In his now famous 2021 blog post, media strategist Eric Seufert confidently proclaimed, “Everything is an ad network.” Due to the emergence of privacy law and fundamental changes occurring in the digital ecosystem, he argued, many organizations would choose to create new business models predicated on selling advertising inventory to monetize web traffic and first-party data—in effect, becoming ad networks.
Three years later, it’s difficult to argue he wasn’t right: Dozens of new, fast-growing ad networks have exploded on the scene—an exciting dynamic that has shattered the world of digital media seemingly into a thousand pieces. Among other things, this new environment features the meteoric rise of retail media, now a $45b+ business, and its challenge to the hitherto indomitable digital “duopoly” of Google and Meta.
Change is gathering pace as the world adjusts to this new reality of a splintered online media marketplace. Organizations of all stripes are looking to cash in on the new digital gold rush. Everywhere you look, it’s a non-stop AdTech party, and everyone is invited—retailers, publishers, broadcasters … even rideshare companies.
To make this happen, organizations are busy updating their tech stacks and making unprecedented investments in advertising technology (AdTech). Data clean rooms, supply side platforms, trading desks, and even Meta DSPs are popping up left and right. Is it time for a corollary to Seufert’s thesis? Is everyone now an AdTech company?
END OF AN ERA
Underpinning the belief that we would witness a proliferation of ad networks is the idea that rapid rollout and global adoption of privacy laws—GDPR, CCPA, CPRA, DMA, DSA, etc.—were striking at the very foundation on which digital advertising was built—or at least the way it has been operating for the past couple decades—with virtually unlimited access to user data and behavioral signals being used to target consumers with digital advertising.
In the new privacy-first era that is emerging in the wake of these statutes, tags, trackers, and cookies are disappearing as consumers are given broad rights over their personally identifiable information (PII), which is increasingly locked down and encrypted, if it is gathered at all. Brands are now asking, “Should I collect this data?” and not “Can I?”
These changes are paving the way to an online world in which the center of gravity is gradually shifting from platforms like Google and Meta, along with data aggregators, to companies with healthy online businesses and consented user data. As the age of third-party data-fueled programmatic advertising fades, the balance of power is shifting back to publishers with a new-found ability to monetize their assets, of which first-party data is perhaps the most important.
FADING DUOPOLY
The slow demise of the Google/Meta advertising “duopoly,” as it is often referred, has gathered pace. As recently as 2017, the two companies accounted for approximately 55% of the overall market, with Google’s ad revenues accounting for 35% of the market, and Meta accounting for 20%. Not only did the duopoly account for the majority of all online ad dollars, but close to 90% of all growth in ad spend went to their coffers.
Fast forward a few short years and we are in a radically different environment. This past year, their share fell to 48.4%, the first time the two have not held a majority share since 2014, reports Ars Technica. Most industry experts expect this decline to continue for “many years to come,” says the WSJ. New players are emerging and audiences are increasingly going to other places, creating more media options for brands.
The duopoly’s decline has been driven mostly by the rise of retail media networks. For those unfamiliar with the term, a retail media network is an advertising platform built on top of an e-commerce business that enables retailers to sell inventory (ad space) to third-party brands. Led by Amazon Ads but also including Walmart, Kroger, and a host of others, retail media surpassed $100 billion, according to GroupM, representing 18% of all global digital advertising.
In addition to retail media, a wide variety of other ad networks have sprung up, including TikTok, Apple, and Pinterest, to name but a few. Uber’s ad network, for example, generated a run rate of $650 million in 2023. It’s not so much that the duopoly has crashed to Earth, but other players have risen to make the online ad space more crowded, diverse, and interesting.
EVERYONE IS AN ADTECH COMPANY
Seufert painted a future world in which “any company with sufficient supply of or access to consumer data” would be able to build an advertising network given the new competitive landscape. Time has proven his thesis correct, as countless ad networks have bloomed. So, where do we go from here?
The rise of privacy laws and the continued evolution of walled gardens are compelling media and entertainment organizations—especially broadcasters and publishers—to execute strategies to monetize digital traffic and unlock the value of first-party data. These moves require serious AdTech.
Across the industry, organizations are busy updating their tech stacks and making unprecedented investments in AdTech. Publishers are building supply-side platforms (SSPs). Broadcasters are standing up data clean rooms and white labeling demand-side platforms (DPSs). Agencies are hiring data scientists to build identity solutions with data from across the advertising world.
A great example of this trend is the recent announcement by TV New Zealand, the state-owned national broadcaster, that they had launched a new AdTech solution to offer advertisers “personalized advertising while protecting viewer data and privacy.” This novel solution, which was built using AWS Clean Room technology to collect audience viewership data, including show preferences and viewing trends, collaborates with advertising partners. This sort of investment by a broadcaster would have been unimaginable previously.
In 2024, these trends are likely to persist, and leading players will continue to make serious investments in AdTech components, including SSPs, data clean rooms, ad networks, identify solutions, and more. It’s a non-stop AdTech party, and everyone is an AdTech company.
Rio Longacre is a Managing Director at Slalom Consulting and has two decades of experience in the digital trenches.