Studies on the value of CX continue to stack up. McKinsey’s global research found that “improving the customer experience can do far more to drive profitable growth than raising advertising spending or lowering prices.” According to The Temkin Group, “companies that earn $1 billion annually can expect to earn, on average, an additional $700 million within three years of investing in customer experience.” Executives also agree with the imperative; 84% of CEOs “believe empathy drives better business outcomes,” according to the 2021 State of Workplace Empathy, an annual study by BusinessSolver.
There has been a focus on customer experience in call centers and in digital transformation, but what about the one-to-one experience in businesses’ physical spaces? In a world increasingly using digital channels for convenience and cost, CX experiences in physical locations may appear to have a smaller role. Yet, people in physical locations—think branch managers, insurance agents, investment advisors, mortgage officers, health care providers, or restaurant and retail managers—directly impact customer experience and their perceptions of a brand. The millions of customer interactions they manage across hundreds of branches or locations each year can also be the hardest to control.
When those experiences are outstanding, they become legendary and so do the companies attached to them. Think of Chewy, where an employee sent flowers to a bereaved pet parent, or the Nordstrom employee who famously accepted the return of tires. Examples are easier to find in retail, which has been earlier to embrace one-to-one CX than industries that historically lag, like financial services and health care. I believe opportunities await companies that create a customer-obsessed culture in their physical channels as well.
DRIVEN BY EMPATHY
Caring about humans, solving their problems, and going above and beyond to delight them is rooted in empathy, which humans are hard-wired for. Though it is critically important, empathy has declined significantly. Jamil Zaki, associate professor of psychology at Stanford University and director of the Stanford Social Neuroscience Laboratory, reported on the significant drop in empathy over time in America. Comparing self-reported empathy scores from roughly 14,000 students over 30 years, researchers found almost 75% of students in 2009 rated themselves as less empathetic than students in 1979.
ACTING ON EMPATHY
Where UX teams carefully design digital experiences that are experienced by millions of customers, one-to-one interactions in the physical channel pose challenges because they can’t be scripted. Each situation is often unique and requires responding on the fly. On top of that, there are thousands of people handling interactions, creating the challenge of consistency at scale.
Ironically, your expertise can become your liability. The longer you work in a role, the more you are keenly aware of what you can’t do when it comes to everything from policies to procedures. In accepting this, your ability to find the open spaces of what you can do—your available freedoms—may atrophy.
Many years in a role can also distance you from what it’s like to be the customer. Does a long-time financial services manager remember how it feels to be scared to invest for the first time? Does a mortgage banker remember that behind the mortgage is someone envisioning the life they will build in their new home?
HOW TO DESIGN WINNING EXPERIENCES IN YOUR PHYSICAL CHANNEL
When it comes to inspiring winning experiences in physical spaces, one key is to operationalize empathy as a new way of thinking and working, rather than treating it like a one-time effort. Empathy can ignite curiosity, surface root causes, and reveal new solutions. It may also inspire you to want to help. I’ve found employee empathy has a direct effect on customer satisfaction and loyalty during customer interactions.
To engage this channel, ignite empathy and give employees a sense of agency with playbooks instead of rulebooks to make empathetic experiences easier to deliver in the moment. Then, back your new way of thinking and working with processes that put training into regular practice throughout locations to ensure impact at scale.
The design of the physical channel becomes even more important to the customer experience. As the theater for your customers’ experiences, physical spaces should be designed with the customer experience in mind. I once visited a 24/7 emergency vet care center that had just designed a new building. This building included end-of-life rooms with exit doors that let grieving pet parents leave the building without having to go back out through the lobby. Something like this might seem trivial unless you understand the customer and the intensity of a pet owner’s pain in that moment.
Last, companies can win the one-to-one CX experience by knowing their customers’ journeys and designing the moments that matter proactively. Take for example a bank merger, a common experience. A study by Deloitte found that 17% “of customers whose banks had been acquired made the decision to move at least one of their accounts to another financial institution. Nearly two-thirds of those who had switched did so immediately, within one month of a merger’s announcement.” How could designing a welcome experience turn friction into delight and retain valuable customers?
Airbnb co-founder and CEO Brian Chesky revealed his approach to winning customer experiences. He starts by identifying what five-star service would be like, and then progressively asks how to amp up the service until reaching an 11-star experience. While an 11-star solution might not be feasible, it can push your mental model to go further in delighting customers and creating legendary experiences.
I believe businesses that define the role of their physical channel and make the most of it with intention and training are poised to win big.
Gretchen Goffe is the CEO and Founder of DTLiveLAB, a leader in the people part of creating customer-obsessed organizations at scale.