Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to better protect accounts from bot intruders

The battle against sophisticated bots is never-ending, but with the right ATO prevention approach, you can better secure your business from these digital threats.

[Image: Adobe Stock / Murrstock]

Profile photo of Benjamin Fabre

The safety of customer data is very much at risk despite prodigious investments in cybersecurity. This begs the question: How is that possible? In April 2022, General Motors customer accounts suffered a massive account takeover (ATO) attack. Affected users watched as their GM store credits were drained or emptied. Even worse, General Motors’ site wasn’t even hacked; the credentials were stolen from other sites and used to gain access to GM accounts. 

In this digital era, all businesses are at risk of data breaches. In 2021, Facebook suffered a massive data breach that exposed the personally identifiable information (PII) of over 550 million users. Similarly, in 2020, a massive Twitter data dump posed another threat to large-scale account takeovers. ATO attacks are rising and businesses should be worried. 

WHY ARE ATO ATTACKS ONE OF THE CHIEF CONCERNS AMONG SECURITY PROFESSIONALS IN 2023?

Credential stuffing and account takeover attacks form a cyclical pattern. The data exposed in credential stuffing attacks on other sites are invariably used for account takeovers elsewhere. During ATO attacks, owners are locked out of their accounts while malicious actors carry out fraudulent transactions. 

For any business with a web presence and/or mobile app, automated account takeover breaches pose a serious threat. The technology behind these fraud tactics is rapidly advancing, with sophisticated bots capable of closely mimicking human actions. According to recent estimates, 22% of U.S. adults have already suffered takeovers, and they are becoming increasingly prevalent; ATO attacks increased 307% between 2019 and 2021. Social media account takeovers get wider publicity, but losses from financial account takeovers are typically higher, with average losses of around $12,000 per incident. 

Part of the reason ATO attacks continue to be so threatening is because password reuse is extremely pervasive (registration required). We know the risks of reusing passwords, yet a recent survey showed nearly 65% of people still reuse passwords across multiple sites. 

WHY BUSINESSES MUST PREVENT ATO ATTACKS AT ALL COSTS

A website attack is like a ship running into an iceberg; ATO attacks are the breaches in the hull that sunk the Titanic. These attacks are causing more risk and damage than ever, and to successfully navigate away from the impending wreck, businesses must brace themselves. 

Here are a few ways ATO attacks can compromise a business’s integrity:

• Chargebacks from fraudulent card use: Loss of funds from these transactions can rise quickly, with the potential to reach damaging levels.

• Loss of time and resources: Faced with fraudulent attacks, businesses are wasting time and resources investigating and manually blocking malicious activity.

• User abandonment from poor site/app experience: Data breaches damage a brand’s reputation, leading to a loss of trust from frustrated users. 

• Targeted information theft: Stolen personal information, like social security numbers, driver’s licenses, and financial data, can be sold or used for other attacks. 

• Account balance theft: Threat actors steal stored value, credit and/or money from your customers, resulting in customer reimbursements from unauthorized transactions.

WHY ARE CURRENT ATO PREVENTION METHODS PROVING INEFFECTIVE?

Bad actors can deploy numerous tactics to compromise user accounts. Popular methods include malware, phishing, credential stuffing, and brute force attacks. Most current preventative solutions fail to offer comprehensive protection from various threats. 

Attacker tools and techniques have evolved beyond generalized providers’ basic defense tools. What looks like the same types of attacks are now more sophisticated in avoiding detection. Think of it this way: Are you still relying on a manual lookout technique using binoculars in the crow’s nest? Or are you implementing advanced radar detection and alerting systems? Without advanced detection measures, your system can be fooled by sophisticated bots that look like humans or take hybrid approaches (CAPTCHA farms). More importantly, basic solutions often fail to detect sophisticated bots with advanced techniques that have replaced outdated approaches like brute force attacks. 

These attacks come from highly disruptive IP addresses instead of simple/concentrated IPs. When you use an overly closed approach that leads to overusing CAPTCHA, it disrupts the user experience and creates more false positives that are incapable of improving over time. Traditional bot solutions from content delivery network (CDN) vendors are like gas station sushi. Sure, you could eat it, but it’ll likely lead to more problems in the near future. 

HOW CAN BUSINESSES PROTECT THEMSELVES FROM ATO ATTACKS IN A FOOLPROOF WAY?

In some cases, brute force tactics can be repelled with basic web application security measures. But as long as users reuse passwords, businesses remain vulnerable to credential stuffing and ATO attacks. Getting users/customers involved in protection is key to ATO prevention. 

This means repeatedly reminding users not to recycle old passwords, strengthen existing passwords, change them periodically, implement a password manager tool, and use multi-factor or risk-based authentication. To ensure adequate security, you also must utilize a breached credentials database. This kind of database can be used to compare new and existing user data, such as usernames and passwords, to detect any matches.

The best way to detect and protect against sophisticated ATO attacks is to level up your defenses. This requires a comprehensive bot and online fraud protection solution that continuously evaluates trillions of client-side and server-side signals from end-user interactions, which tracks small signals on your website or app and interrogates every request in real time. Suspicious activity from automated bots testing stolen credentials at scale, sophisticated bots masquerading as human users, and actual humans exfiltrating customer data can be identified and blocked immediately without manual intervention.

The battle against sophisticated bots is never-ending, but with the right ATO prevention approach, you can better secure your business from these digital threats. Such approaches not only reduce exposure to fraud attempts but also drastically cut down investigation time and initial steps of remediation. It’s essential to equip yourself with an effective defense mechanism (paywall) to protect your business from advanced bots attempting to mimic human behavior. With the right strategy, you can take charge of this incessant fight and help make ATO attacks a thing of the past.


Benjamin Fabre is the co-founder and Chief Executive Officer of DataDome.