Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Five common mistakes of first-time CEOs

First-time CEOs have a unique challenge in transitioning into a role that only a small number of others have ever held.

Leader and her team

[Images: Drazen/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Tracy L. Lawrence

Starting any new job can be daunting. But when that job is chief executive officer, mistakes may have implications for the entire organization, as well as for investors and other stakeholders. First-time CEOs have a unique challenge in transitioning into a role that only a small number of others have ever held. The first-time CEO often navigates their new role in the face of ambiguity and with little guidance.

In my advisory work, I observe the following common mistakes made by first-time CEOs:

1. STILL PERFORMING THEIR LAST JOB

The newly minted CEO was typically a stellar performer in their last role, which is why they were tapped to become chief executive. In their new role, the leader may develop an over-identification with that last position, when they were “in the zone” and delivering at a high level. For example, a CEO with a strong track record in sales and marketing may invest most of their time and energy in these areas because it plays to their strengths.

However, one of the most important functions of the CEO is to build an organization that is capable of delivering on the strategic priorities of the company. When a CEO continues to function more like a department head, their behavior can create a leadership void, resulting in a lack of focus on critical areas of the business.

CEOs should think intentionally about what success in the role means to the organization. What are the ways in which you can uniquely add value to the entire company?

2. NOT RECOGNIZING CHANGES IN POWER DYNAMICS 

First-time CEOs may have trouble adjusting to the fact that they now have no peers within the organization. The CEO may have risen to this level because of strong relationships within the team, or expertise in one particular field. New leaders may continue to lean on old relationships with former peers, not realizing the dramatic shift in power dynamics. Everything a CEO says and does has far-reaching implications for others. Venting frustrations, expressing fears and doubts, or gossiping about other employees can derail efforts to establish a leadership presence.

The first-time CEO should re-evaluate relationships and alliances in light of their new position. CEOs have more stakeholders than peers, and their actions on a day-to-day basis should reflect this.

3. PRIORITIZING CERTAINTY OVER JUDGMENT IN DECISION-MAKING

When rising up the ladder, executives are often praised for their ability to analyze existing information and make solid, fact-based recommendations. However, greater seniority demands greater comfort when making decisions with partial information. Markets change, industries change, and companies change. C-Suite executives are valuable because of their ability to base decisions on their own judgment.

Newly-minted CEOs can have a tendency to want more and more information, and can be hesitant to make decisions in the absence of clear data or facts. A chief executive must be able to leverage experience, knowledge, and intuition in making wide-ranging decisions that have big implications.

4. AVOIDING CONFLICT

Senior leaders often want to be liked. But higher-level decision-making may not leave all stakeholders feeling happy. Effective leaders have the judgment and instincts to know how to make decisions that may not be popular with everyone, but that will move the business forward. Some new leaders hesitate to take decisive action out of fear of disappointing people. Furthermore, healthy tension can be a positive, constructive force in the company when utilized correctly. A strong leader can cultivate a culture that can withstand difficult conversations, thereby allowing the best ideas to emerge.

5. FAILING TO BUILD A FUNCTIONAL LEADERSHIP TEAM

One of the most common mistakes I’ve seen derail a chief executive is the inability to build and lead a strong senior team. Inexperienced leaders may hesitate to take bold action, such as restructuring their leadership teams or moving out department heads who have not bought into the new plan. This kind of hesitation is a missed opportunity to articulate a new vision for the organization and demonstrate leadership acumen.

Successful chief executives should typically target having a full leadership team in place within six to 12 months, depending on market and organizational conditions.

Making the transition from successful executive to chief executive officer is perhaps the biggest leap any leader will make. Past experiences and training are not always directly applicable to the new role. First-time CEOs should take a more expansive viewpoint on their new responsibilities and seek out support from trusted advisors to provide a balanced perspective on the demands of the new job.


Tracy L. Lawrence is Founder and CEO of The Lawrence Advisory, a leadership coaching and consulting firm.