Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

GenAI’s influence on authenticity: How we can reclaim our voice in a digital world

Here are three suggestions for maintaining authenticity and thoughtfulness in the age of GenAI.

GenAI's influence on authenticity: How we can reclaim our voice in a digital world

[Adobe Stock / Narongsag]

Profile photo of Alex Goryachev

AI, Education & Workforce Advisor · AI Transformation Solutions

The way we write is being augmented by artificial intelligence (AI). Whether we have generative AI write a cover letter for a job application or use predictive text to help us break the ice on a dating app, we express ourselves more and more with the help of these technologies.

We don’t even have to ask for that help. Predictive text is more assertive than ever. When I use apps with direct messaging and write emails, recommendations appear before I write a single word.

As easy as it is to ignore these prompts, the intrusion is disturbing for three reasons. One: We are being discouraged from thinking for ourselves. Two: These suggestions don’t come from thin air, but from human beings who programmed them, whose biases are unknown to us. Lastly: By using AI-generated writing, we lose authenticity. We are not the ones expressing our thoughts and feelings.

We know how technologies like this one work—how, once we start using it, it can be hard to stop. The software will only get better, the prompts harder to resist. So, we must understand what we lose when we put on these communication training wheels, and what we sacrifice when we take such tempting shortcuts.

THE COVER LETTER PROBLEM

It isn’t hard to understand why people use generative AI to write cover letters for job applications. The letters take time to write. Job seekers usually apply for many jobs before they get their first interview. With generative AI, all an applicant must do is upload their resume—which is likely to be “tailored,” as they say, using AI—along with the description of the job in question. The system hands over a serviceable document at once. An hour’s work is done in a minute.

Ask anyone who is on a hiring team and they will tell you the problem with this. Because everyone has access to this technology, everyone is using it, and so every cover letter and resume look much the same. Specific details concerning work experience might vary between letters, but the primary thing a hiring team looks for there is gone.

What the applications don’t give them anymore is authenticity. They get no sense of an applicant’s personality. They read what makes them right for the job, but get no impression of the individual. Hiring teams are at a loss. When everyone takes the same shortcut, no one arrives ahead of time, and they have nothing to show for the journey they refused to take. And the problem does not end there.

ALL THAT WORDS CAN DO

The way we communicate matters. What we say and write not only reflects on us, it also influences how we think. As George Orwell put it in his famous essay “Politics and the English Language”:

A man may take to drink because he feels himself to be a failure, and then fail all the more completely because he drinks. It is rather the same thing that is happening to the English language. It becomes ugly and inaccurate because our thoughts are foolish, but the slovenliness of our language makes it easier for us to have foolish thoughts. 

Because we express what’s in our minds with words, he argued, our thoughts are no better than the words we use to express them. He railed against the “invasion of one’s mind by ready-made phrases,” warning writers away from clichés and tired formulations, for they give way to tired ideas.

As I share in my keynotes, we need to be very mindful when using GenAI writing tools. “These tools not only facilitate the use of well-worn language when communicating with others, but shape our own thoughts as well. This disconnection isn’t just between us and others—it’s between us and our own thoughts. We are, essentially, letting someone else think for us, as the suggested text comes from people who don’t know us or our intended message.”

If we let someone else write for us, we allow them to think for us as well. Make no mistake about this: Predictive text allows a stranger to write on our behalf. The suggested text, again, does not come from nowhere. It comes from whoever programmed the software we use, someone who does not know us or the person we mean to address.

HOW WE THINK FOR OURSELVES

Now that AI writing is here and in everyday use, it is here to stay—that is the way of things. So, we must determine how to handle this phenomenon that will likely grow in its appeal and usage. I have suggestions:  

  • Edit Yourself. Use AI writing for initial drafts, especially for weighty documents that must look exactly right. But be an overzealous editor and rewrite sentences that don’t sound quite like you. If you don’t know how you ought to sound in writing, it is time to figure that out.
  • Write Mindfully. Take the act of writing seriously. Be thoughtful with every word you put down. It takes extra time and effort, but some things are worth it. Do not forget: You are always writing to yourself as much as to others—learning what you yourself think while informing others of the same.
  • Limit Predictive Text. Do you need suggestions for what to tell your partner or best friend in a text message? Probably not. Disable predictive text where you don’t need it. The suggestions it gives will only get cleverer and more tempting, threatening to erode your authenticity where you need it most.

Imagine someone using predictive text to write a love letter, feeding the AI his own dating app profile, followed by the profile of whomever he desires, sending the amorous missive, and hoping for the best. Most people would agree that something essential is lost there, that this individual has missed the point of dating and human interaction. Let us apply this same logic to all of our interpersonal communication. Let us speak for ourselves, and listen to ourselves, so that we can be truly authentic.