Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Five steps to hiring the leader you want vs. the leader you need

Hiring someone who thinks like you might be a short-term solution to maintaining the bottom line. But it may not be the solution that will carry you further into the future.

Employees smiling

[Images: Adobe Stock/peopleimages.com]

Profile photo of Tim Foot

Many executives step into the hiring process clouded by a certain vision of the leader they want to hire.

But they could save a lot of time and energy by pausing to ask what kind of person their organization needs—not just for now, but for the future.

Until you understand who you are and where you want to go, you won’t be able to define the ideal leader who can help move your company or your culture forward. Identity determines function, meaning: Who you are and where you’re headed as an organization determines how you get there as well as who you hire along the way.

Understanding identity and direction is especially important for teams waking up to the need for greater diversity, equity, and inclusion. If you want diverse perspectives, equitable environments, and inclusive practices, then think beyond your own wants.

Christopher Cabrera, founder and CEO of Xactly software company, admits inherent bias may unconsciously drive hiring decisions. Halfway through a big hiring process early in his career, Cabrera’s boss—who was African American—pointed out that his first four hires were all 20-something white males. The lesson learned: We do what makes us feel most comfortable if we’re not paying attention.

Hiring someone who thinks like you might be a short-term solution to maintaining the bottom line. But it may not be the solution that will carry you further into the future.

Here are action steps to guide you and your colleagues in determining who you want versus who your organization needs.

FIVE STEPS TO DETERMINE WANT VS. NEED

Need always has the drive.

When it comes to hiring, it’s easy to get blinded by the leader you want rather than the leader you need.

To avoid this trap, I encourage hiring managers to take these five critical steps. These steps are based on my own experience as CEO, as well as what’s worked best for our search partners at Slingshot Group.

1. CLARIFY YOUR IDENTITY

Answer the questions:

  • Who are we?
  • What is our why?

Dust off your vision and mission statement and your company values. Make sure they’re still applicable in the present and still work as the guardrails you need to guide your organization into the future. If not, do the clarifying work needed so you can tell a better story, do the work you intend to do, and cast a greater vision moving forward.

2. DETERMINE WHO’S MISSING

Answer these questions:

  • What role is missing from our org structure?
  • What kind of person is missing from our team?

There will be times when your answers to these questions compete with one another. For example, perhaps your team would benefit from adding a particular personality, perspective, or skill set, but there isn’t an open role.

Or, you may need a grounded, steady individual with attention to detail, but there’s no budget for the administrative or operational role that attracts this kind of person.

Sometimes there’s even a need for an additional role that requires a personality or skill set similar to what’s already represented on your team.

Determine who or what is missing, then prioritize your next hire: the person or the role.

3. INVOLVE KEY STAKEHOLDERS

Answer the question:

  • Who else needs to be involved in this hiring decision?

When we help organizations hire new leaders, most teams are quick to make a list of key individuals they want to involve in the process. But they usually miss a few. Assistants and operations people, as well as volunteers, are just as crucial to this process as board members and executive-level peers.

4. CONDUCT CROSS-FUNCTIONAL INTERVIEWS

Answer the questions:

  • Which teams will this role or individual interact with consistently?
  • How do we include those individuals and teams in the interview process?

Cross-functional stakeholders will have different perspectives on candidates. Invite their perspective into the hiring process, welcome their presence in group interviews, and solicit their feedback as you make your decision. 

5. CONSIDER WHAT’S NEEDED FOR CHANGE

Answer the questions:

  • What are our future objectives?
  • What kind of leader is needed for our trajectory of change?

The only time you should let what you want drive your hiring process is when your company or team needs to grow into an area to bring about change. We call this an aspirationalhire. The areas you’ve identified for growth are the areas in which it’s appropriate to consider who you want to hire.

IT ALL COMES BACK TO IDENTITY

Identity is the foundational bedrock of our lives. It’s how we show up in the world and make crucial decisions, even (especially) when no one is looking. This is true for us as individuals, and it’s true for our organizations.

When you know who you are, what you do, how you do it, and why you stand for the things you stand for as a company, you can attract the appropriate, talented individuals you need. Nine times out of 10, those individuals are looking for an organizational culture in which they align well—one that’s connected to their own sense of identity. That’s why it’s important to create a hiring process built on the foundation of your company’s identity.

Determining and hiring the leader you need can get you to the desired destination you want… so you sustain a remarkable organization today while building a compelling vision for tomorrow.


Tim Foot is the CEO of Slingshot Group.