Leaders seem to want to be first. The first to adopt, launch, and create the next big thing. But in industries that face constant disruption—which, let’s be honest, is most industries these days—being first and launching a profitable service or product are not the same thing. In many cases, they’re not even close.
In advertising tech, we’ve seen a lot of volatility in recent years, from format shifts to privacy regulations, supply path upheaval, and now AI. What may be best practice on one day can flip in less than six months. It’s an environment that doesn’t reward the first to market. Often, it’s the fast followers that ultimately pull ahead.
FIRST MOVER ADVANTAGE IS (MOSTLY) A MYTH
There’s a huge difference between moving quickly and moving strategically. The businesses that have the most successful launches aren’t necessarily the ones who were first to market—it’s the ones who got there at the right time and who read the market strategically.
Uber’s evolution is a great example of this that always sticks with me. It started as a strictly black-car-and-limo platform. Then they saw Lyft’s success with peer-to-peer ride-sharing and quickly pivoted to what seemed like a better long-term model. Later, after Postmates and others proved there was demand for more flexible food delivery, Uber used its existing infrastructure to expand. They watched the market closely, stayed agile, and moved quickly when the time was right. This is the perfect example of a fast follower.
Uber isn’t alone. Facebook wasn’t the first social network. But nobody is talking about Friendster or Myspace anymore. The iPhone wasn’t the first smartphone either. But it drove Blackberry to its grave. In each case, the company with long-lasting success was better timed and executed rather than being the first to market.
DON’T LET AI PUSH YOU INTO BEING A FIRST MOVER
Today’s leaders are up against a new pressure brought on by AI. It has greatly compressed the time between initial idea and execution, making the time between concept and prototype nearly instant. Many will probably say that’s an advantage, which is true in some cases. But it also makes it dangerously fast and easy to go down the wrong path.
When it comes to deciding whether we take on a new initiative, my decision matrix is simple: If the concept took a full quarter to build without AI, would we still do it? If the honest answer is no that tells me we might be chasing an idea because it’s exciting, not because it solves a problem. The speed we’ve gained from AI doesn’t change the fundamental question: Does this solve a real problem, and will customers pay for it?
A common mistake I see during disruption is confusing market excitement with viability. Customers will give positive feedback on a product or rave during demos, but there’s a huge difference between compliments and opening wallets.
I witnessed this firsthand. We were deep in diligence for an acquisition that looked like a perfect fit on paper. We talked to several customers; everyone loved it, thought it was amazing, and didn’t want it to disappear. But when it came to getting them to sign even a one-year contract renewal, we couldn’t secure a single commitment. The customers loved it, just not enough to pay for it. We dodged a bullet by taking the time to ask the hard questions before committing. AI can help you build faster, but it can’t tell you if what you’ve built is worth buying.
FAST FOLLOWERS WILL USUALLY HAVE THE REAL ADVANTAGE
Fast followers are closely monitoring the first movers and emerging marketplace trends, making sure not to jump before true value is proven. Instead of being the first to epically fail or find out the hard way, they’re taking a beat to watch early movers, ask questions, run tests, and make strategic decisions with real data. The fast follower gets most of the learnings that the first mover paid for dearly but for free.
The two critical questions to ask before making a move:
- Can anyone explain why this is needed in an elevator pitch?
- Will customers sign an agreement for it? Not theoretically. Actually.
At the end of the day, those are the two signals that matter. Use AI to reach the MVP stage but pause to really test the market before going too far with a first-to-market solution that may not be needed.
The future will keep rewarding speed. But the real question worth asking is whether you’re moving in the right direction at the right time rather than focusing on if you’re moving fast enough. The most successful businesses aren’t always the ones to launch first. They’re the fast followers who watch, wait, and move quickly when the time is right.
Kurt Donnell is CEO of Freestar.