Skip to content
Fast Company Executive Board

The Fast Company Executive Board is a private, fee-based network of influential leaders, experts, executives, and entrepreneurs who share their insights with our audience.

How to scale with your values intact

How mission-driven brands keep environmental values built into decision-making at every stage.

[Photo: Getty Images]

Profile photo of Kate Williams

CEO · 1% for the Planet

Standing for something requires courage, clarity, and hard work. But giving up on values? It’s apparently much easier, as business headlines have been reporting one corporate giant after another shirking previously upheld values and backing away from commitments.

Consumers saw Target roll back DEI commitments, mega-brands walk back climate goals, and Unilever acquire Ben & Jerry’s and continue to attempt to strip away the very mission that defined it.  

This trend of the biggest names in business retreating—of getting spineless and short-sighted—has cost more than the commitments ever would have. Target and Magnum stock fell in the aftermath. Meanwhile, companies that hold the line are seeing the opposite: A 2023 study by Jump Associates found that purpose-driven companies deliver market returns up to five times greater than the S&P 500 over a 20-year period.

You may think it’s because they’re the most noble or idealistic, but it’s about being structurally disciplined. These forward-looking brands have made strategic decisions like committing to an annual certification, parting ways with an investor who just didn’t get it, or making their commitments legally binding within their governance structure.

In a dozen years leading the 1% for the Planet network of businesses, I’ve seen companies across industries prove that values can scale with you. Here’s what I’ve seen work best.

BE PREPARED FOR VALUES LANDMINES

Organizations rarely lose their values in one big, pivotal decision. It happens in a series of chronic, smaller decisions that steer your company further from your north star.  Knowing where the landmines are hidden will help you avoid them. The breakdown often occurs at these points:

  • During rapid growth, especially if values aren’t built into hiring and operations from the start.
  • When ESG/CSR efforts lack the credibility of third-party accountability.
  • Being overly reactive to external factors, like election cycles, trends, or pricing pressure.
  • When new investors enter the picture with an agenda of their own.
  • Following acquisition or ownership changes.

Of these, acquisition is a particularly important inflection point. You reached this milestone because consumers believed in your brand, and preserving the reasons why is where it’s easy to stumble. One fast-growing CPG brand recently came to 1% for the Planet facing exactly this reason. They were acquired by a much larger corporation, its leadership team remained committed to the mission that built the brand, and they turned to third-party certification as a trusted seal that would keep communicating where the brand stands even under new ownership.

FOCUS ON DURABILITY

If commitments and goals can crack at the first sign of pressure, they probably weren’t so solid in the first place. Here’s how to ensure they’re durable.

1. Decide what is fixed and what’s flexible: Getting clear on this up-front makes it easier to make the right call when things come up. For 1% for the Planet members, directing 1% of annual revenue to environmental solutions is fixed, but whether they do that through cash, employee volunteering, or in-kind support is flexible.

Clean laundry detergent brand Earth Breeze approaches how it meets (or even exceeds) its 1% commitment differently depending on the year, whether that’s giving four times the required 1% in 2025, or donating laundry detergent products to shelters—with more than $300 million worth given in total.

This pre-determined clarity about what’s set in stone can make you more confident and compelling to investors. In conversation with an investor who suggested she drop 1% for the Planet certification, the founder of a large agency in our network came in strong and straightforward, saying, “1% for the Planet is non-negotiable.” She got the investment.

2. Operationalize commitments across the company: Values survive growth when they become part of your business architecture. Making the planet a line item in your budget, right alongside other essential assets like payroll or office space, is square one. From there, consider where impact sits in your org chart. Which reporting line(s) will best set this team up for success?

3. Embed values into your governance: This might look like legally giving the Earth a seat on your board, so it is part of every vote and decision, or becoming a public benefit corporation so you’re legally obligated to consider your impact on the planet. For the privately held public benefit corporation Cotopaxi, this legal structure keeps sustainability and social impact built into core business strategy.

Any company can take inspiration from public benefit corporations and develop impact metrics that leadership reports on at every board meeting. This will help you stay grounded in the interwoven nature of business success and your impact on the world.

4. Leverage your environmental commitments as the competitive advantage they are: In a recent Impact Report, haircare brand Innersense Organic Beauty noted that its 1% for the Planet certification—through which it has directed more than $2 million to environmental solutions—is directly tied to the brand’s growth.

If you have authentic, verified commitments, celebrate them on your packaging, retail displays, website, and marketing channels to earn trust from consumers. Consumers are looking for the signal: 74% of millennials believe corporations and governments share responsibility for environmental sustainability, and brands that lean into that message are the ones earning their loyalty.

The research on the business case is just as strong. A meta-analysis of more than 1,100 peer-reviewed studies by NYU Stern and Rockefeller Asset Management found a positive relationship between ESG performance and financial performance in 58% of cases, and a neutral one in another 13%—meaning only 8% found a negative relationship. And it’s a long game: The data shows ESG’s financial upside becomes stronger the longer a company sticks with it.

Kate Williams is the CEO of 1% for the Planet.