Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Every difficult moment is a gift

The challenge for leaders is to develop the discipline to find it.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Kurt Donnell

CEO · Freestar

Not long ago, I heard “oh, and one more thing” at the end of a one-on-one—the kind of statement that instantly puts a pit in my stomach followed by words I didn’t want to hear: “I’m sorry to do this, but I’ve accepted an offer.”

The departure of my chief revenue officer, a senior executive who was in many ways the face of the company, an absolute force of nature, and a dear friend, was completely unexpected.

My first reaction wasn’t calm and transition-focused, it was sheer dismay.

I immediately jumped to everything that could go wrong: a gaping hole in leadership, key projects grinding to a halt, and the demoralizing signal it sent to the rest of the organization. Plus, the daunting prospect of replacing someone who seemed irreplaceable, despite my regular refrain when we lose a good team member that we are all replaceable, myself included.

Then something wonderful happened. In the vacuum created by the departure, several vice presidents immediately stepped up and began taking over the CRO’s responsibilities, leading critical meetings and driving cross-team collaboration. They demonstrated an ownership and competence that had been tempered when the CRO was always available to intervene. This gave me time to zoom out and look at what skillsets the business needs now versus when we originally hired the CRO years ago. Unsurprisingly, we needed to hire a leader with a much different profile.

This situation is a great reminder of advice a good friend shared with me years ago: Every difficult moment is a gift. The challenge—for leaders, especially— is developing the discipline to find that gift.

Setbacks hijack our thinking

When something goes wrong at work—a deal falls through, a project fails, a key employee leaves—our reaction is often visceral. Our brains are wired to detect threats and respond quickly. Stress hormones kick in, narrowing our focus and pushing us toward urgency, blame, and binary thinking.

This fight-or-flight response may have been useful when survival depended on outrunning predators, but in modern organizations, it’s far less helpful, and often shows up at exactly the wrong moment when leaders need perspective and judgment most.

Recognizing this reaction for what it is—a reflex, not a directive—is the first step in finding the gift. With repetition, we can work on rewiring our brains so that we don’t succumb to the cortisol burst and instead turn these seeming losses into wins. 

Shift from victim to architect

One of the most useful mental shifts I’ve learned is to move from the innate “woe is me” response to an “architect” mindset. The victim asks: Why did this happen and how do we get back to where we were?The architect asks instead: How can we build something better from here?

That shift doesn’t deny reality or minimize pain. Losing a client or missing a forecast has real consequences. But while we can’t control the event itself, we can control how we respond, and what we choose to take away from it.

Making that shift after my CRO’s departure was eye-opening. The structure I assumed absolutely required her involvement clearly didn’t. Her departure exposed a choke point in our operations and opportunities for growth for the next generation of leaders. The gift wasn’t the loss but rather the clarity it brought about our bench strength and needs of the business going forward.

Look for these gifts

In my experience, most business challenges tend to offer at least four recurring gifts, if we’re willing to look for them:

1. Clarity

    Crisis has a way of stripping away the nonessential. When resources tighten or plans fall apart, priorities become obvious. Teams are forced to distinguish between what’s merely important and what’s truly critical.

    2. Resilience

      Organizations don’t build resilience during smooth quarters; they build it by navigating difficult ones. When teams work through real adversity, they gain confidence, cohesion, and proof that they can handle more than they thought. That organizational muscle compounds long after the moment passes.

      3. Innovation

        Constraints are often the spark for creative breakthroughs. When the old way stops working, teams are pushed to experiment, simplify, and rethink assumptions. Many of the most durable innovations I’ve seen didn’t emerge from brainstorming but from necessity.

        4. Humility

          Success can be a poor teacher and it’s easy to confuse favorable conditions with flawless execution. Setbacks, while painful, offer unfiltered feedback because they invite honest reflection: Where did we get complacent? What signals did we miss? What needs to change?

          None of these gifts will arrive neatly packaged. They’re usually buried under frustration, disappointment, or fatigue. But they’re there.

          Develop a gift-seeking culture

          This mindset can’t live only in a CEO’s head. If leaders want organizations that learn quickly and adapt well, they must normalize this kind of gift-seeking at every level. That starts with language. After a failure, asking “What can we learn?” is far more powerful than“Who’s responsible?”

          When teams see that insight is valued more than fault-finding, problems surface earlier and learning accelerates. Over time, people stop hiding mistakes and start extracting value from them.

          Some of the most meaningful progress I’ve seen in my own company has come directly from things going wrong: integrations that were harder than expected, operational missteps that forced us to tighten systems, and growing pains that exposed where we needed to invest earlier. None of those moments felt like gifts at the time, but in hindsight, many were.

          Final thoughts

          Leadership isn’t about maintaining the illusion that everything is under control or being constantly reachable. It’s about helping people navigate reality with perspective and purpose, even when things feel uncertain.

          The same instinct that made me panic when I lost our CRO is the one that tempts leaders to overcorrect, over-function, or rush to label adversity as failure.

          Leaders don’t need to lose a key employee to gain that perspective, but they do need the discipline to step back long enough to question their assumptions. When they do, they often discover that what first looked like a disruption was actually an invitation to lead differently—and better. As other famous leaders have said, never let a good crisis go to waste.

          Kurt Donnell is CEO of Freestar.