outside the conference, I encountered the largest protest I’ve ever witnessed. Thousands of people were picketing up a storm because companies had broken sustainability and social justice promises made to them. 

Although I didn’t approve of the destructive tactics some of the protestors used, seeing so many people rallying together left an impression on me. I realized just how important it was for me and my team to truly be careful with our ESG promises. 

DON’T MAKE PROMISES YOU CAN’T KEEP

It’s not unusual for organizations to make projection statements related to their ESG goals, such as claiming they’ll be completely carbon neutral by a specific year. Lots of companies sign up to join groups within different initiatives, too, which adds to the appearance of commitment and accountability.

Often, though, there are too many variables in play for leaders to know with absolute certainty they can keep their promises. Let’s say I have a client who isn’t sure if they’ll switch to electric vehicles over the next 10 years due to the nature of their transport. If they’re not sure what their business will need or look like at that time, it becomes much more difficult for me to make predictions and commitments for my own business, which provides their vehicles. 

This means, in a practical, operational sense, you have to find a better balance between ambitious targets and those with an exceptional likelihood of success due to the sufficient number of “knowns” involved. It’s better to set a slightly lower goal and keep your word than to set a goal so high you never reach it, fracturing consumer trust.

DON’T DO IT FOR THE HEADLINES OR COMPETITION

Events like COP26 are often accompanied by knee-jerk reactions from companies jumping on whatever initiatives they can, unveiling copious amounts of marketing around what they want to accomplish. After all, it’s easier to get publicity traction on things that are immediately newsworthy or trendy. 

Similarly, if your competitor is on a list of sustainable brands or makes a statement, you might feel like you have to make a move, too. But what happens when the event or trend of the hour is over? Every headline you’ve put out there is something you now have to do. 

Don’t just do something because it looks good at the moment. Think about your ability to make a long-term commitment to stay with the initiative and how it will ultimately shape your business. Simply doing what everyone else is doing isn’t what matters. It’s about the ability to deliver to your customers in the unique way you promised, based on all your differentiators. If other companies break their promises just for search engine rankings or to sound competitive and you don’t, you’re the one who wins.

LET’S TALK ABOUT THE LACK OF FUNDING

Leaders are often quick to draft a policy or legislation on an ESG issue without accounting for potential obstacles in the future. California typically leads in this area, as it did by approving a first-in-the-nation regulation requiring 100% of auto sales to be zero-emission vehicles by 2035. Behind the scenes, though, these types of proposals often hit funding walls. 

In March 2022, Congress released a final appropriations bill to fund the fiscal year 2022 that prioritized elements like logging and fossil fuel development on public lands while simultaneously limiting entities such as the Environmental Protection Agency. To stay true to promises, it’s essential to allocate necessary resources through effective, comprehensive planning. However, government regulation isn’t a fix-all. Legislation can also create certain budgeting obstacles for individuals and business leaders alike. 

For instance, you might not know if you should buy an EV if you don’t know whether your local municipality can afford to install a charging station near your house. Switching my company’s fleet to EVs sounds good to me, but did my representatives get the electric companies to cover 10% of the infrastructure build so my local grid could handle the 20 new stations I’ll need? Failing to address these issues only fuels the disillusionment that results from being all talk and no action.

ESG CHALLENGES ARE LOOMING—MEET THEM HEAD-ON

Europe leads the world in ESG adoption. Yet, European citizens have seen a pattern of statements followed by inaction for decades. They’ve had time to get angry about what’s happening with ESG (or perhaps more accurately, what’s not happening). Comparatively, the U.S. is behind not only Europe but Canada and Asia, too. 

With Europe teetering on the precipice of serious, large-scale protests, the continent serves as a harbinger of what’s to come. Realize that people aren’t giving lip service to ESG issues and be willing to transparently set targets you can realistically hit. Initially, you may feel like you’re not getting far enough, but once your workers and customers know they can trust you, you’ll be able to work together at warp speed. That’s the moment to measure your success—not a second before.


Brendan P. Keegan is Chairman, CEO and President of Merchants Fleet.