For all the progress companies claim to have made on inclusion, one workplace bias remains remarkably durable: the motherhood penalty.
While organizations have entered a new era of leadership pipelines, pay equity audits, and open discussions about well-being, motherhood continues to fundamentally shift how women are perceived in the workplace. Strong performers are suddenly viewed as less ambitious, respected leaders are seen as less available, and employees who were previously trusted to manage complex work are quietly recast as less committed once pregnancy, childbirth, or caregiving becomes visible.
This outdated thinking is now colliding with a new legal and cultural reality. The implementation of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) has exposed a growing gap between executive expectations and how work actually gets done. The law was designed to ensure reasonable accommodations for pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions, but it is also forcing employers to confront a harder truth: many workplace systems were built around rigidity, not real-time decision-making. Too many organizations still treat pregnancy-related needs as exceptions to be managed, rather than predictable workforce realities. This is exactly where legal risk begins to build.
Pregnancy is a temporary condition
In many workplaces, the first question remains: “Does this person qualify for leave?” But that is the wrong starting point. The better question is: “What does this employee need to remain employed, productive, and supported?” That distinction matters.
Federal leave laws, including the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), establish the minimum of an employer’s obligations. Even when an employee does not qualify for FMLA or has exhausted available leave, the employer should still conduct an individualized accommodation analysis. When organizations default to eligibility instead of a needs analysis, they often make inconsistent decisions that create both operational and legal exposure.
Under the PWFA, that analysis may include modified duties, reduced lifting, more frequent breaks, temporary reassignment, scheduling flexibility, telework, or light duty. However, this is where many employers get stuck. They rely on attendance rules, job descriptions, or leave policies to make decisions that should be made through a structured, interactive process. Policies are important, but they cannot substitute for judgment. When a company allows a policy to end the discussion about accommodations, it risks treating pregnancy as a problem to remove from the workplace rather than a temporary condition that can often be managed with practical, consistent adjustments.
The point is not to force pregnant employees to keep working at all costs or to push them out on leave prematurely. The point is to maintain employment wherever possible and protect the employee’s role and career trajectory. To do that effectively, employers need more than good intentions; they need clear, repeatable frameworks that guide decision-making in real time. The PWFA cannot simply be a checklist for the legal department. It must become part of how managers understand performance, staffing, and retention.
How the laws can work together
It helps to understand how the PWFA fits alongside the FMLA, a law most managers already know. Enacted in 1993, the FMLA gives eligible employees job-protected leave for serious health conditions, childbirth, and caregiving, essentially providing the right to temporarily step away from work.
The PWFA, passed in 2022 and effective in 2023, addresses a different problem: the right to stay at work with reasonable accommodations for pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical conditions. The PWFA does not replace the FMLA or serve as an update to it. Instead, it helps close a gap for employees who may not qualify for FMLA, may require more leave time than allowable under FMLA, or may not need leave at all but do need temporary adjustments to keep working.
In practice, the two laws can work together. An employee may use PWFA accommodations to remain on the job during pregnancy and then use FMLA leave to recover after childbirth. Treating them as interchangeable, or assuming leave is the only answer once someone is pregnant, is where employers can miss an important opportunity to support employees effectively and make stronger, more informed workforce decisions.
Create a return-to-work plan
Managers often make assumptions that can quietly derail women’s careers. Some assumptions are well-intentioned, while others are rooted in outdated beliefs about commitment, ambition, and the role of working mothers. A manager may decide that a pregnant employee should not be considered for a challenging stretch assignment. A senior leader may assume a new mother no longer wants a travel-heavy role. In some cases, these decisions are framed as supportive. In others, they reflect underlying biases about priorities and performance. A team may shift important client opportunities elsewhere without ever having a direct conversation with the new mother.
Regardless of intent, when decisions are made without input from the employee, organizations risk losing talent. True equity requires a structured, interactive dialogue between the manager and employee. Managers should be trained to ask what support is needed, clarify the role’s essential functions, explore temporary adjustments, and document the process. Managers should also understand that accommodation is not a favor and flexibility is not a concession. It is part of building a workplace that can retain talent through predictable life events.
Managers often neglect to create a process for a new mother’s return to the workplace. For too many women, maternity leave functions as a quiet exit ramp from the leadership track, because organizations are not intentional about how they manage their transition back. When a mother returns to work, her manager often takes a “wait-and-see” approach, making assumptions about her capacity before her performance is even re-established.
A more effective approach is to treat return to work as a strategic transition. That means establishing clear communication before leave begins, confirming how major projects will be handled during the leave period, identifying a point of contact during leave, and creating a re- entry plan that outlines workload, expectations, and near-term priorities. There should also be ongoing conversations about long-term growth to ensure the employee’s career trajectory is not quietly altered.
Final thoughts
Ultimately, what matters most is whether an employer can help new mothers remain employed, productive, and supported in the workplace. Organizations that want to reduce legal risk and retain talent need to move beyond reactive decision-making and build processes that are consistent, defensible, and grounded in real-world application.
For employers who are unsure where to start, bringing in a dedicated accommodations and leave compliance expert can help move beyond generic policies and toward systems that work across accommodations, leave, and return to work.
At its core, this is not just about legal compliance. It is about whether your organization is equipped to make sound decisions when it matters most.
Rachel Shaw is president of Rachel Shaw Inc.