Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

Here’s why social commerce hasn’t peaked in U.S. retail yet

As we navigate e-commerce amidst the return to in-person consumerism, here’s why I believe social commerce hasn’t yet peaked in the U.S.

[Images: stokkete/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Ben Crudo

BY Benjamin Crudo

Recently, one of our clients had an ad campaign debut at the Cannes Lions International Festival of Creativity. The best part? It was an ad for “shoppable” armpits. Yes, you heard that right. 

Needless to say, it was a deodorant client who had cleverly launched a campaign in which their product could be purchased by clicking on the image of an influencer’s armpit online.

The technology behind the campaign wasn’t new. Social commerce features like shoppable posts and live shopping have been around for nearly a decade, but America hasn’t adopted them as quickly as countries like China. 

As of 2022, 84% of Chinese consumers (registration required) reported shopping on social media channels compared to 36% of U.S. consumers; additionally, live shopping only made up 2% of the U.S. e-commerce market in 2022 compared to 10% in China. 

As we navigate e-commerce amidst the return to in-person consumerism, here’s why I believe social commerce hasn’t yet peaked in the U.S.

MARKETS RESPOND TO TECHNOLOGY DIFFERENTLY

For all the e-commerce comparisons that have been made between the U.S. and China, it’s important to remember our countries are individually responding to the use of technology in a way that fits the local culture and ecosystem. 

For instance, in the U.S., we don’t have one dominant “super app” like WeChat that combines social channels, live streaming, chat, and commerce into one platform. Aside from Amazon, which dominates in e-commerce, in the U.S. our shopping habits are much more fragmented, making it harder for retailers to influence and predict consumer behavior. 

Add to that the recent backlash we’ve seen from parents after the U.S. surgeon general’s warning that social media is negatively impacting the mental health of youth, and it becomes easy to understand how a country’s adoption of tech can differ based on cultural trends and norms.

RETAILERS MERGING WITH MEDIA CHANNELS

With that said, there’s no denying the trend toward retailers becoming media channels and media channels becoming retailers. Just as the “shoppable armpit” campaign illustrated how easily an influencer’s Instagram image can be turned into a deodorant store, U.S. retailers shouldn’t ignore the potential social commerce holds. Shoppable content shortens the path a customer has to take from discovery to inspiration to consumption, increasing convenience for consumers while allowing merchants to sell more.

It’s the reason visual social platform Pinterest has committed to making shopping a core component of its product experience. Since integrating shoppable posts into the platform in 2015, 50% of Pinterest users now view the platform as a place to shop. And as the company integrates AI into its shoppable media features, it aspires to become a “digital bazaar” in the coming years.

Live shopping and shoppable media may not be used as widely in the U.S. as they are in China, but American retailers are still experimenting with how these technologies can best serve consumers as cultural trends evolve. 

DIGITAL BOUNDARIES ARE BEING TESTED

Despite the languishing of virtual reality, tech companies like Apple, which recently released its new VR headset for a whopping $3,500, are placing big bets on digitally immersive experiences. While the current price point presents a barrier to entry for many, as VR becomes more accessible, it will undoubtedly impact social commerce.

Artificial intelligence, which can analyze users’ preferences and behavior to make product recommendations, is being integrated into VR. This powerful combination offers the potential for shoppers to discover, purchase, and influence in virtual environments that mimic real life. 

Despite the accelerating pace of AI and virtual technology, however, retailers are still trying to gain a better understanding of consumers’ degree of comfort in interacting with digital environments. For example, consumers were eventually comfortable switching from shopping on desktop to shopping via mobile, but it took several years for mobile shopping to reach widespread adoption. 

PERSONALIZATION BEYOND THE SCREEN

As we enter the era of hybrid commerce, many retailers are confused about how much time and resources they should invest in digital versus in-person experiences. 

The general trend is still heading online—globally, e-commerce made up 19% of retail sales in 2022 and is expected to grow 25% by 2027. But it’s also clear consumers have missed the human connection and tangible interactions that come with shopping in real life.

A recent PWC report showed nearly 60% of consumers feel companies have lost touch with the human element of the customer experience. While the promise of technology was to connect us further, the great irony is in many ways it has done the opposite. 

That’s where tools like live shopping can be effective, particularly for digitally native brands whose sole touch point with consumers is through the screen. Products that are nuanced in their differentiation, for instance, or where the purchase price may be higher, can be better personalized through a live shopping experience that educates the online consumer more efficiently. According to Coresight Research, live shoppers are 40% less likely to return an item than other online shoppers after attending a live online event. Similar research suggests live shopping can increase sales, improve conversion rates and build stronger customer relationships online. 

FINAL THOUGHTS

The blend of digital and physical has complicated the customer journey in retail. For many retailers, hybrid shopping is new terrain and advancements in AI and social commerce trends can be hard to keep up with. It’s neither possible nor advisable to jump on every retail trend, but it is wise to focus on macro-cultural shifts and allocate a healthy portion of resources to the online experience. 


Ben Crudo is CEO of Diff Agency. A retailer-turned-technologist, Ben is an e-commerce expert helping retailers win today and tomorrow.