Top of license has been a buzzword in healthcare circles for a few decades now. It’s the idea that having team members focus on job elements that most align with their maximum credentials creates a more efficient, affordable healthcare system. For example, a doctor should spend their time making complex medical decisions, performing highly skilled procedures, or diagnosing rare diseases. Lesser-skilled tasks should be delegated, and each team member should spend the maximum amount of their time on the most complex cases.
It’s a perspective that aligns with the fee-for-service (FFS) world of healthcare—a world where every scarce moment is billable, ideally as highly billable as possible—with an emphasis on specialist procedures. Top of license in medicine is like the economic concept of comparative advantage. It is a task-oriented view where workers complete tasks they are comparatively better at, implying a highly impersonalized experience with patients moving through an assembly line, like a widget on a manufacturing line.
“Top of license” care is not what patients or physicians want, and it doesn’t drive good health outcomes.
THE VALUE OF EXPERIENCE CONTINUITY
We want to ensure that a professional with proper skills performs every service. No one wants to waste anyone’s time. But something magical happens when a patient calls, and the doctor answers. Or when a patient needs an injection performed or sutures removed, and it’s the physician who gives time and attention to do the task. These moments matter to patients; they build trust (the most important ingredient to high-quality care), and transforms the care experience.
The magic is in the continuity of the experience and the opportunity to adapt to the smallest of signals or to be as flexible as the situation requires. If a patient calls in distraught, the physician can provide care that becomes outsized and impactful because it’s just-in-time. Medicine is not deterministic like a widget produced in a factory. The fewer the barriers in the care experience and the interaction between the doctor and the patient, the better.
We’ve used service reimbursement to make doctors inaccessible, even creating a culture that glamorizes that inaccessibility. This scarcity approach has been destructive, leading to rushed, distrustful patients and burned-out, professionally dissatisfied clinicians. The good news is that technology transformations may be accelerating an end to this era.
A BETTER APPROACH THAN TOP OF LICENSE
Clinicians know that being available for what is most important to their patient (not what is most important to the fee schedule) is where the true value of the profession lies. That may be listening to stories, changing a bandage or having enough time to understand what the patient is afraid to ask. Evolving to a top of importance model fulfills these wants and needs.
Everybody wants a doctor who is present, patient, listening, and accessible. We want a medical system that provides ample time for care. I have never met a physician—especially a primary care physician—who doesn’t want more time to invest in meeting with patients and their families, while being paid fairly for that accessibility.
We are in a powerful moment of AI expansion, and we have important choices to make. AI can erase the tedious work and create new abundance so the clinician can spend more time on the patient. The hope is that the healthcare system allows clinicians to use this newfound time to go a layer deeper in the patient relationship, not just to drive more volume-based revenue. In a for-profit healthcare system, however, hope is not a plan.
A primary care physician recently said at an industry conference “With AI, we are throwing a very powerful tool at a dysfunctional system, and it has the potential to make that dysfunction worse.”
Our healthcare industry is steeped in decades of a transactional, fee-for-service mindset. In this pivotal moment, AI is colliding with the ongoing shift to value-aligned payment models, we have a rare opportunity to accelerate support for primary care—the only area of medicine where direct investment improves patient outcomes and cost. A study in Oregon found that investing $1 in primary care delivered $13 in savings by reducing emergency visits, hospitalizations, and specialty care treatment. Abundant primary care delivers better patient experience and directly impacts outcomes and costs in our healthcare system.
Many new AI technology companies are focusing on maximizing FFS billing and capturing the value of every scarce moment. This isn’t what we need. We have a responsibility to think bigger. With the proliferation of this intelligence, what wholly unexpected evolution or even revolution of our payment systems could be ahead? In a world of primary care abundance, will we no longer need to rely on dramatic and pervasive systemic payment reform to really allow primary care to flourish?
FINAL THOUGHTS
This moment of rapid transformation is giving us an opportunity to leave the scarcity mentality in healthcare policy behind. Good medicine has always been about the clinician-patient relationship. We need to seize this opportunity and move to a future that creates space for what medicine has been for thousands of years—personalized, thoughtful, and patient care—with time for the things that matter most. Clinicians, patients, and our entire healthcare system will benefit from that abundance.
Kyna Fong is the cofounder and CEO of Elation Health.