I come from a family of reporters. I respect the hell out of them. Their job is tough. They are overworked, underpaid, and some of the smartest people I’ve ever met.
But as a PR professional, I’ve noticed that the relationship between PR people and reporters feels more strained than ever before. Here’s just one example of a nasty exchange between a reporter and PR person. And then there’s this one: a reporter making fun of a PR person for calling a newsroom with a pitch.
Reporters complain about PR folks, and PR folks get frustrated with reporters. Both professions have their outliers, but most reporters and PR professionals just want to tell compelling stories featuring diverse spokespeople. When our relationship is strong, we both have a higher rate of success. So how do we change a dysfunctional relationship into one where we are on the same team?
According to the Q4 2022 Propel Media Barometer study, reporters respond to roughly 3% of the pitches they receive. PR teams are hustling their asses off for that 3%. Sure, we can write off some of the lack of responses to bad pitch writing, but not all 97%!
So, here’s what I and others in the PR industry ask from reporters so that we can best work together:
PUBLICLY SHARE SPECIFICS ABOUT WHAT YOU DO AND DO NOT COVER
PR people are often dragged for not knowing what reporters cover and for incorrectly pitching them. And I know every reporter is probably thinking, “What I cover isn’t a secret; all stories I’ve ever written are public.”
But that doesn’t mean there isn’t room for incorrect assumptions. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve pitched a reporter after reading their articles and doing my homework, and truly believing it’s something they will cover—only for them to angrily tell me it’s not a fit. I can’t possibly know from reading a journalist’s coverage on VC-funded tech companies that they will not cover my VC-funded tech company because it isn’t based in San Francisco, founded by a female, valued at $1 billion, or…insert any other stipulations that are not explicitly stated.
PR professionals work with hundreds of different people every week, each with their own set of unique guidelines and preferences that we are expected to juggle and understand. We’re bound to get it wrong sometimes. If we do, sincere apologies, but (most of us) are just doing our best.
A SIMPLE “I WILL NOT BE COVERING THIS” WILL SUFFICE
Surely, a one-second reply isn’t too much to ask. We don’t need pleasantries. We don’t even need to know why (although it’s always appreciated when a reporter tells us). We will stop following up, I promise.
But a lack of response makes it hard to report back to our client. A specific journalist might be our client’s dream publication and ideal reporter, and we may have been planning our outreach for weeks as part of a greater PR strategy. There’s a lot riding on a reporter’s response. So, when our client asks, “Have you heard back?” and we say no, it gives them hope. They say things like, “Have you tried calling?” and “Please reach out again” or “What if you DM them on Twitter?” If a reporter is getting a lot of follow-ups from a PR person, it’s often because we’re hoping for any response—even if it’s a no—that will assuage our client.
Reporters like Fast Company’s Lydia Dishman have mastered this. Dishman described on a podcast how she responds to every single pitch she receives—even the ones she doesn’t plan to cover. Her language is templated, which means it’s a simple copy/paste. But trust me, PRs do not care that a response is templated—we appreciate being able to stop following up as much as you do, and we can tell our client, “Lydia Dishman has passed and will not be covering this.”
THE FINAL WORD
I can acknowledge how hard a reporter’s job is, but I would also argue that their work is benefited by a partnership with PR professionals. By connecting them with industry experts and thought leaders, PR people provide reporters with a compelling and fresh perspective for their story—one they might not have known about otherwise. There’s a lot of pressure on reporters right now to highlight diverse voices and unique insights. PR people can help accomplish this.
As we move into 2023, here’s my ask of all PR professionals: do the homework, never use a “spray and pray” approach, only pitch when you have a compelling story, and say thank you to the many reporters who treat us like colleagues.
Remember: PR professionals and reporters all have the same goal: to do good work and tell great stories.
Shannon Tucker is the Vice President at Next PR, a national tech PR agency. She lives in Denver.