If recent job market news feels like a case study in contradictions, you’re not alone. The Washington Post writes that the country is facing “the largest labor shortage in its history.” Meanwhile, The New York Times reports a hiring slump, with employers cutting 23,000 jobs in July.
Why the discrepancy? Because these generalizations ignore differences at the occupational and geographic level. A general business degree may not have the value it once did, but there is enormous opportunity in the jobs our communities desperately need most: teachers, healthcare workers, and mental health professionals.
By 2038, the Bureau of Health Workforce expects a nationwide shortage of nearly 110,000 registered nurses, 100,000 mental health counselors, and 136,000 psychologists. Other studies find occupational therapists, K-12 teachers, and school counselors are also in high demand, particularly in certain regions.
That leaves many wondering: Why aren’t colleges doing more to train the workforce for these careers?
HIGHER EDUCATION CAN’T ABSORB THE BURDEN ALONE
Universities aren’t oblivious to the demand, but the economic and logistical realities of offering these high-demand degrees tie the hands of many university administrators. Starting up these highly regulated, licensure-based programs is expensive. For example, it took a $15 million gift for Cal State Monterey Bay to expand its nursing education, funding new degree programs, faculty hiring, lab renovations and accreditation costs.
Many programs already operate on single-digit margins, and facilities alone can represent over 16% of program costs. Most institutions lack the capital to grow capacity as federal student loan limits put additional pressure on affordability. Even if they build it, can students afford to come?
As a member of the Department of Education’s Reimagining and Improving Student Education (RISE) Committee, I’ve seen this tension firsthand. The new federal loan caps aim to discipline tuition pricing and end unsustainable borrowing, but many degrees in critical workforce shortage areas are subject to the caps. Lower loan ceilings only work if institutions can lower delivery costs.
Institutions need collaboration from the accreditation side. Many specialty accreditation standards are equally unsustainable, sometimes imposing archaic requirements that inflate costs, such as curriculum hours, headcount, and in-person learning that haven’t kept pace with technology or workforce realities.
Expecting institutions to produce more high-demand practitioners while limiting tuition financing and maintaining expensive and sometimes outdated requirements creates a stalemate. Higher ed cannot solve this alone. We need to redesign the system around a shared goal: getting more qualified professionals into the field without sacrificing quality.
These five steps can get us there.
1. MODERNIZE ACCREDITATION STANDARDS WITHOUT LOWERING THE BAR
It’s time to ask whether rules designed for yesterday’s classroom meet tomorrow’s workforce needs, and to leverage technology to meet those needs more efficiently without weakening quality.
The RISE Committee’s work effectively lowered the price ceiling, but accreditation reform now needs to help lower the cost floor. Reducing unnecessary in-person requirements and modernizing rigid ratios would allow instructors to reach more students through video-based instruction and hybrid learning. When done well, these changes have been shown to keep quality high while expanding access and capacity, reducing faculty workload by one-third and cutting program costs by as much as 40%.
2. EXPAND THE LEARNING FOOTPRINT
Professional education doesn’t have to happen exclusively inside a university. Rather than measure program quality based on where learning occurs, let’s measure it by competency, licensure, and student outcomes.
Apprenticeships that provide hands-on experience while earning degree credit can lower time and cost barriers. Students can earn while they learn, spend less time in higher-cost campus facilities, and enter the workforce faster, armed with the skills employers need.
3. INVOLVE EMPLOYERS AND ACCREDITORS AS PROGRAM CO-DESIGNERS
Partnering with employers and specialty accreditors on curriculum ensures programs meet real-world conditions. Rather than treating them as downstream customers and auditors, bring them into the process.
This is especially relevant to artificial intelligence usage. Colleges should teach profession-specific application, not generic AI literacy as a stand-alone skill. For a marriage and family therapy student, that means learning where AI is useful, where it isn’t, and how to use it ethically and responsibly. Employers can help define those parameters in partnership with accreditors based on what’s happening on the ground.
4. DEVELOP AN EVIDENCE ENGINE
Higher education can counter the bleak job market narrative with data-driven evidence. Institutions can publicize workforce demand statistics alongside their graduation and licensure rates, employment outcomes, case studies, and salary data in those fields.
At Alliant University, eight of our programs align with occupations facing major workforce shortages. We highlight our K-12 teacher certification graduate employment rates and over 1,200 placement partnerships with clinics, hospitals, and school districts. For students considering a nursing degree, we point to our 100% first-time National Council Licensure Examination (NCLEX) pass rate for our first nursing cohort. Demonstrating the real-world value of a licensed professional degree proves outcomes to both prospects and employers.
WORKFORCE SHORTAGES DEMAND A SHARED SOLUTION
Declaring a workforce crisis while making it unnecessarily difficult and expensive to educate people for those professions is an obvious dead end. Colleges can’t reduce startup costs, modernize accreditation standards, expand tuition financing, or create hiring pathways alone.
Workforce capacity must be addressed as a shared system. The federal conversation has already begun. Now, the Department of Education’s Accreditation, Innovation, and Modernization Committee must continue the RISE Committee’s work, addressing accreditation hurdles and reconsidering professional loan limits in fields facing critical shortages.
Graduate-level institutions that offer programs with specialty or program accreditation cannot unilaterally lower tuition. Their largest cost drivers are not institutional choices, but infrastructure and mandates baked into the standards of specialty and programmatic accreditors. Many of these standards are needed for high-quality education, yet several need review and revision. A range of standards could be revised to leverage today’s tools and technologies, reduce delivery costs, and lower tuition rates for students.
Higher education, accreditors, policymakers, and employers must work together to lower financial barriers without lowering standards, expand access without sacrificing quality, and build programs to address community needs. The question is: Are they willing to let go of status quo thinking and move quickly and creatively to meet our communities’ modern needs?
Andy Vaughn, EdD, is president and CEO of Alliant University.