Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to build a third-party commerce marketplace like you’ve done it before

There’s no better way to learn how to launch and effectively run a third-party marketplace than by simply jumping in and doing it.

Shopping app on a phone

[Images: Monster Ztudio/Adobe Stock]

Profile photo of Barry Fiske

CXO, Global Experience & Innovation · Merkle

If you’re considering standing up an e-commerce marketplace, no doubt you’ve got a good plan in place. You’ve thought about how to introduce it to the market, how to make it a seamless and frictionless shopping experience, and how to use it to diversify your supply of products, so you’re never out of stock and unable to serve your customers. That’s great. 

But here’s the thing. I guarantee there are things you’re overlooking. Because when I talk to any leader who has stood up a marketplace recently, that’s what they always say: There are always things they wish they had known better before they started. This is usually because there are benefits to marketplaces that go far beyond the basics, and they always wish they had better planned to take advantage of them.

Well, good news. I didn’t just talk to these leaders—I made a list.

Here are five pieces of advice for leaders planning the design and launch of their own marketplace. Follow this advice to take advantage of everything your marketplace can provide your business.

1. DESIGN FOR EVEN MORE TRAFFIC THAN YOU THINK 

Traffic? That’s not a surprise, right? In many ways, driving more traffic is the reason you’re doing a marketplace. But when I talk with leaders, universally they tell me they’re surprised by exactly how much the traffic to their website increases. It’s a lot, and you really need to plan for it.

Think through how you’re going to handle this surge in customers and activity. Is your infrastructure really ready to handle the load? Is your team really ready to capture all this additional customer data? Before you press go, double-check that you’re prepared for the rush or you might get overrun.

2. PLAN, PLAN, PLAN HOW YOU’RE GOING TO USE ALL THIS DATA

With a marketplace, you’re going to be offering your customers products and services far beyond what your company traditionally sells. That means you’ll be learning about your customers’ needs and behavior in parts of the shopping journey far beyond what your business was ever privy to before.

Are you ready to use this new intelligence to improve the way you cross-sell? How will you leverage this expanded understanding of your customers’ needs to create entirely new products and services?

Before you launch, make sure you have a comprehensive plan to use your newfound wealth of data to design an even more valuable customer experience and become an even more valuable partner to your customers.

3. JOIN THE LIFETIME VALUE REVOLUTION WITH A MODERN LOYALTY PROGRAM

If you couple your marketplace with a smart loyalty program, you’re not just selling a wider range of products. You’re giving your customers more opportunities to earn loyalty points than ever before. Make sure your loyalty program is up to the challenge. 

How are you registering these new customers in your program? How are you using loyalty incentives to drive the exploration of your new product offerings? How are you upgrading your rewards to really create a high lifetime value customer who will consistently come to you to satisfy all their needs? 

A great loyalty program coupled with your new marketplace is a great way to make sure you become the one-stop shop in your industry.

4. MAKE YOUR MARKETPLACE THE TIPPING POINT FOR DIGITAL BUSINESS TRANSFORMATION 

When I talk with leaders who have launched a marketplace, they tell me that introducing all these new products with all of their related content into their digital ecosystem was an eye-opening experience for executives across their companies. It can also be the moment everyone’s been waiting for. Don’t miss your chance. 

Use your marketplace project to trigger larger, deeper digital business conversations. This is your opportunity to get senior leadership to see the big picture and to finally “green light” those transformational projects that could fundamentally change how your company does business and unlock a new level of growth. With a bit of planning, your marketplace project can be the initiative that brings all the digital projects across your company together and unites them into a single mission.

5. YOU’RE NEVER COMPLETELY READY—JUST BEGIN

Designing, launching, and managing a marketplace isn’t fast, simple, or easy. It’s a big project. No amount of planning is ever going to answer every question or identify every challenge ahead of time. But what I hear time and time again when I talk with leaders now running their own marketplaces is: That’s OK. 

They tell me there’s no better way to learn how to launch and effectively run a third-party marketplace than by simply jumping in and doing it. The experience itself is the teacher. So, expect some growing pains and build some flexibility into your approach—but stay confident that over time, your team will figure out the path and process that works best for you. 

The other thing marketplace leaders always say is this: If they knew then what they know now, they would have launched their marketplace much sooner. So do it! Just dive in. Plan, design, and build your marketplace to work for your specific customers and business the best you can.

I hope the tips above help answer some questions, but don’t worry about having everything figured out before you begin. The lesson is: Just start your commerce marketplace journey and enjoy the ride.


Barry Fiske leads Experience Creative & Innovation for Merkle in the Americas. He is also host of the What Bubbles Up creativity podcast.