Imagine you’re a retailer in January, sifting through boxes of holiday returns. You’re trying to distinguish between worn and unworn clothing, find cracks in electronic device screens, and ensure all accessories are still there, such as laptop cables.
While this may seem like an impossible task, it’s quite common and necessary in retail. It’s the first step in dispositioning, or the process of deciding what to do with a returned item. It’s also the first in a chain of retailer actions to identify which products can go back on the shelves.
While complex and costly, efficiency is essential because returns are a supply chain and an environmental problem. In the U.S., total returns for the retail industry were projected to reach almost $850 billion in 2025. That’s an enormous stream of inventory moving in reverse through networks designed for speed in one direction.
As a chief sustainability officer, I look at returns a little differently. Every return is a second trip, a second touch, and a second set of emissions. And if the item is ultimately destroyed or landfilled, it’s also wasted materials, water, and energy.
What really happens after you click “return”
The normalization of free returns arrived with the rise of direct-to-consumer brands and e-commerce. Free returns reduce purchase risk for consumers.
Whether returning defective equipment or simply sending back shoes that don’t fit, few shoppers consider what happens to products after a return to the retailer. And while awareness of the returns challenge is growing, many consumers still imagine their returned product will be repaired, or refurbished, repackaged, and resold. Not sent to a landfill or warehouse purgatory.
Meanwhile, the retail business, which optimized the process of getting goods out to consumers, isn’t set up to do the reverse and process returned products with speed, data, and consistent decision-making. Retail perfected “ship it fast.” Returns require “decide it fast.”
So for retailers, the truth is sobering. Shelf-ready products must be unused and in excellent condition. For seasonal products, the item cannot be resold, regardless of its condition. Fewer than half (47%) of returned goods are resold at full price, 42% sold for less, and about 12% are never resold.
Retailers may also use charitable donations as a sustainable alternative to destroying or landfilling products. However, returned goods may not necessarily be in good enough condition to be given to charity stores, and many charities don’t accept donations of electrical products.
Options for returns then become far less sustainable, with choices of landfill or incineration.
Sustainability pressure and regulation drive change
An estimated 8.4 billion pounds of returned U.S. goods ended up in landfills in 2023.
The destruction of unsold products directly generates waste and pollution and wastes the energy, water, and raw materials used in the production of goods. When a return is trashed, so is everything that went into making it.
Pressure for change is mounting. First, consumers are becoming more aware of the environmental damage caused by the disposal of unwanted goods. According to Blue Yonder’s 2025 Global Consumer Retail Returns Survey, 65% of consumers are somewhat concerned about the environmental impact of returns, and 71% said they wouldn’t return an item if they found out it might end up in a landfill.
Meanwhile, legislation around waste is tightening, particularly in Europe. The European Commission’s new rules will prevent the destruction of unsold clothes and shoes. The ban applies to large companies beginning in July 2026, with a 2030 timeline for medium-sized companies.
The direction is clear. “Throw it away” is becoming harder to justify and easier to penalize.
All this puts pressure on retailers to recommerce more of those products. The question is, how?
3 return solutions for retailers
Solutions are emerging to some of the sustainability challenges associated with collecting returns. For example:
1. Use drop-off kiosks. This offers consumer convenience while reducing transportation-related return costs. The kiosks cut associated emissions by harnessing existing store logistics and systems and consolidating returned products into bulk shipments.
2. Automate the dispositioning process. Returns management systems can use AI analytics, image recognition, and machine learning to speed up everything from inspecting returned products to sorting and grading them, all while reducing human error. This helps get products back on the shelves faster.
3. Leverage partnerships and shared data. For example, warehouse technology can incorporate prebuilt connectors to popular recommerce vendors, making it easy to route returns automatically, minimize financial loss, and prevent vast amounts of waste from ending up in landfills.
Of course, managing reverse logistics and dispositioning are more complex processes than selling and delivering new goods. However, innovative logistics and new technologies provide consumers with more flexible return options and make it easier for retailers to match products in different conditions to the highest-value endpoints.
The goal is simple. Move returned inventory to its next best home before time, labor, and uncertainty erase its value. This helps conserve both value and planetary resources without asking consumers to carry the burden of “being sustainable.”
Winning companies will redesign the reverse supply chain, not just tweak policy. And they will treat the landfill as a point of failure, not a cost of doing business.
Saskia van Gendt is the chief sustainability officer of Blue Yonder.