Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

From passenger to pilot: How managers help in an era of uncertainty

If you are a manager, here are five ways you can help your employees foster optimism and agency in the workplace.

Group of professionals looking at a tablet

[Images: Adobe Stock / auremar]

Profile photo of Christine Carter

Every day, there are new headlines about rising loneliness and how bad it feels, the toll that the upcoming American presidential election is having on our mental health, and increasing disengagement at work. This news can feel like a self-fulfilling prophecy; if you aren’t anxious, simply check your feeds, and the media will give you a reason to be.

Fortunately, if you’re ready for some good news, I have it for you: More than a quarter of our workforce is actually doing quite well. Over the last 15 months, BetterUp Labs partnered with Jeff Hancock and the Stanford Social Media Lab to follow over 10,000 workers across 18 industries to understand how AI is changing the nature of work—and what employees need from their managers as a result. Across that dataset, two different personas emerged that can help us identify the factors that help people navigate these turbulent times: “Passengers” and “Pilots.”

Pilots, who make up 37% of the workforce, are those remarkable individuals who combine optimism with a strong sense of agency. They believe they have the skills and resources they need to excel. They are significantly more emotionally energized at work than Passengers, who make up 5.5% of the workforce and who often lack confidence in their abilities and struggle to see a clear path to accomplishing their goals. 

Something else that’s encouraging: Managers play a pivotal role in fostering Pilot mindsets. While many factors influence our optimism and sense of agency at work—not least of which are organizational culture and our co-workers—the BetterUp research shows that it’s managers that tend to have the most significant impact.

How? If you are a manager, here are the ways that you can help people become Pilots at work:

1. CARE FOR AND ABOUT YOUR PEOPLE

In an era of AI, people increasingly want empathy from their managers. When people feel seen, heard, valued, and cared for at work, they experience up to 89% greater growth in agency and optimism, which characterizes the Pilot mindset. 

As a manager, you have a unique opportunity to not just show your team members empathy, but also to articulate their value to the organization. By doing so, you foster two more key factors needed for the Pilot mindset: a strong sense of belonging and organizational support.

2. ENCOURAGE OPEN DIALOGUE ABOUT MISTAKES

In this era of rapid change and unpredictability, people are likely to make more mistakes. When they feel comfortable admitting where they went wrong, they increase the odds of doing better in the future—and that makes them feel more like Pilots than Passengers. In fact, people who feel comfortable admitting mistakes, raising questions, and learning from the past show 63% more growth in agency and optimism than those who have lower psychological safety at work.

3. ACT AS A COACH OR MENTOR, NOT JUST A BOSS

People want managers who support them in the ways that a mentor or coach might. Good coaches foster self-awareness and a growth-orientation, which helps people feel more confident that they can achieve their goals and bring about positive change. 

Mentor your team members along each step of their planning process: setting goals, thinking of multiple ways they might achieve those goals, and then quickly adapting to changes when their plans need tweaking. People who learn to identify multiple ways to accomplish their goals grow much more in agency and optimism compared to their counterparts who don’t master this key skill.

4. FOCUS ON YOUR OWN MINDSET

Managers with a Pilot mindset tend to inspire the same in their reports. In fact, those reporting to Pilot managers are almost three times as likely to be Pilots themselves. In other words, your emotions and attitudes are contagious: When you exhibit high agency and optimism, your team is likely to follow suit. 

If you think your mindset might be more like a Passenger than a Pilot, seek sources of support and empathy at work. Reflect on your own development and how you might improve your awareness of your strengths and weaknesses. How can you invest in your own learning and growth? Consider how you set goals and plan for obstacles to achieving those goals, knowing that agility and the identification of multiple pathways to reaching your goals will be key to your success.

5. BE AUTHENTIC

Authenticity builds trust. BetterUp Labs examined 25 possible predictors of trust in leadership; we found that managers’ ratings of their own authenticity strongly predicted organization-wide trust the following quarter. When you show up as your true self, open up and express your feelings, and allow people to know the “real you,” your team has the opportunity to feel more connected to you and is more likely to trust you—which is essential for fostering Pilot mindsets. 

People thrive when they have empathetic, supportive, and authentic managers. By nurturing these qualities within ourselves and our teams, we can help more people become Pilots to navigate the uncertainties of today’s world with confidence and resilience. And that is very good news, indeed.